›

Did you hate or love Lilly

Tomi021Tomi021
edited June 2013 in The Walking Dead
Ok as requested by Bioshock Infinite WD i made this poll :D Im personally neutral on this one since i didnt hate her that much even tough she killed DOUG we were best friends . But she wanted to shoot Ben wich i was okay with at the time to be honest . But if she tryed to shoot ben now i would be mad.
Of course tough TEAM KENNY :D

Comments

  • TeamKennyAlwaysTeamKennyAlways
    edited June 2013
    I was on Kenny side on the other poll so I hate Lilly. I felt sorry for her when Kenny (when I say Kenny I mean me and Kenny) killed Larry but she shot Carley. So I vote I hate Lilly. Yes first person to reply!
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited June 2013
    I felt somewhat sorry for Lilly but I started hating back in Episode 2, the hate increased in Episode 3 but I thought she could be trusted, show's what I know about people, because of her I will never trust anyone unless they prove themselves, which is a miracle that I liked Christa and Omid.
  • zev_zevzev_zev
    edited June 2013
    Yes, I love her! Awesome character, story is not such a complete without her. I was try to support her as it was possible( in my second walkthrough). You can call me a bustard, but I don't giving a fuck.
  • DildorDildor
    edited June 2013
    Lilly was an awesome character, it's too bad that I hate her and never want to see her again for what she did.
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited June 2013
    I do not care that you like Lilly, I will say she did add a lot to the game and the quality may have been less without her and she was well written but hay it's all opinion.
  • Rock114Rock114
    edited June 2013
    I'm neutral. I hated her at first, then after I helped Kenny in the met locker I felt really sorry for her, so I tried to be nice. Then she murdered Carley, and tried to spill my secret to everyone (although I'd already told everyone beforehand). I don't think she's particularly a bad person (or used to be, at any rate). She went over the edge after her father's death, which I viewed as necessary at the time. I probably would have liked her more if she hadn't killed Carley for insulting her. Shooting at me or Kenny is fine, because of what we did, but not Carley.
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited June 2013
    This is not on topic but I have to add that Carley's death and Lee's death show's Telltale has more balls then AMC, if Telltale wrote the show then Daryl would be dead right now, just goes to show how good the game is.
  • CarScarCarScar
    edited June 2013
    I don't know where I stand with Lilly. After episode two I was more so on Lilly's team because Kenny started to act like a complete fucking monster. Then she shot Carley. I don't know. She's a good character, a bitch a lot of the time but in episode three she really had some cool / meaningful / really sincere dialogue with Lee.
    Bioshock Infinite WD wrote: »
    This is not on topic but I have to add that Carley's death and Lee's death show's Telltale has more balls then AMC, if Telltale wrote the show then Daryl would be dead right now, just goes to show how good the game is.
    Sorry to derail the thread with more off-topic stuff, but yeah, that's something I noted too. Especially in season three, they intentionally killed off all the characters that would result in the least amount of anger from the fans:

    "Everyone really hates Lori, so let's kill her off to make the fans happy! Lets throw in Andrea too, nobody likes her. Eh, people are iffy with Merle so let's get 'em in there as well! ... Fuck it, let's also toss Axel / T-Dog in as well for good measures. No one cares about them!"

    Even before that, in previous seasons, they haven't really gotten the right feeling that the comics has. They killed Shane who was suppose to be dead back in the first season, they killed Dale but Hershel has thus morphed into his exact clone so nothing was lost, and finally they killed the nonexistant / pity character that is Jacqui offhandedly. The show needs to step it up and start killing fan favorites, e.g. Glenn or Daryl. They're doing a disservice to the comics. The only ballsy thing they did was kill Sophia.

    The game is great though. Killing off fan favorite Carley, the sudden department of the main character Lilly, murdering a child and a mother back-to-back... They really captured that dark feeling and "nobody is safe" vibe that The Walking Dead is all about.
  • RichWalk23RichWalk23
    edited June 2013
    I'm neutral towards Lilly, but because I'm biased towards Kenny, I'm more sympathetic towards her than him.

    Unlike Kenny, Lilly didn't hold petty grudges against me should I disagree with her and she saved my life more times than him. She came across more genuine and honest, and she had considered making difficult choices so others wouldn't have to.

    Of course that was until Episode 3 changed everything, given the 'Lilly shoots Carley/Doug' scenario, and I left her beind seeing how she's a liability to have around. Still I understand why she completely lost it, what's with the murder of her father and no one seemed to cared because they didn't like him one bit, and having to live with the one who did it who showed little remorse.

    In the end I pity Lilly more than I hate her.
  • XarneXarne
    edited June 2013
    Too hard to like her- she had an even less forgiving nature that Kenny when it came to picking sides. She's always like 'poor me, its so hard to lead, such responsibility' but she wasnt the leader, not according to Kenny anyway.
  • TeamKennyAlwaysTeamKennyAlways
    edited June 2013
    Can I ask a question. I'm new to the forum so I was wondering how to make a poll. I'm really dumb so it's probably the easiest thing to do. I would really appreciate the help.
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited June 2013
    I honestly do not know either which is why I do not make many threads, it's kind of dumb but I would like to know also.
  • zev_zevzev_zev
    edited June 2013
    TeamKennyAlways wrote: »
    Can I ask a question. I'm new to the forum so I was wondering how to make a poll. I'm really dumb so it's probably the easiest thing to do. I would really appreciate the help.

    Just click on "Yes, post a poll with this thread" and then customize your poll.
  • TeamKennyAlwaysTeamKennyAlways
    edited June 2013
    zev_zev wrote: »
    Just click on "Yes, post a poll with this thread" and then customize your poll.
    Thanks
  • MornaiMornai
    edited June 2013
    Didn't like Lilly from the start. It only deteriorated from there... she always wants to be the leader, then always complains about how difficult it is and how people aren't following her orders, but doesn't want anyone else to take charge. Anyone who would let a child die just because they're a stranger and "could be dangerous" is no friend of mine.

    After the death of Larry it only got worse. She clung to the motor inn even though we had clearly exhausted the entire area of supplies, and she shot down any attempt at leaving. Then the final straw was drawn...she murders a group member in cold blood, with little to nothing to support her wild accusations. She doesn't apologize, and still tries to turn it around by saying what she did was right. If you're a kind enough soul to bring this wretch with you after that(i was not) she steals our last method of transportation(and with it any supplies we may have had) and is never seen again.

    My relationship with Lilly was a fuse just waiting to be lit right from the start.
    It takes a lot to make me hate a character. I forgave Kenny for his actions even though i believe he was wrong, i forgave Ben even though he possibly caused the most damage to the entire group. Lilly's actions crossed the line, and to say i would even feel neutral about her is being optimistic. Along with Vernon, she is the one of the only characters i hold nothing but contempt for.
  • Mark$manMark$man
    edited June 2013
    I must say, I love to HATE her. I never liked her, even at the very beginning, and by episode 3 I just hoped she'd die. However, I did keep her in the RV, because I hate to kill people or just cause their problems. I have a conscious people xD.

    Anyway, if she returns... Either she is kissing the new protagonist's and Clem's feet, or she is getting a bullet between the eyes :P sorry Lilly.
  • zev_zevzev_zev
    edited June 2013
    Mark$man wrote: »
    I hate to kill people or just cause their problems.

    Did you try it you will like it. Trust me.
  • Mark$manMark$man
    edited June 2013
    You don't know what I've tried, and no, I don't like it. Life isn't to be stolen away. It is death's hands that should decide when their time has been reached. Either way, what would give anyone the right to end someone's existence on this Earth, whether they be the kindest individual or the most wretched being? So... no, I wouldn't like it.
  • zev_zevzev_zev
    edited June 2013
    Mark$man wrote: »
    You don't know what I've tried, and no, I don't like it. Life isn't to be stolen away. It is death's hands that should decide when their time has been reached. Either way, what would give anyone the right to end someone's existence on this Earth, whether they be the kindest individual or the most wretched being? So... no, I wouldn't like it.

    So, after that nice words, you still want to kill Lilly? You are contradicting yourself dude.
  • RichWalk23RichWalk23
    edited June 2013
    zev_zev wrote: »
    So, after that nice words, you still want to kill Lilly? You are contradicting yourself dude.

    That's what I was thinking. I guess Lilly's a special case.
  • silverpython14silverpython14
    edited June 2013
    I was neutral in episode 1 I was 100 percent team lily in episode 2 and the beginning of episode 3 but I was so pissed off with her when she killed carley but overall I preferred her to Kenny and just remember if your parent had their head smashed in in front of you well you probably would be doing crazy stuff too
This discussion has been closed.