Yeah in that moment if Telltale had played that scenario differently.... Say Lee was further away and instead of grabbing her he raised his gun, I'd have gunned her down without hesitation.
Yeah in that moment if Telltale had played that scenario differently.... Say Lee was further away and instead of grabbing her he raised his gun, I'd have gunned her down without hesitation.
Hell, I would've shot her even at point blank range...
No, leave her with her guns if you hate her so much. She did what would be best for the group(killing Ben).
If she killed Ben, Chuck will still be alive and kicking ass.
Kenny will be in peace with Lilly because she killed the murderer of her wife and son.
And Lilly would probably have killed Molly on sight... which is bad.
No, leave her with her guns if you hate her so much. She did what would be best for the group(killing Ben).
If she killed Ben, Chuck will still be alive and kicking ass.
Kenny will be in peace with Lilly because she killed the murderer of her wife and son.
And Lilly would probably have killed Molly on sight... which is bad.
If she killed Ben nobody in the group would be like "Thanks you did a good thing, lets hop back in the RV and carry on!". The same thing would happen, Lee and Kenny would leave her, or tie her up again and she'd leave. She would have (or actually did with Carley) killed a group member without warning or proof he did anything wrong.
No... I'll go with the old "that will make me just as bad as you" cliche.
It is not my right to decide when her life ends, but she certainly no longer has a place in my group.
I agree,that and I would like to make her suffer for longer in this harsh world,though being the nice gentleman I am I still let her stay with us and I let her back on the rv.
At the time I wanted to shoot but no I wouldn't even though she killed one of our group, just like Morani said, I would be as bad as her. Leaving her on the side of the road is punishment enough.
I left Lilly, but I wouldn't have killed her. I didn't want to keep her around Clementine, as I felt she was a danger - but I at least hoped that she could have survived on her own. I would not have shot her, especially right after she'd done the same thing to another member of the group.
If she killed Ben nobody in the group would be like "Thanks you did a good thing, lets hop back in the RV and carry on!". The same thing would happen, Lee and Kenny would leave her, or tie her up again and she'd leave. She would have (or actually did with Carley) killed a group member without warning or proof he did anything wrong.
I'd rather see Carley killing Lilly for justice than Lilly killing Carley for nothing(Ben=nothing).
Comments
It is not my right to decide when her life ends, but she certainly no longer has a place in my group.
Hell, I would've shot her even at point blank range...
If she killed Ben, Chuck will still be alive and kicking ass.
Kenny will be in peace with Lilly because she killed the murderer of her wife and son.
And Lilly would probably have killed Molly on sight... which is bad.
If she killed Ben nobody in the group would be like "Thanks you did a good thing, lets hop back in the RV and carry on!". The same thing would happen, Lee and Kenny would leave her, or tie her up again and she'd leave. She would have (or actually did with Carley) killed a group member without warning or proof he did anything wrong.
I agree,that and I would like to make her suffer for longer in this harsh world,though being the nice gentleman I am I still let her stay with us and I let her back on the rv.