›

Who Came With You On Your First Playthrough?

MsLoxMsLox
edited July 2013 in The Walking Dead
Poll will be up in a second, just really interested in some numerical stats (: Please only choose who came with you the first time you played.

Comments

  • NobleNoble
    edited July 2013
    All the things.
  • DreadMagusDreadMagus
    edited July 2013
    Bonnie and Shel
  • MsLoxMsLox
    edited July 2013
    Some of the questions I'm trying to answer through this poll are:

    Does everyone get Bonnie?
    Which character came the least often?
    Are Wyatt and Russel always a package deal?
  • loop holeloop hole
    edited July 2013
    In my first playthrough everyone went to the settlement with Tavia.
  • Nate the GreatNate the Great
    edited July 2013
    From what I've seen Vince and Russell are the ones that have come the least. I'm pretty sure Bonnie comes every time
  • pyrrhus19pyrrhus19
    edited July 2013
    In my playthrough Vince stayed behind while the others left with Tavia.
  • MsLoxMsLox
    edited July 2013
    WalkingDeadFan23 wrote: »
    From what I've seen Vince and Russell are the ones that have come the least. I'm pretty sure Bonnie comes every time

    Sure you don't mean Vince and Shel?
  • Nate the GreatNate the Great
    edited July 2013
    MsLox wrote: »
    Sure you don't mean Vince and Shel?

    No, but Shel is a stubborn one, too lol. The reason I say Russell is because the only reason you can get him to go is if you mention friends family and people you may know might be at Tavia's camp. His story has no impact on whether or not he goes
  • Sox&Rocks22Sox&Rocks22
    edited July 2013
    I got Vince Wyatt and Bonnie. Shel, Russell and the punk stayed.
  • MsLoxMsLox
    edited July 2013
    WalkingDeadFan23 wrote: »
    No, but Shel is a stubborn one, too lol. The reason I say Russell is because the only reason you can get him to go is if you mention friends family and people you may know might be at Tavia's camp. His story has no impact on whether or not he goes

    I only say Shel because of the votes so far, but it's only the first day I suppose. I said the friends and family thing to get Wyatt and Russel to go, and it looks like a lot of other people did, too.
  • MsLoxMsLox
    edited July 2013
    Sox&Rocks22 wrote: »
    I got Vince Wyatt and Bonnie. Shel, Russell and the punk stayed.

    This is super interesting, cause now I know for sure that Wyatt and Russell aren't always a package deal. Thanks (:
  • Nate the GreatNate the Great
    edited July 2013
    MsLox wrote: »
    I only say Shel because of the votes so far, but it's only the first day I suppose. I said the friends and family thing to get Wyatt and Russel to go, and it looks like a lot of other people did, too.

    Yeah, but I've been watching a lot of Let's Plays and people like to chose the "People of all ages" dialogue option for Tavia which gets Becca and shel to come
  • MsLoxMsLox
    edited July 2013
    WalkingDeadFan23 wrote: »
    Yeah, but I've been watching a lot of Let's Plays and people like to chose the "People of all ages" dialogue option for Tavia which gets Becca and shel to come

    I didn't realize the other phrases could change anyone's mind! That's so cool, thanks for sharing.
  • MsLoxMsLox
    edited July 2013
    Just realized I probably should have given a "no one" option if I wanted to figure out about Bonnie haha. Do you guys think it's possible to not get Bonnie?
  • HuckleberryHuckleberry
    edited July 2013
    I don't think it's possible not to get Bonnie.

    Also, Wyatt and Russell are only a "package deal" if Wyatt loses the rock-paper-scissors game. Then he's hesitant to join Tavia's party, and the only way to get him to join is to say "there might be someone you know there", which is also the only way you get can Russell to join.

    If Wyatt wins the rock-paper-scissors game, he'll stay in the car and abandon Eddie at the end of his story, which makes him feel guilty. Then, he'll automatically go with Tavia, no matter what dialogue options you choose--though you can still lose Russell by not choosing the "there may be someone you know" option.

    In summary:
    - You always get Bonnie
    - You can get Wyatt without Russell, but you can't get Russell without Wyatt.

    Oh, and in my first playthrough, I got everyone but Vince.
  • Brock SamsonBrock Samson
    edited July 2013
    My first play through I got Vince, Bonnie, and Wyatt.

    On my second I got Russell, Bonnie, and Shel.

    On my third the whole family came with me. :p
  • musdymusdy
    edited July 2013
    Wyatt, Russel & Bonnie.

    Was hoping to get Shel to come :(
  • MoggyoxysMoggyoxys
    edited July 2013
    Everyone but Russell
  • MsLoxMsLox
    edited July 2013
    It looks like someone didn't get Bonnie... that person should speak up and explain haha.
  • KCohereKCohere
    edited July 2013
    Oh shoot, I messed up. I read that as who didnt come with you. Everyone came with me except Russel. What does it take to convince that guy?
  • sQOrPIONsQOrPION
    edited July 2013
    KCohere wrote: »
    What does it take to convince that guy?

    Tavia need to say that there are some people that he may know or found,something like that.

    In my first playtrought everybody come except Vince and Russel
  • StanleyStuttersStanleyStutters
    edited July 2013
    On my first playthrough I was only able to get Wyatt and Bonnie to come with me.
  • MsLoxMsLox
    edited July 2013
    So I'm guessing two people thought it was "who didn't come with you"? Cause now there are 2 no-Bonnie votes and only one has been disproved, haha.
  • ISavedDoug2ISavedDoug2
    edited July 2013
    Only Bonnie on my first play. Wierd...
  • eblocksonianeblocksonian
    edited July 2013
    If you want to everyone, you must avoid having Shel kill Stephanie. For one thing, "kids of all ages" for shel and becca and "someone you know" for russell and wyatt (paraphrasing are exclusive). That means, you HAVE to avoid killing Stephanie for Shel to come with you automatically so that you can convince Russell.
  • kirby18kirby18
    edited July 2013
    Just Bonnie and Wyatt. It was kind of irritating with Vince it all depended on who you shoot... and that really was just a pure preference of who youd want to shoot. What I mean is, it didnt come down to morals or anything just "luck." I shot Justin the first time bc Danny seemed nicer... only thing I disliked about the game. I had to re-do Shels case to get her to come and as for Russel I bought up that he could find family there and now everyones with me. Yay!
  • MsLoxMsLox
    edited July 2013
    kirby18 wrote: »
    Just Bonnie and Wyatt. It was kind of irritating with Vince it all depended on who you shoot... and that really was just a pure preference of who youd want to shoot. What I mean is, it didnt come down to morals or anything just "luck." I shot Justin the first time bc Danny seemed nicer... only thing I disliked about the game. I had to re-do Shels case to get her to come and as for Russel I bought up that he could find family there and now everyones with me. Yay!

    Yeah, over on another thread we are in heated debate about Danny vs. Justin and it's actually very interesting...
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited July 2013
    Yes... interesting... not what I would say but it's some kind of something.
  • cme550cme550
    edited July 2013
    I got everyone except for Russell. I would have liked Russell to go with me, but I'm not going to attempt it again. I'm happy with the way it turned out
  • HudomonkeyHudomonkey
    edited July 2013
    Shel and Bonnie
    I lost Wyatt because he wasn't trusting (lost Rock Paper scissors)
    I lost Russel because he walked away and I didn't use very persuasive dialogue
    I lost Vince because I save Danny...
    I got Shel because Becca seemed to think it was a good idea and because I chose to shoot Steph I guess Shel was willing to do whatever was best for Becca
    I'm pretty sure everyone gets Bonnie...
This discussion has been closed.