Guest ghost appearence of Lee & Carley in Season 2?

edited July 2013 in The Walking Dead
I'm guessing we'll see Clementine on Season 2 but what about throwing in Lee and Carley for the fans who've been wanting them back? Please Telltale? :p

It doesn't have to last long, just appear once and that's it. I'd be perfectly happy with that.
«1

Comments

  • edited July 2013
    Ghosts...
    Seriously...
  • edited July 2013
    I........ what? They even revealed that she is dead to stop people doing this
  • edited July 2013
    Carley already had appeared once. In a form of a decayed corpse. I guess that is a pretty nice indication that she's done.
  • edited July 2013
    Phil_TWD wrote: »
    I'm guessing we'll see Clementine on Season 2 but what about throwing in Lee and Carley for the fans who've been wanting them back? Please Telltale? :p

    It doesn't have to last long, just appear once and that's it. I'd be perfectly happy with that.
    Carley is dead. If you've chosen her, her rotten corpse appears in Russel's Story. Happy?
    Lee is dead/zombie. He won't return (unless in a way mentioned). Get over it.
  • edited July 2013
    This was mentioned before. if we have sort of "little" playable sections with clementine, it'd be nice to see a reimagined Lee, as Clemetine's imaginary friend, cause she is still a child with a big imagination, his personality can be based on what clementine thought of you throught the series nad taught her.
  • edited July 2013
    stevean2 wrote: »
    This was mentioned before. if we have sort of "little" playable sections with clementine, it'd be nice to see a reimagined Lee, as Clemetine's imaginary friend, cause she is still a child with a big imagination, his personality can be based on what clementine thought of you throught the series nad taught her.
    This sounds a bit silly, IMO.
  • edited July 2013
    jiFfM.jpg
  • edited July 2013
    I could imagine Clem having little flashbacks, remembering Lee and her parents.
  • edited July 2013
    Lingvort wrote: »
    This sounds a bit silly, IMO.

    A child having an imagination? Okay doke.
    They could build upto, like you could catch Clementine talking to herself, it's not impossible, it's even shown the the comics. It's to help survivor's cope. Rick spoke to his recently dead wife, lori, through a phone.

    Michonne also went through something similar with her..best friend I believe?

    The Governor also did it.
  • edited July 2013
    stevean2 wrote: »
    A child having an imagination? Okay doke.
    They could build upto, like you could catch Clementine talking to herself, it's not impossible, it's even shown the the comics. It's to help survivor's cope. Rick spoke to his recently dead wife, lori, through a phone.

    Michonne also went through something similar with her..best friend I believe?

    The Governor also did it.
    Not child with imagination is silly, putting such concept in game is silly, but that's IMO. If you say it did appear in comics (or what do you refer to, TV series?), then fine. I just don't see how it would play in the game.
  • edited July 2013
    stevean2 wrote: »
    They could build upto, like you could catch Clementine talking to herself, it's not impossible, it's even shown the the comics. It's to help survivor's cope. Rick spoke to his recently dead wife, lori, through a phone.

    Michonne also went through something similar with her..best friend I believe?

    The Governor also did it.

    Yeah but they also weren't in their right mind. Do you want Clementine to be going insane in Season 2?
  • edited July 2013
    Yeah but they also weren't in their right mind. Do you want Clementine to be going insane in Season 2?

    you dont have to be insane to have an imaginary friend. That was to help them cope with the stress and guilt.
  • edited July 2013
    Lingvort wrote: »
    Not child with imagination is silly, putting such concept in game is silly, but that's IMO. If you say it did appear in comics (or what do you refer to, TV series?), then fine. I just don't see how it would play in the game.

    It's been shown in both the comics and tv series so far. It's a theme of the walking dead.
  • edited July 2013
    I'd rather have flashbacks of Lee rather than "ghosts". I don't how TellTale could incorporate ghosts in the series without it coming off as extremely cheesy
  • edited July 2013
    stevean2 wrote: »
    you dont have to be insane to have an imaginary friend. That was to help them cope with the stress and guilt.

    When you're an adult? And that imaginary friend talks back? And it takes you days to realize it's not a real person? Yes, you do have to be insane.
  • edited July 2013
    When you're an adult? And that imaginary friend talks back? And it takes you days to realize it's not a real person? Yes, you do have to be insane.
    Being insane is not that hard in zombie apocalypse (not the guy' point, I think).
  • edited July 2013
    Lingvort wrote: »
    Being insane is not that hard in zombie apocalypse (not the guy' point, I think).

    Exactly, it isn't. But I don't really want Clem to be insane in Season 2. Not even a little bit.
  • edited July 2013
    I'd rather have flashbacks of Lee rather than "ghosts". I don't how TellTale could incorporate ghosts in the series without it coming off as extremely cheesy

    Yeah, if a character was going to start seeing dead friends I'd probably assume it was to personify mental instability before I thought that anyone would make a Return of the Jedi styled ghost appearance.
  • edited July 2013
    Come on, even show her dead body and make us Carley fans feel is not enough for some people, Phill TWD you are good person, but please hear me out, Carley is D.E.A.D and won't becoming back unless it's a flashback, I thinks ghosts might be a tad bit to chessy.
  • edited July 2013
    I don't think any of you thought about it clearly, when I said "ghosts" I didn't mean how you see them normally in films which make them cheesy.

    But as in Dexter, which his father Harry whom is dead though appears from time to time to socialise with him, because he's the only one who truly knows Dexter (well, Deb knows him too now).

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Kv6_PbXTkc

    Anywho, Telltale's probably not going to bring them back but okay.
  • edited July 2013
    Telltale ALREADY brought Carley back. Didn't you see? She and Russell had a nice little meeting in that ditch.
  • edited July 2013
    She was so pretty after half a year, I mean if Russel did not get there first I am sure Nate would have gotten the tail he always wanted, PS, I do not want Nate going anywhere near Carley's body, she deserves better.
  • edited July 2013
    gftgyjhjngffgvghjhuygtfvrgvfgtfg

    The letters above, were the keys i pressed as i slammed my head on the keyboard after reading the first post of this thread. Just letting you know.
  • edited July 2013
    People really need to stop with this "OMG THEY MIGHT STILL BE ALIVE" or "BRING THEM BACK PLEASE!" No...just...no. Stahp it.
  • edited July 2013
    It's funny, I said in another thread "Well since we saw the body that means no more Carley is alive threads" Well shit I guess I should have nothing, BECAUSE IT'S HAPPENING AGAIN!!!
  • edited July 2013
    Clem having a bit of a break down and seeing an image of Lee pushing her forward may work nice. But no real ghost. This isn't Star Wars.

    Now a fear induced "Rocky 5" moment may work. "Get up Clem! Cause Lee loves ya." :P
  • edited July 2013
    I honestly don't see it happening at all. I mean the only situation I can sort of see it in is that the two figures on the hill top are just Clementine's imagine. She gets close and its Lee and Carley. She runs up to them and they dissapear. But even that is strecthing it. More likely the only mentions of Lee and Carley is if Clementine mentions them if she decides to join a group. But hey it is the Walking Dead, wierder shit has happened before.
  • edited July 2013
    I guess that is a way to see it, the best thing anyone will ever get is mention in dialog, and honestly that is enough for me.
  • edited July 2013
    Rodan78 wrote: »
    I honestly don't see it happening at all. I mean the only situation I can sort of see it in is that the two figures on the hill top are just Clementine's imagine. She gets close and its Lee and Carley. She runs up to them and they dissapear. But even that is strecthing it. More likely the only mentions of Lee and Carley is if Clementine mentions them if she decides to join a group. But hey it is the Walking Dead, wierder shit has happened before.

    Well the tv show has brought in the whole "people seeing things" angel so it wouldn't completely be out there. Rick has an entire conversation with "Lori" after she dies. In the comics Michone talks to her dead bf (one of the "walkers" she had on the chains that she later killed) long after he was dead, and even after his walking corpse was dead. So it's not completely impossible for Clem to see visions of Lee, but it would prove that she is kinda losing it when he shows up. It could work though honestly, but only if done right. I don't know if Tell Tale wants to go there though.
  • edited July 2013
    I don't think they should, Clementine going insane should not happen for quite sometime if ever.
  • edited July 2013
    I don't think they should, Clementine going insane should not happen for quite sometime if ever.

    It could work if written right. Maybe the next time we see Clem she has an "imaginary friend" named "Lee". Only later once Omid and Christa join "the camp" do the other survivors realize that Lee used to be a real person. Kind of the way she held onto the walkie talkie so she could talk to her parents.

    The entire time she talks to other people about what "Lee thinks we should" do it reflects the choice we made in the first game. For example "Lee says we should stay out of the cities. I don't think we should go either."
  • edited July 2013
    There are just so many angles to take season 2, I guess that is a good thing and Telltale is having a field day.
  • edited July 2013
    Well there are recorded voicovers for an intended conversation with the "ghosts" of Carley/Doug for a cut nightmare scene episode 2, so it may not be such a crazy idea. I certainly doubt they'd reappear now, but i don't think Clementine having something like that over Lee is unfeasible or even dreaming about the entirety of the Motel group, suddenly being the sole survivor of the people she spent the early days with is bound to have been pretty traumatic for her.

    Sure they cut that scene, but then they did put that scene where Clem is a walker in so they're not too shy of things that end up not being real.
  • edited July 2013
    It's unlikely but possible, that is the best I will go down to, and I did forget the whole dream from Episode 3.
  • edited July 2013
    It's unlikely but possible, that is the best I will go down to, and I did forget the whole dream from Episode 3.

    I certainly agree it's very very unlikely. It requires Clem to be the new PC,then for them to take the direction with the character and the tone just to make it a possibility.

    Just expressing that the pretty aggressive reactions to this thread were a bit harsh.
  • edited July 2013
    The Fallen wrote: »
    Sure they cut that scene, but then they did put that scene where Clem is a walker in so they're not too shy of things that end up not being real.

    Agreed. Again it's all about how it is written. Of course I think what we are all talking about here who are arguing this point is character's having dreams or hallucinations, not actual "Ghost" in the Obi Wan Kenobi way. :p
    It requires Clem to be the new PC,then for them to take the direction with the character and the tone just to make it a possibility.

    Like I said with my "imaginary friend" angel, I think it can be done without having to play as Clem. Depending on how it is actually written.
  • edited July 2013
    Like the ones in the return of the jedi.
  • edited July 2013
    I believe the hostile reaction is because they think the OP means bring Carley back even after her body was seen, it's the phrasing.
  • edited July 2013
    The only person alive from Season 1 that really knew Lee and Carley well is Clemmie, and unless she becomes the PC, I doubt we will have proper flashback sequence (i.e. seeing them). At best, we might see Clem mentioning dreams of them, zoning out, or talking to herself.
  • edited July 2013
    Since Carley was a reporter, TT can have a flashback of another character where he/she is watching the news of a news reporter having a hard time turning on an electronic device with no batteries - instant Carley camp
This discussion has been closed.