How would Carley have reacted if...

edited July 2013 in The Walking Dead
She had lived to hear Ben confess to stealing supplies and getting their friends killed?

Comments

  • edited July 2013
    she probably would have wanted the full story (reporter) and forgiven him
  • edited July 2013
    Carley and Doug were forgiving people...

    Doug was willing to give his life for Ben which shows that he would have easily forgiven him if he confided in him

    Carley ,from what I've seen ,stood up for him...
  • edited July 2013
    I don't think they would forgive him that easily. His act, though well intentioned, did lead to the death of Duck and Katjaa.

    They were try to protect someone who they thought were innocent, who was actually guily the entire time, I wouldn't be surprised if they felt betrayed, Carley more so than Doug since she was more defensive for Ben's sake than Doug was.

    Not to say that they would never forgive Ben, but I can see them getting a little shaken and upset about it, but in due time they'll come to forgive him and understand why he did it.
  • edited July 2013
    RichWalk23 wrote: »
    I don't think they would forgive him that easily. His act, though well intentioned, did lead to the death of Duck and Katjaa.

    They were try to protect someone who they thought were innocent, who was actually guily the entire time, I wouldn't be surprised if they felt betrayed, Carley more so than Doug since she was more defensive for Ben's sake than Doug was.

    Not to say that they would never forgive Ben, but I can see them getting a little shaken and upset about it, but in due time they'll come to forgive him and understand why he did it.

    Doug was a bullet's worth more defensive then Carley...
  • edited July 2013
    Hudomonkey wrote: »
    Doug was a bullet's worth more defensive then Carley...

    It doesn't matter who protected Ben better , both of them protected him how they could . It's stupid to hold a competition about who is better .
  • edited July 2013
    She would have been upset with him for not telling them, but she would forgive him at a point and vote to keep him during Kenny's vote in Crawford.
  • edited July 2013
    I think she'd put him in a headlock until he passed out. I think she'd be disgusted by his actions, especially since she defended him. It'd probably take a long time for her to forgive him, but I don't think she could bring herself to completely hate him. Nothing like Lilly anyway.
  • edited July 2013
    She would have been upset with him for not telling them, but she would forgive him at a point and vote to keep him during Kenny's vote in Crawford.

    This. Off topic but I wonder if Ben ever had a crush on Carley. Just a thought, he is a teenager after all.
  • edited July 2013
    she probably would have wanted the full story (reporter) and forgiven him

    That sounds like Carley. Even with Lee she was like, "You're a murderer but I dont care. It's a skill that might come in handy" lol.
  • edited July 2013
    Carley would be pissed at him, and Doug would be dissappointed. Both would feel betrayed. Eventually, I can see Doug forgiving him for it, after awhile. Carley, I'm not so sure of, but she would at least vote to keep him during the Crawford scene simply because she's a good person.
  • edited July 2013
    What about Kaja? How would she react?
  • edited July 2013
    What about Kaja? How would she react?

    Well, considering how pissed she was at Lilly for killing Doug/Carly, someone she barely interacted with, I doubt she'd be happy about Ben's involvement in the death of someone as close to her as her son.
  • edited July 2013
    If Doug and Carley were alive that means we had to reason to leave Lilly = she could be there to ? in that case ben would get shot by Lilly.

    If Lilly escapedwith the RV before then they would maybe talk about it in the house - carley would forgive ben
This discussion has been closed.