Characters from comics in game?

edited July 2013 in The Walking Dead
Hello, does anyone of you know if Kirkman ever answered similliar question if some characters from comics will appear in the game or some game character in comics book? I think it would be nice to meet someone even just a small role from the comics in the game. What do you think. :)

Comments

  • edited July 2013
    I do not think he has ever said that anymore people from the comics will show up, could be wrong but I do not think so.
  • JenniferJennifer Moderator
    edited July 2013
    Not much has been said about season two so far, but I wouldn't rule out comic characters showing up (after all, Glenn did show up in season one).

    The one thing that has been said about a possibility of a crossover though, is that Telltale's CEO Dan Connors said there's a possibility that characters from the television show could meet up with characters from the game.
  • edited July 2013
    It could happen, I am not a fan of the idea but I will not rule it out of the world of possible.
  • edited July 2013
    If it were to happen, I'd trust Telltale's abilities to make something out of it. Who knows if they have an epic master play behind everything involving either the comics or the show or maybe neither? My guess is, that whatever they come up with will satisfy us, the fans.

    To state my opinion on the question at hand: I don't remember anything concrete on that matter, but then again, I'm not the best informed person here anyways, neither am I pro crossovers with either the show or the comics, because there might be certain issues with such a thing, those issues are self explanatory, such as having a character from the comics, who's currently alive in the comics for instance. They couldn't be killed off, and thus you wouldn't have to worry about them, which takes away a great part of the excitement.
  • edited July 2013
    I'm pretty sure Lily used to be the Lily from the comic, until Kirkman made Road to Woodbury.
  • edited July 2013
    It was, long story short that was bull.
  • edited July 2013
    I hope telltale keeps the game true to the comics, because all the characters look like they do from the comics (Hershel notably) and not the show. I was real disappointed when lily was announced as not being the Woodbury lily. Anyway if anyone from telltale games is reading this, please don't do a crossover with the show. Keep it as it was supposed to be in the comic universe, if you want a character to add do Sgt Abraham Ford and his group, in the comics he stated that he had to leave several groups people behind for the sake of the "mission"
  • edited July 2013
    I wouldnt mind seeing comic characters appear more in the game. I loved having Glenn and even Hershel as curmudgeonly as he was.
  • edited July 2013
    Jennifer wrote: »
    Not much has been said about season two so far, but I wouldn't rule out comic characters showing up (after all, Glenn did show up in season one).

    The one thing that has been said about a possibility of a crossover though, is that Telltale's CEO Dan Connors said there's a possibility that characters from the television show could meet up with characters from the game.

    ...Daryl?
  • edited July 2013
    Vaxij wrote: »
    ...Daryl?

    Daryl has his story in the other shitty game. I didn't play it though, so I dont know how much of his history is explained there.
  • edited July 2013
    Nothing was explained, it was all a waste of time, I am sorry to anyone who bought it, because I knew it would suck from day one.
  • edited July 2013
    I would like more cameos, I think at least one is assured. Hershel and Glenn cameo's were great in Episode 1, and I still like to think game Lilly is comic Lilly as it is such a great tie in to explain how comic Lilly got to be the way she was (Lee's/Kenny's actions), which lead her to do pretty crazy shit in the comics.

    I feel like they shouldn't have any of the comic Villains in the game, as it could potentially ruin their image (The Governor and Negan in particular). However maybe seeing Abraham at one point, as he doesn't reach the group till later and he has a pretty interesting backstory that could be explored through the game. Also maybe one of the Hunters (Cannibals), before they began eating people. Possibly something that happens in the game could lead them to join the Hunters and become a cannibal? There is six of them who could make an appearance:

    The_Hunters.png

    And we aren't given much background information on them, so maybe seeing one, or a couple, or even the whole group in the game as a cameo would be good to see. I think the game should also stay away from main locations (Woodbury, Hilltop Colony, etc...) as it would just complicate canon. Also the timeline would have to be considered as well, if this takes place straight after Season 1 then were already well into the apocalypse, or if it starts after 400 Days then that is even longer afterwards.

    Edit: Just read that the Hunters were originally an ordinary group who turned to cannibalism to survive. Might be cool to see that in the game, or maybe before they were cannibals.
  • edited July 2013
    I think there was enough of cannibalism with St.John family.
  • edited July 2013
    NEGAN wrote: »
    I think there was enough of cannibalism with St.John family.

    I feel like it was a whole different situation. Maybe they wouldn't even need to show cannibalism, just the group (or a few of the group) before they all went crazy. It's just an idea though, pretty much any cameo (as long as it makes sense to the canon) would be great.
  • edited July 2013
    NEGAN wrote: »
    I think there was enough of cannibalism with St.John family.

    I agree. I'm not sure if they will go there again. Maybe they will but if I remember right the cannibals from that comic are somewhere near DC. I also think the Hunters are all from that particular area. I haven't read that part of the series since it came out, but I think there is a monologue where they talk about how they used to just be regular suburbanites until the food ran out... they then killed and ate each others kids.

    I could be wrong on the details though. Like I said I really haven't read that section of the series since it first came out.
  • edited July 2013
    I just found out that there is a reference to Thomas, the prisoner who cut heads of Hershel kids. At the beginning the policeman speaks about him in the car with Lee.

    Its the guy who cried in his car and yelled: "Mama, it's all a big mistake! It wasn't me!"

    Thomas.jpg
  • edited July 2013
    Jennifer wrote: »
    Not much has been said about season two so far, but I wouldn't rule out comic characters showing up (after all, Glenn did show up in season one).

    The one thing that has been said about a possibility of a crossover though, is that Telltale's CEO Dan Connors said there's a possibility that characters from the television show could meet up with characters from the game.

    No, then it would mean that the TV show is also cannon to the comic, meaning there are 2 Ricks and 2 Carls running around, please do not ruin the game
  • edited July 2013
    In the SDCC panel, I remember someone asking this same question. It was then said that Telltale is working with Kirkman to see what characters would make sense crossing over in season 2.
  • edited July 2013
    They did mean comic right? I would be somewhat okay with a comic cameo but the show, please no.
  • edited July 2013
    Zeruis wrote: »
    In the SDCC panel, I remember someone asking this same question. It was then said that Telltale is working with Kirkman to see what characters would make sense crossing over in season 2.

    It would ruin the game.
  • edited July 2013
    It would not ruin it if it's comic characters, TV characters would be a notch down in my book.
  • edited July 2013
    It would not ruin it if it's comic characters, TV characters would be a notch down in my book.

    I dont have a problem with that?
  • edited July 2013
    I still have no idea why they even thought bringing TV characters is a good idea, well that is one fear I do have for season 2 that could happen.
  • edited July 2013
    They did mean comic right? I would be somewhat okay with a comic cameo but the show, please no.

    Yeah, it was stated that it was comic characters. However, I do not know if they're still crossing over TV show characters or not.

    In my opinion though, I'd just like to keep characters separate to their own mediums.
  • edited July 2013
    Thanks, I was hoping you meant comic characters, I agree very much so, no TV show characters as it would really mess up the continuity way to much, a small comic cameo is won't affect me at all.
  • edited July 2013
    Zeruis wrote: »
    Yeah, it was stated that it was comic characters. However, I do not know if they're still crossing over TV show characters or not.

    In my opinion though, I'd just like to keep characters separate to their own mediums.

    I agree,though seeing some more comic characters would be really cool,it would also be awesome if Kirkman added some original characters in the game to the comics,not main characters just a side character or two.
  • edited July 2013
    That would also be nice, but a small comic cameo is all right with me.
  • edited July 2013
    Yeah I think the cameos are good, but they need to be careful with them. There were still some canon issues with Hershel. Mainly where is Shawn's brothers and sisters at the time, wouldn't they have heard the screams and ran outside? I know not all of them would have been at Hershel's at this point, I imagine once the apocalypse started the older ones (Arnold, Lacey and Maggie) would have come back to Hershel's as they might have houses for themselves or go to college, but at least the younger ones would have been there (Hershel mentions Shawn goes to check on his sister at one point as well). Also how in the comics Hershel mentions Shawn was bitten and died a few days later, whereas in the game it looks like he dies almost straight away. I guess Hershel may have figured out after Lee and the others left that Shawn was still alive and he tried to save him, and Shawn died later on. But I think Telltale did a great job of making Hershel, Glenn (and Lilly) stay true to the comics, and Hershel's farm looks almost exactly the same as it does in the comics.

    As long as it fits the comic canon, and they don't include too major characters like Rick, The Governor and Negan, I think it would be cool. I just hope Kirkman has better communication with Telltale over comic characters being in the game this time, I would hate to have another Lilly situation.

    Edit: The Walking Dead wiki says that it could be possible that Shawn just turned into a Walker a few days later, which would still make sense I guess. I can forget about this, there are possibilities around it.
  • edited July 2013
    I agree, it was very canon to the comics, not so much the show for that scene but they did do that part very well.
  • edited July 2013
    I think crossing over with any characters from the TV series would kill any logic. Firstly because the first season of the game portrayed the characters as they are in the comics- Hershel, for instance, was nothing like the TV series' Hershel. So they can't just introduce some characters as they appear in the comic, and then throw someone from the TV series in, when they don't even exist in the comics at all. It just sounds... messy.

    Minor TV series spoilers ahead

    Secondly, to introduce someone from the TV series, the timelines would have to match, which, at the moment, they don't. The day Atlanta survivors arrived at the CDC in the TV series was day 64 of the outbreak, according to Wiki. They then left for Hershel's farm, where they spent an unspecified amount of time, but I believe it was under a month. After that they spent 8 months offscreen, during the gap between season 2 and 3. Which would put the total amount of time the infection has been in existence to just under a year in the TV series. 400 days, on the other hand, happens, well, 400 days after. Which means the events of the second season of the game will happen in the future from the current events depicted in the TV show. We do not yet know who will survive that long in the TV series' version of things, therefore, characters can not be added without making a huge mess from the continuum.
  • edited July 2013
    That does make sense, but I got a idea that at least the first Episode would be in the 90 day range, so if they dare do it they will be in the beginning.
  • edited July 2013
    That does make sense, but I got a idea that at least the first Episode would be in the 90 day range, so if they dare do it they will be in the beginning.

    What makes you say that? You mean like in the first season, when the first episode explored how everybody got into the group, then cut to three months later, to people surviving? Maybe, but personally, I didn't like the idea of that gap, especially because the survivors hardly seemed to bond/improve their relationship over the course of those three months at all. And Mark's addition was never fully explained, which also bothered me (even if I did like the character a lot). Personally I'd rather they abstained from such big time gaps in season 2, and if they do it, I think we should at least be given a cutscene explaining what happened in quick bits, kinda like "Previously on the Walking Dead" episode intros.
  • edited July 2013
    I just think they will start right were they ended it, so we can find out if Kenny made it, who the people on the hill are, and so forth, but we do have to know more about this settlement and 400 Day's survivors, so I think at a point they will do a time skip.
  • edited July 2013
    We still don't know how big of an appearance the 400 Days characters will have in S2, so we don't know if things will start after 400 Days. If we are introducing a new protagonist, S2 could start with them at any time.

    I am okay with any comic cameos as long as continuity is preserved. Tv character integration is trickier. To keep the continuity intact, you couldn't have any characters that have an alternate comic counterpart. So that leaves original characters like Daryl, Merle, TDog, etc. And it would have to be an alternate version of the tv character. At this point, things are already so convuluted that you wonder if it would even be worth it. Merle and Daryl are probably the only worthy original tv characters to integrate, but their story was already explored in that other game. So it would have to be an original version of them, where they never joined Shane's group, but I still think that would just confuse so many people over which universe the games are based in. I guess I could still accept it as long as the continuity remains, and I would love more comic cameos, but I would rather no tv character crossovers.
  • edited July 2013
    I agree, it will be way to confusing, and we do not need the Walking Dead becoming Inception.
  • edited July 2013
    I agree, it will be way to confusing, and we do not need the Walking Dead becoming Inception.

    Deadception?
  • edited July 2013
    Yes, a zombie within a zombie within another zombie, not something I want to understand every day I play, I mean I kind of already had that treatment this year.
  • edited July 2013
    walking-dead_0.jpg
    Did anyone else notice in the season 4 preview that michonne is looking at Macon on the map?
  • edited July 2013
    walking-dead_0.jpg
    Did anyone else notice in the season 4 preview that michonne is looking at Macon on the map?

    everyone.
  • edited July 2013
    I knew that, I have just not seen the pic before, thanks.
This discussion has been closed.