›

Question about dropping the gun in episode 5

KilledLarryKilledLarry
edited July 2013 in The Walking Dead
Does Ben pick up THAT gun you drop, or give Lee HIS gun? He says something really wierd

Here, im not good with these, you droped it down there

why did he add that he is not good with them? thats something you say if you are giving someone something right? Here your better with these things than i am, take it. get what i mean? LOL it dont make a lick of damm sense. :confused:

Comments

  • TTaing987TTaing987
    edited July 2013
    I think people said it's Carley's gun, Lee kept it and he dropped it in the house. Ben picked it up.
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited July 2013
    Because I think it was, so it kind of had meaning beyond being a self defense weapon.
  • KilledLarryKilledLarry
    edited July 2013
    Bioshock Infinite WD wrote: »
    Because I think it was, so it kind of had meaning beyond being a self defense weapon.

    The gun ben owns in episode 4 is in fact Lillys. Carly seemed to have lost her gun in episode 3.
  • DildorDildor
    edited July 2013
    Yeah, I just replayed this part 2 nights ago and Ben picks up the gun Lee dropped. Pretty sure it's Carley's gun.

    I don't understand what happens to the bullets you save from the zombie standoff a few minutes later when Kenny asks how many you have.
  • KilledLarryKilledLarry
    edited July 2013
    Dildor wrote: »
    Yeah, I just replayed this part 2 nights ago and Ben picks up the gun Lee dropped. Pretty sure it's Carley's gun.

    I don't understand what happens to the bullets you save from the zombie standoff a few minutes later when Kenny asks how many you have.

    Oh no my bad its not Lillys gun, ben DOES have Lillys gun though
  • KilledLarryKilledLarry
    edited July 2013
    Dildor wrote: »
    Yeah, I just replayed this part 2 nights ago and Ben picks up the gun Lee dropped. Pretty sure it's Carley's gun.

    I don't understand what happens to the bullets you save from the zombie standoff a few minutes later when Kenny asks how many you have.

    2 Nights ago?..Yeah thats prolly what happend. Youve been...all by yourself throught this?
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited July 2013
    If you don't say I am not leaving you give them to Kenny and walk away, he then fires more the said amount of shots into the horde.
  • DildorDildor
    edited July 2013
    KilledLarry wrote: »
    2 Nights ago?..Yeah thats prolly what happend. Youve been...all by yourself throught this?
    *Clementine will remember that*
    Yeah. I want my parents to come home now.
    clementine_the_walking_dead_ep4_by_thefilipino52.jpg
  • TTaing987TTaing987
    edited July 2013
    Dildor wrote: »
    *Clementine will remember that*
    Yeah. I want my parents to come home now.
    clementine_the_walking_dead_ep4_by_thefilipino52.jpg

    I think that may be a long time...
  • KilledLarryKilledLarry
    edited July 2013
    marioluigi344 wrote: »
    Yeah, I want my parents to come home now. :(

    I think that.... may be a little while, ya know? I mean they prolly turned into walkers and for some reason stayed together in walker form over 3 months and will appear to show you that they are dead in episode 5 so you can move on, shall we get going?
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited July 2013
    Well that would have been cruel if you could tell Clem that.
  • VelociraptoriusVelociraptorius
    edited July 2013
    A theory on the Wiki says it's indeed Carley's gun. It's never explained in the game, but people speculate that Lilly, with her paranoia, only allowed the person on the watch to have a gun on them, while keeping the rest of the weapons, including Carley's Glock, in her room. Hence why she had the gun on her in the RV scene.
    I think this theory is likely true, since throughout episodes 1/2 Carley's Glock is the only such pistol the group has and it's unlikely to have changed. If you choose to believe this theory, like I did, then I suppose it does make it the last memento of Carley, as Lee carries it with him throughout the remaining episodes. On the other hand, that also makes it the gun that KILLED Carley, so there's that :D Either way, it all makes dropping the gun without Ben to pick it up sadder. Although I was disappointed that even if you do save Ben, who retrieves the gun, and you still have bullets, even if you don't give it to Kenny, the game never presents you the opportunity to use it again. It even disappears from Lee's model. Which is disappointing, I was hoping to shoot the Stranger with it.
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited July 2013
    I believe it was the gun, so Lilly killed Carley with her own gun, and I think Lee hands it to Christa or Omid off camera, as he would have used it during Campmans part or given it to Clem, so I think they have Carley's gun, so just one more reason they need to live.
  • MornaiMornai
    edited July 2013
    KilledLarry wrote: »
    why did he add that he is not good with them? thats something you say if you are giving someone something right? Here your better with these things than i am, take it. get what i mean? LOL it dont make a lick of damm sense. :confused:

    Let's be honest here, the overall safety of the group would decrease if Ben were to have a gun instead of Lee. How many walkers did Lee kill with a pistol compared to Ben? Let's just say, more than enough.
  • ZacTBZacTB
    edited July 2013
    It would have been nicer for Clementine to hold onto Carley's gun. Seems a lot more appropriate than having the Stranger's gun.

    What gun does Lilly use to kill Doug? I have done a Doug playthrough but never noticed that she used Carley's gun to kill Carley (which is ironic in a horrific kind of way).
  • TTaing987TTaing987
    edited July 2013
    I think that Clem having the strangers gun might be symbolism for Clem's loss of innocence if she shot the stranger. If not it can be a symbol for her maturity, as she learned from her mistakes after the stranger incident.
  • ZacTBZacTB
    edited July 2013
    TTaing987 wrote: »
    I think that Clem having the strangers gun might be symbolism for Clem's loss of innocence if she shot the stranger. If not it can be a symbol for her maturity, as she learned from her mistakes after the stranger incident.

    I like this idea, I think symbolism works well in this game.
  • VelociraptoriusVelociraptorius
    edited July 2013
    Bioshock Infinite WD wrote: »
    I believe it was the gun, so Lilly killed Carley with her own gun, and I think Lee hands it to Christa or Omid off camera, as he would have used it during Campmans part or given it to Clem, so I think they have Carley's gun, so just one more reason they need to live.

    Hm, that's a valid theory, I suppose, it would explain why Lee doesn't carry the gun when confronting the stranger. Although why he would hand Omid or Christa an empty gun, I don't know, especially since he probably treasures it as the last memento of Carley. Personally, I would have preferred if Lee kept it throughout and then gave it to Clementine. Her carrying Carley's gun would have been more symbolic. Now it seems she has some random cop's gun.
  • ZacTBZacTB
    edited July 2013
    Wait I thought she had the Stranger's gun but yeah she picked up the walker cop's one. What happened to the Stranger's gun?

    The case of the missing handguns.
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited July 2013
    It is a gun, they did not find many in Savannah, so I think they kept it just in case they find ammo, spare gun is never not useful.
  • ZacTBZacTB
    edited July 2013
    If Lee had the Stranger's gun couldn't he just get Clem to shoot the trapped Walker at the end instead of trying to get the keys/gun off him alive? I'm confused, maybe they left it behind which would be pretty dumb.
  • BubbaFightsUnlimitedBubbaFightsUnlimited
    edited July 2013
    Bioshock Infinite WD wrote: »
    Spare gun is never not useful.

    No, I think you have shovels and spare guns mixed up.
  • VelociraptoriusVelociraptorius
    edited July 2013
    The Stranger's gun was out of ammo when Lee shot the walker in the hotel. That was the last bullet. It's not seen or used afterwards. Lee could have either kept it or left it. It seems to disappear the same way Carley's gun does, as soon as it's out of ammo and not useful anymore. And Clem uses the gun she picks up from the cop walker.
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited July 2013
    BubbaFightsUnlimited wrote: »
    No, I think you have shovels and spare guns mixed up.

    Shoves are more useful then empty guns, but that is determined, it might have one or it might not, I just like to think Lee gave it to Christa and Omid, and is not on his body.
This discussion has been closed.