At first I thought it was Kenny because he said he would do ANYTHING for his family but I changed my mind not long after because he was my bro and it hurt to much to suspects him. Ben was too obvious so I thought it was him after that, I made a thread like this before. Anyway so yeah I thought it was Ben.
Remember when the episode 3 trailer came out and it looked like Lilly was about to shoot Clem before Lee pins her to the RV? And most of us assumed Clem was somehow looting supplies?
I thought it was Ben since he had only been there for a week, and the way he reacted was odd, during the roadside argument I then changed it to maybe it was someone we did not know, I mean Jolene did take Clem's hat, what says it can not happen again, I was beyond pissed when Ben told me the truth.
First I thought Ben, then Carley because she had to make another battery joke when I asked her about the flashlight (the bulb was even broken! Batteries won't fix that!), it seemed like she tried to deflect the question. In the end, I decided it was Ben.
First I thought Ben, then Carley because she had to make another battery joke when I asked her about the flashlight (the bulb was even broken! Batteries won't fix that!), it seemed like she tried to deflect the question. In the end, I decided it was Ben.
No, I DECIDED it was Ben. I decide who's guilty of what, my thoughts MAKE IT HAPPEN. I willed it to be Ben, and then I willed him to confess! I willed the supplies to magically disappear in the first place, and my thoughts caused Larry to have a heart attack! The St. Johns didn't place that bear trap in the middle of the woods for David to step in, my MIND did. Tread carefully, sir, or YOU may be next.
I thought Clem. The game did a pretty damn good job making her look suspicious... talking on the phone, the fact it was her chalk, etc. I'd assumed somebody was blackmailing her for her parents (I was, in hindsight, totally correct) and forcing her to steal stuff.
I thought it was Ben. When you ask him about the flashlight, guilt is just written on his face. I understand that he might be terrified if Lilly asked him, but when he almost pissed his pants at Lee asking, I knew something was up. He's never reacted that way to Lee talking to him, so... had to be something. I also suspected Carley for maybe a fraction of a second, she did dodge the flashlight question spectacularly. But in the end I figured she's too trustworthy for that. Oh, and I also grew suspicious of Duck when he found the exact chalk I was looking for. But in the end I figured he's too stupid to successfully steal supplies. So yeah, Ben it was.
At first I had no idea, then at the RV I suspected it could be someone from outside OR Lilly herself trying to blame Carley. At the end, I thought it could be Ben because he was desperate, trying to evade the questions Lilly made him. Turns out I was right. 8)
lmfao 4 people voted clem wat...
I originally thought it was Lilly because she was pinning everything else on Ben or Carley...depending on your game. Like someone said before, she wanted to get the chance to kill Kenny and/or Lee for vengeance. She could be capable and willing to do it since how broken she was.
Comments
I remember.
" Anything with opium in it "
and Kenbny had been shot before in episode 2..............
you mean you FOUND OUT its ben? XD
Until I talked to Ben, then it became really obvious. "Oh, you've been reading the bible, Ben? No way you could have done it then." Rofl.
No, I DECIDED it was Ben. I decide who's guilty of what, my thoughts MAKE IT HAPPEN. I willed it to be Ben, and then I willed him to confess! I willed the supplies to magically disappear in the first place, and my thoughts caused Larry to have a heart attack! The St. Johns didn't place that bear trap in the middle of the woods for David to step in, my MIND did. Tread carefully, sir, or YOU may be next.
It wasn't that big of a mystery IMO.
Yeah, but it's Ben. He freaked out when Lee asked him if he came down to Macon a lot.
Did you show him the flashlight? He becomes overly-defensive at the exact moment you show him it.
*Group begins voting*
Ben: We don't need all these votes!
One of the best lines of Season 1. Oh Ben.
I originally thought it was Lilly because she was pinning everything else on Ben or Carley...depending on your game. Like someone said before, she wanted to get the chance to kill Kenny and/or Lee for vengeance. She could be capable and willing to do it since how broken she was.
Meh. I thought it was patently obvious.
But then I took a dislike to him from the start; I didn't want to share the ZA with an even more inept version of Shaggy.