Why all the hate on Clementine?

13

Comments

  • edited August 2013
    No she isn't. Not by a long shot. A psycho would've killed Carley and Doug with no remorse. Lilly felt regret.
  • edited August 2013
    Yes, regret, she sure regretted stealing the RV and leaving everyone for dead, great way to show you still care.
  • edited August 2013
    Harpadarpa wrote: »
    No she isn't. Not by a long shot. A psycho would've killed Carley and Doug with no remorse. Lilly felt regret.

    She felt regret after killing Doug, but after killing Carley she just said ''she couldn't be trusted''
  • edited August 2013
    She is better off without them as we saw. They all died.
  • edited August 2013
    She thought that those people were going to kill her. If someone was holding you prisoner, would you sit around if given the chance to escape? Even if it meant leaving them for dead? At least she didn't kill anyone else.

    Also, you could clearly hear regret.
  • edited August 2013
    She showed more regret than Kenny ever did...
  • edited August 2013
    I am alone, in a sea of Lilly Fans, great.
  • edited August 2013
    He showed regret for not helping Shawn. He didn't after the meatlocker scene because he was sure that he saved everyone's lives (but I gotta admit, that he was an asshole to Lilly after that)

    Don't worry Bio, you're not alone :P
  • edited August 2013
    I'm not a fan of Lilly I dislike her...
    I just dislike Kenny more and think really people let Kenny off with too much just because he has a nice moustache...
    I mean he also wanted to kill Ben and demanded his death he just chose a more painful and agonizing death for him...
    He leaves you for dead if you don't help him kill people...
    He is willing to execute possible walkers whilst actively fighting and denying against a guaranteed walker...
    He forgets everything you've done if you ever disagree...
    Lilly is a bit more consistent and either does things through Paranoia or because the alternative would be death...
  • edited August 2013
    Thanks, he said he regretted wanting Ben dead, he regretted letting Shawn die, he regretted a lot more then Lilly ever did.
  • edited August 2013
    Thanks, he said he regretted wanting Ben dead, he regretted letting Shawn die, he regretted a lot more then Lilly ever did.

    I just let Ben go and just watched Shawn get eaten.
  • edited August 2013
    Hudomonkey wrote: »
    I'm not a fan of Lilly I dislike her...
    I just dislike Kenny more and think really people let Kenny off with too much just because he has a nice moustache...
    I mean he also wanted to kill Ben and demanded his death he just chose a more painful and agonizing death for him...
    He leaves you for dead if you don't help him kill people...
    He is willing to execute possible walkers whilst actively fighting and denying against a guaranteed walker...
    He forgets everything you've done if you ever disagree...
    Lilly is a bit more consistent and either does things through Paranoia or because the alternative would be death...

    I never cared about the stache. Ben got his whole family killed. Yeah, he does leave you for dead, that's the only time I didn't like Kenny. He was in a stage of loss, denial. Most people go through that. I think that's more bogus coding than showing Kenny as a person... Unless you did one of a couple of things.
  • edited August 2013
    Thanks, he said he regretted wanting Ben dead, he regretted letting Shawn die, he regretted a lot more then Lilly ever did.
    Lilly wasn't given time to regret anything before she was either left to survive in the wilderness or tied up in the back of an RV by the man who killed her father and aggressively argued for her to be left to the walkers...
  • edited August 2013
    Lol Ehkay you got a lot of hate in you

    LOL so I see. :)
  • edited August 2013
    Lol Ehkay you got a lot of hate in you

    And even more love for Lilly
  • edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    LOL so I see. :)

    Hey Ehkay can I ask a question. If you accidentally shot Lilly by mistake what would you do?
  • edited August 2013
    I'm kinda shocked to hear that Ehkay doesn't like Eddie , I mean how can you not like Eddie and his dick ? :(
  • edited August 2013
    So he dosen't like the road eiether, the road's straight as his dick.
  • edited August 2013
    Hey Ehkay can I ask a question. If you accidentally shot Lilly by mistake what would you do?

    ...
  • edited August 2013
    I'd try to find Sanctuary.
  • edited August 2013
    What would you do if Clementine accidentally shot Lilly because Lilly ran in front of a walker that Clementine was trying to kill?
  • edited August 2013
    I would tie Clementine to a chair and use her as bait as I throw her into a horde of walkers and I leave for another group.
  • edited August 2013
    ...
  • edited August 2013
    Ehkay never disappoints with his answers
  • edited August 2013
    What if with her dying words, Lilly said that it wasn't Clementine's fault and that she was just careless for getting in the way? And then she made Larry promise (who's still alive in this hypothetical) to keep Clementine safe. So now in order to kill Clementine, you'd have to kill Larry first. Would you do it?
  • edited August 2013
    What if with her dying words, Lilly said that it wasn't Clementine's fault and that she was just careless for getting in the way? And then she made Larry promise (who's still alive in this hypothetical) to keep Clementine safe. So now in order to kill Clementine, you'd have to kill Larry first. Would you do it?

    Yes.
  • edited August 2013
    Alright, then reverse Lilly's and Larry's roles. Clem shot Larry on accident and Lilly's protecting Clementine with her life. Would you kill Lilly to also kill Clem?

    If your answer to that is yes, then I want to know how many of the characters in your signature you would kill to be able to kill Clem if she shot either Lilly, Larry, Oberson, or Nate?
  • edited August 2013
    DomeWing i'm starting to think you're the joker :3
  • edited August 2013
    Alright, then reverse Lilly's and Larry's roles. Clem shot Larry on accident and Lilly's protecting Clementine with her life. Would you kill Lilly to also kill Clem?

    If your answer to that is yes, then I want to know how many of the characters in your signature you would kill to be able to kill Clem if she shot either Lilly, Larry, Oberson, or Nate?

    I couldn't kill Lilly and the only person(s) I would kill on my signature would be Nate. (I still have people to add to my signature).
  • edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    I couldn't kill Lilly and the only person(s) I would kill on my signature would be Nate. (I still have people to add to my signature).

    What if Clem shot every single person in your signature except for Lilly? Would you still not kill Lilly to be able to kill Clementine even then?

    And TTaing? Me? The Joker? Couldn't be...

    tumblr_mmnk6vPbCb1rlnv4ko1_500.gif
  • edited August 2013
    ...It can't be...
  • edited August 2013
    Hey, guys, someone's spiked Chuck's whiskey.



    I'm scared.
  • edited August 2013
    Want a nip?
  • edited August 2013
    If everyone was killed then yes there would be hell to pay. I had a hard enough time choosing between Shane and Lilly let alone the rest. Nate I do not mind dying but the rest oh hell no.
  • edited August 2013
    Alright. Last one.

    Clementine has shot every single character in your signature except for Shane and Lilly who are all now guarding Clementine with their lives. You have to kill both of them in order to kill Clementine. You only have one bullet in your gun, though, so you would have hack the other one to death with a meat cleaver. Would you kill both Lilly and Shane to get your revenge (which one would you shoot, which one would you hack?) or would you just let it go in order to keep them alive?

    This was interesting. Thanks for indulging.
  • edited August 2013
    Okay this might sound crazy, but after all that shit with Supporter of Cany I think Ehkay is not a bad guy, your somehow okay now Ehkay, I never thought I would say that but its the truth.
  • edited August 2013
    Yep. As much as he tries to say how ruthless he is, in the end, he cares about characters in the game just as much as you do. Your Clem is just his Lilly and your Lilly is his Clem.
  • edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    If everyone was killed then yes there would be hell to pay. I had a hard enough time choosing between Shane and Lilly let alone the rest. Nate I do not mind dying but the rest oh hell no.

    Of course you oughta pick Shane's side!
  • edited August 2013
    If I had completed my signature then yes I would of killed them but with what I have right now they live. I still have to add Sanctuary. But I do not want to spoil them.
  • edited August 2013
    You forgot to say which one you'd shoot and which you'd hack. But anyway, interesting threshold you have there. I just wanted to get a feel for how you weighed seeking vengeance vs saving the people you like. Pleasantly surprised by the results. Good talk.
This discussion has been closed.