Show VS. Game Battle 2! Vote
You guys voted, and due to a four way tie I was forced to make the final call. The next Match up is.... CARLEY VS. ANDREA.
Remember, these votes yu cast are what decides the winner, it has almost nothing to do with their skills themselves. So before we get to the voting, here are the qualities of each contender.
Carley:
+ Is an expert shot with a pistol
+ Is tough and not willing to go down easily
- Can lose her temper
- Is awful with technology
Andrea:
+ Easily adaptable
+ Is good in combat
- Has close to no common sense (I mean really, the governor had WALKER HEADS in his office and it didnt raise her suspicon)
- Goes in over her head
Im aware that comic Andrea is much better. However this is called Show vs. Game for a reason. Will Carley get the draw on Andrea? Or will Andreas skills save her and in the end get Carley down? You decide! Let the voting commence!
CURRENT SCORE:
GAME: 1
SHOW: 0
Remember, these votes yu cast are what decides the winner, it has almost nothing to do with their skills themselves. So before we get to the voting, here are the qualities of each contender.
Carley:
+ Is an expert shot with a pistol
+ Is tough and not willing to go down easily
- Can lose her temper
- Is awful with technology
Andrea:
+ Easily adaptable
+ Is good in combat
- Has close to no common sense (I mean really, the governor had WALKER HEADS in his office and it didnt raise her suspicon)
- Goes in over her head
Im aware that comic Andrea is much better. However this is called Show vs. Game for a reason. Will Carley get the draw on Andrea? Or will Andreas skills save her and in the end get Carley down? You decide! Let the voting commence!
CURRENT SCORE:
GAME: 1
SHOW: 0
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
I haaaate tv show Andrea. Go Carley!
Am I missing something?
Nope. TV show andrea is really good for nothing, except sleeping around with bad dudes and almost killing awesome characters. So she'll either kill Carley, or sleep with her.
If it's hand to hand, Andrea has the advantage, having dispatched walkers without the use of guns, and she undoubtedly has a tougher physique.
Seeing as Carley never leaves home without her gun, bye, bye, Andrea.
Can you please drop the battery situation thing already ? It's getting old now .
Comic Andrea would beat Carley in a fight though, I think.
If carley wins, you'll like how it ends
Both are good with firearms
Neither of them have a lot of defining characteristics and abilities that make pitting them against each other an easy thing to do. I guess I would go 50/50 on this one.
You're forgetting that while Andrea from the show is good with fire arms, Carley has never missed her target.
Ill still try to make the fight interesting. Hint is no guns to start with.
I still maintain that both Carley and Andrea are both equal in terms of accuracy, and obviously it depends on the circumstances of the fight and the location, if they're both right next to each other than it doesn't matter who has superior aim, all in all it's a lot harder to discuss who would win in a fight between two ordinary human female characters than than two vastly different characters like Superman and Goku. Really both of them have average human skills and abilities and neither are exactly "stronger" than the other.
That is what I like about them, they are pretty average which makes them a little more realistic, and Goku vs Superman was a amazing fight by the way.