›

Show vs. Game vote 3!!

Flame ReaderFlame Reader
edited August 2013 in The Walking Dead
es! Its out already! No, these unfortunately wont be as frequent as this. Yes, now its time to pit up the two looney assholes who killed off suriors without consulting the group, resulting in their downfall! This is a big one everybody! LILLY! VS.! SHAAAAAAAAANE!!!!!!!!!

Lilly:
+ Very good in combat
+ Good Strategist
- Looses Temper easily
- Only looks out for herself

Shane:
+ Kills without hesitating
+ Built like a brick shithouse (Very muscular in kenny language)
- Very selfish
- IS BAT SHIT INSANE

Technically, they both have three positives in terms of entertainment Both of these horible pieces of crap, have been known as some of the most unlikable characters in he walking dead history! Which of these armed, nuts, and well trained lunatics will win? YOU DECIDE! VOTE BEGINS NOW!!!
«1

Comments

  • empoempo
    edited August 2013
    I don't like either so I will choose by saying in my opinion all of the games characters are better then the tv one Even lily
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited August 2013
    I want to see Lilly die, enough said.
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    Bioshock Infinite WD wrote: »
    I want to see Lilly die, enough said.

    so do i
  • Sick OctopusSick Octopus
    edited August 2013
    "Hey, Lilly, I tell you what, lemmemask u sumthi......" *BANG*

    In all seriousness, if no guns, Lilly hasn't got a chance unless Shane starts head-rubbing and squatting down, about to try to explain how it's gonna be.


    Ooooh, there's a video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FTiO-h5W1Ww
  • TTaing987TTaing987
    edited August 2013
    I wouldn't say Lily only looks after herself, that is before episode 3.

    She tried her best taking care of the group.
  • CornflakeDudeCornflakeDude
    edited August 2013
    I don't know if I'd call them both lunatics, I also think that Lilly did look out for people other than herself like her father, Clementine, and Lee if you sided with her, and I'm not sure if tv show Shane is really insane he just was jealous of Rick.

    I think characters like Rick and Shane stomp basically everyone in Walking Dead that we've met aside from maybe main antagonists like The Governor and Negan in a one on one fight because they have police training which makes them better than most civilians when engaged in a firefight. Obviously again it depends on circumstances and location.
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    CornflakeDude wrote: »
    I don't know if I'd call them both lunatics, I also think that Lilly did look out for people other than herself like her father, Clementine, and Lee if you sided with her, and I'm not sure if tv show Shane is really insane he just was jealous of Rick.

    I think characters like Rick and Shane stomp basically everyone in Walking Dead that we've met aside from maybe main antagonists like The Governor and Negan in a one on one fight because they have police training which makes them better than most civilians when engaged in a firefight. Obviously again it depends on circumstances and location.

    Id say the episode where he killed that hostage kind of cemented him as insane for me.
  • TTaing987TTaing987
    edited August 2013
    I voted Shane because that one time he left a guy to get eaten by walkers.

    EDIT: and when he slept with Lori. People called him Scumbag Shane for a reason.
  • DildorDildor
    edited August 2013
    Bioshock Infinite WD wrote: »
    I want to see Lilly die, enough said.

    This. Why are you guys voting for Lilly?! :D

    Kidding.
  • BubbaFightsUnlimitedBubbaFightsUnlimited
    edited August 2013
    Bioshock Infinite WD wrote: »
    I want to see Lilly die, enough said.

    Same here.
  • Sick OctopusSick Octopus
    edited August 2013
    I'm surprised by the poll.

    Lilly's not going to fair well hand to hand with a strapping ex-cop with a penchant for fisticuffs and neck snapping. Unless, of course, Shane becomes distracted by his own ego.
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited August 2013
    Really, Lilly is winning what are you doing, let her die.
  • Sick OctopusSick Octopus
    edited August 2013
    Bioshock Infinite WD wrote: »
    Really, Lilly is winning what are you doing, let her die.

    Ah, well, at least a few of us are being realistic about it.
  • Rock114Rock114
    edited August 2013
    That depends, is Shane looking in her direction when the fight starts? Cause if not...

    Kidding! Kidding, Lilly fans. I'm actually not sure WHO to vote for in this. Leaving slightly toward Shane, though.
  • EhkayEhkay
    edited August 2013
    No! I can't choose! Lilly...Shane...Lilly...Shane I can't :(.
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    I voted forShane. Ive seen Shane get his karma hit him already (even if it wasnt the version i was hoping where walkers got him while rick repeatedly shot him in the groin area) so now i want to see lilly go.
  • Sick OctopusSick Octopus
    edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    No! I can't choose! Lilly...Shane...Lilly...Shane I can't :(.

    You can do it, Ehkay.

    Go with the neck-breaker!
  • EhkayEhkay
    edited August 2013
    But...But... Lilly!...but Shane GRRRR!
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    this is probably the first installment with a real tough decision
  • EhkayEhkay
    edited August 2013
    Grr.
  • EhkayEhkay
    edited August 2013
    There I had to do it now I will not be able to sleep tonight.
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    There I had to do it now I will not be able to sleep tonight.

    you have ade a good choice *evil laugh*
  • EhkayEhkay
    edited August 2013
    I had to pick Shane he was behind and he was my first favorite but poor Lilly I just can't I will watch the Lilly vs Shane fight with a box of Kleenex :( .

    Rip Shane/Lilly :(.
  • Sick OctopusSick Octopus
    edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    I had to pick Shane he was behind and he was my first favorite but poor Lilly I just can't I will watch the Lilly vs Shane fight with a box of Kleenex :( .

    Rip Shane/Lilly :(.

    epic-hugs-friends-sherlock.gif
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    I had to pick Shane he was behind and he was my first favorite but poor Lilly I just can't I will watch the Lilly vs Shane fight with a box of Kleenex :( .

    Rip Shane/Lilly :(.

    well either one who loses i will be satisfied with. but lilly id be more happy
  • Sick OctopusSick Octopus
    edited August 2013
    You did good.
  • Sick OctopusSick Octopus
    edited August 2013
    Ben Paul is online. EVERYONE HOLD ONTO YOUR BUTTS.



    http://www.telltalegames.com/forums/member.php?u=535813 I love it.
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited August 2013
    shane would win, and that poll is confusing which one do i select the one that dies or the one that wins?
  • EhkayEhkay
    edited August 2013
    Who wins I believe
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    Who wins I believe

    damn it's basically tied i need confirmation
  • TTaing987TTaing987
    edited August 2013
    you select the person who should kill the other person

    that is how it is with the other threads :)
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited August 2013
    KILL HER, yes it's tied at the moment.
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited August 2013
    TTaing987 wrote: »
    you select the person who should kill the other person

    that is how it is with the other threads :)

    done now but had to make sure because it was close, next time though the questions should be who wins, because the confusing part what which who am i answering, the first or the second? is it who will kill lilly so i pick shane, or is it Shane will kill who so i pick lilly.

    anyway lilly and shane both trained people with weapons, but no matter what i think of lilly i think she would have a straight fight but shane would cheat at any chance he got, and if it was a fist fight lilly would have no chance she doesn't even know kung fu like all weaker people (in tv,movies, and games) need to know so it doesn't seem ridiculous that they even had a chance.

    edit: Lilly is winning and that is just wrong, it isn't a fair fight she would definitely lose, except for random luck in a gun fight
    look what he did to this guy (his greatest moment)
    http://youtu.be/krliwLJN5hE
  • EhkayEhkay
    edited August 2013
    Bioshock Infinite WD wrote: »
    KILL HER, yes it's tied at the moment.

    Excuse me I'm going to cry myself to a 5 minute nap :(.

    RIP Shane/Lilly
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    thestalkinghead wrote: »
    done now but had to make sure because it was close, next time though the questions should be who wins, because the confusing part what which who am i answering, the first or the second? is it who will kill lilly so i pick shane, or is it Shane will kill who so i pick lilly.

    anyway lilly and shane both trained people with weapons, but no matter what i think of lilly i think she would have a straight fight but shane would cheat at any chance he got, and if it was a fist fight lilly would have no chance she doesn't even know kung fu like all weaker people (in tv,movies, and games) need to know so it doesn't seem ridiculous that they even had a chance.

    edit: Lilly is winning and that is just wrong, it isn't a fair fight she would definitely lose, except for random luck in a gun fight
    look what he did to this guy (his greatest moment)
    http://youtu.be/krliwLJN5hE

    yea sorry :P
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited August 2013
    i guess shane may lose if he hesitates about killing a woman, and Lilly takes that oportunity to kill him
  • Sick OctopusSick Octopus
    edited August 2013
    thestalkinghead wrote: »

    edit: Lilly is winning and that is just wrong, it isn't a fair fight she would definitely lose, except for random luck in a gun fight
    look what he did to this guy (his greatest moment)
    http://youtu.be/krliwLJN5hE

    I cheered him on. All that anger and frustration re: the Lori situation, and Ed copped it right in his face.

    Knowing what Carol later alludes to in the church in S2 re: Sophia, I kinda wished he'd finished him right there. Of course, then we wouldn't have had that gory scene with the axe which was almost cathartic for Carol.
  • Sick OctopusSick Octopus
    edited August 2013
    thestalkinghead wrote: »
    i guess shane may lose if he hesitates about killing a woman, and Lilly takes that oportunity to kill him

    Yeah.

    There's got to be some hesitation or distraction to make it in any way realistic.
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited August 2013
    Sick Octopus wrote: »
    I cheered him on. All that anger and frustration re: the Lori situation, and Ed copped it right in his face.

    Knowing what Carol later alludes to in the church in S2 re: Sophia, I kinda wished he'd finished him right there. Of course, then we wouldn't have had that gory scene with the axe which was almost cathartic for Carol.

    that scene demonstrates why you would need guys like Shane in the apocalypse, that is until he went full psycho, never go full psycho
  • DildorDildor
    edited August 2013
    Rock114 wrote: »
    That depends, is Shane looking in her direction when the fight starts? Cause if not...


    Rofl. :p
This discussion has been closed.