›

SHOW VS. GAME IS BACK! Who's next?

Flame ReaderFlame Reader
edited August 2013 in The Walking Dead
Yup! Its time to start these fights once again! This time, I need you guys to decide the match ups!

You guys have 5 hours to recomend and discuss match ups for the rest of season 1 of Show vs. Game.

Here are the rules:

1. No two characters from show or game can be pitted up against each other, only 1 character from show and 1 from game

2. Merle, Nate, Becca, Carl, Roman, and Phillip can't be picked, as they will eventually end up in the 400 days special episodes

3. No characters that were picked already. Especially not the dead ones. Winners will fight another day (Le season 2 foreshadow)

4. Please dont recommend situations where the game will obviously win

Ok guys! you may begin!!! Its all up to the audience on who shall fight who!

UPDATE: I need at least 8 match ups

CURRENT SUGGESTIONS:

1. Doug vs. Milton
2. Hershel vs. Chuck
3. Rick vs. Lee
4. Beth vs. Katjaa
5. Ben (show) vs. Ben (game)
6. Carol vs. Christa
7. Tdog vs. Omid
8. Chet vs. Ottis
9. Nelly the horse from ep.1 vs. Maybelle
10. Maggie vs. Danny St. John
11. Carol vs. Brenda
12. Glenn (show/ late ZA) vs. Glenn (game/ early ZA)
13. Andy vs. Tyreese
14. Glenn vs. Russel
15. Lori vs. Stranger
16. Rick vs. Justin
17. Big Tiny vs. Larry
18. Shel vs. Karen
19. Danny (400 days) vs. Oscar
20. Wyatt vs. Morales
21. Wyatt vs. Jim
22. Eddie vs. Jim
23. Bonnie vs. Lori
24. Dale vs. Vernon
25. Dale vs. Katja
26. Maybelle vs. Sigards family horse
«1

Comments

  • Ben PaulBen Paul
    edited August 2013
    Doug VS Milton! Who's with me!?
  • BubbaFightsUnlimitedBubbaFightsUnlimited
    edited August 2013
    Not me.
    Ben vs. The Governor.
    Be ready to fight, Shaggy.
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    BubbaFightsUnlimited wrote: »
    Not me.
    Ben vs. The Governor.
    Be ready to fight, Shaggy.

    Philip is the governor, sorry fella
  • CrixusCrixus
    edited August 2013
    Herschel vs Chuck?
    Glenn vs Glenn? :D
    Rick vs Lee?
    Carl vs Clementine?
    Maggie vs Carley?
    Beth vs Katjaa?
    Judith vs Ben?
    Walker#7 vs Ben?
    Blade of Grass vs Ben?
    Ben vs Ben?
    Doug vs Milton?
    Martinez vs Kenny?
    Sophia vs Clem?
    Carol vs Christa?
    T-dog vs Omid?
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    Crixus wrote: »
    Herschel vs Chuck?
    Glenn vs Glenn? :D
    Rick vs Lee?
    Carl vs Clementine?
    Maggie vs Carley?
    Beth vs Katjaa?
    Judith vs Ben?
    Walker#7 vs Ben?
    Blade of Grass vs Ben?
    Ben vs Ben?

    Glenn vs. Glenn
    Rick vs. Lee
    and Beth vs. Katjaa all acceptable

    also ben vs. ben after looking it up :P

    and carol vs. christa, and tdog vs. omid :P
  • ZacTBZacTB
    edited August 2013
    I think Season 3 Maggie vs. Lilly would be a very tough competition.

    Maggie kicked all kinds of ass in Season 3, and Lilly is obviously very capable especially with that rifle.
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    ZacTB wrote: »
    I think Season 3 Maggie vs. Lilly would be a very tough competition.

    Maggie kicked all kinds of ass in Season 3, and Lilly is obviously very capable especially with that rifle.

    Lilly was in show vs. game already
  • Ben PaulBen Paul
    edited August 2013
    Speaking of S2, Katjaa VS Lori would be interesting. Of course, Katjaa's parenting skills are much much MUCH better.

    Campman VS Governor
    Doug VS Milton
    Lee VS Rick
    Chet VS Otis
    Maybelle VS Nelly the Horse or the Horse from S1E1

    The possibilities are endless...
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    Ben Paul wrote: »
    Speaking of S2, Katjaa VS Lori would be interesting. Of course, Katjaa's parenting skills are much much MUCH better.

    Campman VS Governor
    Doug VS Milton
    Lee VS Rick
    Chet VS Otis
    Maybelle VS Nelly the Horse or the Horse from S1E1

    The possibilities are endless...

    ...Im counting Maybelle vs. Nelly XD
  • Ben PaulBen Paul
    edited August 2013
    The horse from Days Gone Bye and Nelly are the same horse.
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    Ben Paul wrote: »
    The horse from Days Gone Bye and Nelly are the same horse.

    i knows :P

    In two more hours voting will begin for who you want to see in the rest of SHOW VS. GAME
  • Ben PaulBen Paul
    edited August 2013
    I felt bad for the horse in Days Gone Bye. :(
  • ZacTBZacTB
    edited August 2013
    Sorry I misread, I thought winners of previous fights were allowed, I like the ideas that people have already posted:

    Carol vs Christa
    Hershel vs Chuck
    Omid vs T-Dog
    Lee vs Rick

    Or what about these:

    Danny St. John vs Maggie
    Brenda vs Carol
    The Stranger vs Dale
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    ZacTB wrote: »
    Sorry I misread, I thought winners of previous fights were allowed, I like the ideas that people have already posted:

    Carol vs Christa
    Hershel vs Chuck
    Omid vs T-Dog
    Lee vs Rick

    Or what about these:

    Danny St. John vs Maggie
    Brenda vs Carol
    The Stranger vs Dale

    I wont count the last one, seeing as how show dale was purely morale in the group on the show. He never really did anything violent or even showed any strategy towards it like doug did. He just was the morale, so I dont think ill accept suggestions with Dale. But the other two, HELL YEA
  • ZacTBZacTB
    edited August 2013
    Flame Reader wrote: »
    I wont count the last one, seeing as how show dale was purely morale in the group on the show. He never really did anything violent or even showed any strategy towards it like doug did. He just was the morale, so I dont think ill accept suggestions with Dale. But the other two, HELL YEA

    He did carry that rifle though, and he did kill some walkers. I just never got the feeling The Stranger was that good at fighting (Lee can beat him in a fist fight with one arm lol). I get what you mean though, Dale was rarely seen fighting walkers, let alone other humans.

    Edit: Glad you like the others!
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    ZacTB wrote: »
    He did carry that rifle though, and he did kill some walkers. I just never got the feeling The Stranger was that good at fighting (Lee can beat him in a fist fight with one arm lol). I get what you mean though, Dale was rarely seen fighting walkers, let alone other humans.

    Edit: Glad you like the others!

    honestly i dont get enough suggestions involving the st.johns
  • ZacTBZacTB
    edited August 2013
    Flame Reader wrote: »
    honestly i dont get enough suggestions involving the st.johns

    We need to think of one for Andy as well.

    What about Andy vs Tyreese? Or Andy vs Morgan?
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    tyreese. there's more meat on him XD
  • zev_zevzev_zev
    edited August 2013
    Glenn vs Russel
  • ZacTBZacTB
    edited August 2013
    Flame Reader wrote: »
    tyreese. there's more meat on him XD

    Lol yeah, can't wait to see Tyreese as a proper main character in Season 4!
  • CrixusCrixus
    edited August 2013
    ZacTB wrote: »
    He did carry that rifle though, and he did kill some walkers. I just never got the feeling The Stranger was that good at fighting (Lee can beat him in a fist fight with one arm lol). I get what you mean though, Dale was rarely seen fighting walkers, let alone other humans.

    Edit: Glad you like the others!

    Dale Killed one walker in the whole series although he killed it alongside two others,in season 1 when they find the walker in the bushes outside camp all 3 bash it's head in.It's around when you first meet Daryl.So you could say Dale killed 0.33% walkers. Lol
  • Ben PaulBen Paul
    edited August 2013
    @Flame Reader

    This is basically what would happen if you pit a human character against Maybelle.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d4QL2lfoh5w
  • CrixusCrixus
    edited August 2013
    ZacTB wrote: »
    Lol yeah, can't wait to see Tyreese as a proper main character in Season 4!

    He's my favourite comic book character,hope he doesn't have the same interaction with the govenor in the show that he had in the comics though if you know what I mean.
  • Ben PaulBen Paul
    edited August 2013
    Cany0udance wrote: »
    I would love:

    -Ben Vs. Governorr (since Ben stands no chance)
    -Stranger Vs. Lori (Both bad at hand to hand)
    -Justin Vs. Rick (lulz)

    Ben will probably find a way to accidentally kill the Governor. Watch.
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    Ben Paul wrote: »
    @Flame Reader

    This is basically what would happen if you pit a human character against Maybelle.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d4QL2lfoh5w

    With the exception of the look of the CG cow, looks like a good movie.
  • ZacTBZacTB
    edited August 2013
    Crixus wrote: »
    Dale Killed one walker in the whole series although he killed it alongside two others,in season 1 when they find the walker in the bushes outside camp all 3 bash it's head in.It's around when you first meet Daryl.So you could say Dale killed 0.33% walkers. Lol

    Haha guess I didn't prove my point well? I thought he killed some when when leaving the CDC but he can't have as he left later on with Andrea just as it exploded.
    Crixus wrote: »
    He's my favourite comic book character,hope he doesn't have the same interaction with the govenor in the show that he had in the comics though if you know what I mean.

    Yeah same here, and I agree I think
    it would be a waste to get rid of him that quickly, as it looks like the Governor's story arc will end this season possibly. And Robert Kirkman said he always regretted killing of Tyreese that early, and that the TV show is an opportunity for him to change some variables in the comics like Rick's hand. I think Tyreese might be safe for a bit :D
  • CrixusCrixus
    edited August 2013
    ZacTB wrote: »
    Haha guess I didn't prove my point well? I thought he killed some when when leaving the CDC but he can't have as he left later on with Andrea just as it exploded.



    Yeah same here, and I agree I think
    it would be a waste to get rid of him that quickly, as it looks like the Governor's story arc will end this season possibly. And Robert Kirkman said he always regretted killing of Tyreese that early, and that the TV show is an opportunity for him to change some variables in the comics like Rick's hand. I think Tyreese might be safe for a bit :D

    Yeah because he had hardly any development in season 3,i'd be happy for him to be around until season 5 or 6 hopefully.
    I can't wait to see his fight with Rick which was alluded to in the trailer and his epic hammer scene also he may have a romance with Michonne aswell like in the comics.
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    ZacTB wrote: »
    Haha guess I didn't prove my point well? I thought he killed some when when leaving the CDC but he can't have as he left later on with Andrea just as it exploded.



    Yeah same here, and I agree I think
    it would be a waste to get rid of him that quickly, as it looks like the Governor's story arc will end this season possibly. And Robert Kirkman said he always regretted killing of Tyreese that early, and that the TV show is an opportunity for him to change some variables in the comics like Rick's hand. I think Tyreese might be safe for a bit :D

    chnge some things from the comic? how about.... LILLY
  • CrixusCrixus
    edited August 2013
    Flame Reader wrote: »
    chnge some things from the comic? how about.... LILLY

    I think Karen is taking Lily's place in the show.
  • DomeWing333DomeWing333
    edited August 2013
    Vernon vs Dale
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    DomeWing333 wrote: »
    Vernon vs Dale

    Vernon: Beats the living crap out of people for a boat

    Dale: Keeps others from killing hostages
  • Sick OctopusSick Octopus
    edited August 2013
    Ben Paul wrote: »
    Doug VS Milton! Who's with me!?

    Given I suggested it, yes.
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    One more hour guys, then no more suggestions and on to voting
  • CrixusCrixus
    edited August 2013
    Dale would take the boat away and try and hide it. Lol
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    Also, just because there are 400 days specials, doesnt mean I dont accept characters from 400 days, only the ones im using for the specials
  • CrixusCrixus
    edited August 2013
    Oscar VS Kenny?
    Thomas VS Lily?
  • Sick OctopusSick Octopus
    edited August 2013
    Flame Reader wrote: »
    Vernon: Beats the living crap out of people for a boat

    Dale: Keeps others from killing hostages


    I'm hoping for Dale to go all Kung Lao with his bucket hat ;)
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    Crixus wrote: »
    Oscar VS Kenny?
    Thomas VS Lily?

    both kenny and lilly have been in the fights already. Sorry :(
  • Sick OctopusSick Octopus
    edited August 2013
    Big Tiny v Larry.

    Bulk for bulk.
  • ZacTBZacTB
    edited August 2013
    What about:

    Vince vs Glenn or Vince vs Morgan
    Danny (in Vince's story) vs Oscar
    Shel vs Karen
This discussion has been closed.