the Penny Arcade game
Jake
Telltale Alumni
Has anyone been playing the Penny Arcade game? I'm a few hours in and enjoying it a lot more than I thought I would. I usually can't stand turn-based games, but the combat system they have has kept me on my toes and decidedly un-bored. Also I have been beating up mimes and collecting hobo meat--always a plus. And, not surprisingly, the writing and story are fun, especially, I imagine, if you like the comics. It's always nice to play a game that really wants to entertain me, instead of beat me over the head with how bad-ass it's trying to be.
I feel like I should say more, but that's all really. Wondering if anyone else has checked it out, and what they thought?
I feel like I should say more, but that's all really. Wondering if anyone else has checked it out, and what they thought?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
I really enjoy turn-based combat, but I don't get too much exposure to it since I usually stick to adventure games. It's nice to have an RPG other than Final Fantasy to play.
About the game itself, I have relatively few complaints. It looks great, it plays smoothly, the humor in the dialogue is fantastic. The gameplay is a bit straightforward and there isn't much adventuring (as in: exploration, puzzling, et cetera) to do, but it's fun nonetheless.
:eek: That's the best part!
It's funny, but at some points it starts to feel long-winded...
You've successfully summed up Penny Arcade.
The atmosphere is great, the comic style is cool. I love the 1920's setting too. The
It's a little stressful because there are
The little bit I played, I have to agree the dialogue gets quite long (but at least they give you the option of skipping through it).
You know, it's funny. But I really do like Penny Arcade, and yet... it's never really been hilarious to me. Sure, there's a grin now and then, but I don't find myself laughing constantly. It's the same for the game. I really like the game. Actually, I'm kindof fond of their story arc. But it's never really been "OMG that's hilarious."
I am also kinda disappointed with the price. $20 seems like a bit much for any episodic game that isn't Half Life 2. :P
It would have been a daring choice at this point to cast voices for Gabe and Tycho. Based on the hit or miss voice reads of the narrator I think they made the right choice to not go overboard with voice in the game.
Yeah, that's what I ended up realizing. It would have been awful if they had chosen voice actors that sucked at the part. I do love the narrator though (both his lines and his accent). It makes you forget the fact that none of the characters are speaking. :P
The combat and collection stretch things out and keep you engaged, but there's hardly ever so much of it to be tedious. It's just complicated enough to keep you involved, without going ridiculously overboard. The combat is a little too reliant on mini-games for my taste (and I could never pull off the one for Gabe). And with all the blocks, items, counter-attacks, resistances and so on, I felt like it kept flipping between having to wait forever for something to happen, and feeling like there was too much going on and I had no control. But once you learn that unlike the Final Fantasy games, there's a near-infinite supply of items, so you should use them frequently, it's pretty fun.
I'll definitely check out episode 2, at least.
Yeah, that was definitely a wise choice. For one thing, they avoided the problems with casting "official" voices for characters that wouldn't jibe with what people imagined. And also, most of the lines would only work in print, and having to hear those voiced would've gotten super-tedious. Being long-winded and overwrought is Tycho's whole schtick.
I still prefer CAD to PA, though. Say what you will about Tim Buckley, but he cracks me up.
(Speaking of CAD, I demand a Chef Brian game.)
In fact, I found the dialogue surprisingly lightfooted, considering that it's written by the same guy that writes the news posts for Penny Arcade, which often tend to drag on and be a bit too wordy for my taste.
the price may prove to become a little problem however. it's not that i can't or don't want to afford 20$ per episode, but i am not sure if your average casual gamer will pay roughly 80$ for all four episodes and they may end up with only the die hard fans buying everything...but, we'll see.
oh yeah, what about these archivments, are they console-only?
I have nothing against combat. If combat (or stealth) pops up in an adventure game, I like it as it's something a little exciting to do. But it's nice when it's over and you have some time to relax and explore. I liked the game, but I'm afraid it'll get tedious for me and I won't finish it. Maybe an RPG isn't for me, possibly. Sorry for this long and slightly angsty post.
Combat never seems to slow down from there, as I played all the way through the demo and the combat was pretty frequent. However, I enjoyed it because the battle system was so well done, kind of like a cross between games like Shadow Hearts, Final Fantasy, and the Mario RPG games.
also, some combat is optional, like when you want to find all parts for your weapons or do all side-quests...but still it's the main aspect of the game, besides the story.
I've not played it myself yet, but I'm not really a fan of PA.
First, I found out I still hate turn-based combat (It's been ages since the last time I played an RPG). But I already expected that, I thought I would forgive those parts for the adventure elements and funny storyline.
Anyway, it turns out I found the comedy to be meh at best, and the only adventure elements where 'click to move' and the dialog trees, which, if you don't find funny, are pretty worthless.
I kind of did the same with the Sam and Max games. Played episode 4 of season 1 and bought all of Season 1 in one of the bundles. Kudos to TTG for making Sam and Max fun. Now all I have to do is save money for Season 2.
Hey, sorry for the ugly question, but with this bug, it has to be asked.
Did you, in fact, pirate the game?
Because sources tell me that the number one best way to get this bug is to do so.
Nope, it's legit. But, I redownloaded it, and it works fine now. So no worries.
Yeah. Sorry. Terms of Use != License Agreement.
You can probably view the EULA from the demo copy, but in any case, it says that you're limited to 3 installs at a time, although they make it very clear that it's easy to get more if you email them.