So, you want to hear Clementine singing? Wish fulfilled, her voice actor sang in Back to The Future The Game, another game by Telltale.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dJ3MSqeoFs
I don't watch the TV series much at all, and with different art styles, different actors, and a completely different story it could be done completely different. Look up at the Viva-La-Lee and DomeWing333 thread for some good ideas.
Maybe her singing a nursery rhyme or something (Maybe to Rebecca's baby, if it lives?) Full out singing would make me cringe a lil bit too much though.
I'd be fine with her humming a little bit (maybe humming a theme tune from a different telltale game or something) but full-on singing would be out of place and a bit stupid.
And this would only be once she got out of her spiralling depression.
I'd be fine with her humming a little bit (maybe humming a theme tune from a different telltale game or something) but full-on singing would be out of place and a bit stupid.
And this would only be once she got out of her spiralling depression.
nope, This is The Walking Dead, not a Disney movie.
This is not a world ,where you randomly burst out in to songs, and have animals singing a… morelong, and walkers thriller dancing in
the background .Nope, singing attracts walkers, and other bad things.
Mhm, mhm, mhm... so how does singing make it anything like a Disney movie? A scared girl, singing to a scared baby, in the middle of a ZA.. don't think Disney has even considered that one.
I think people are getting the idea that this would be Clem randomly bursting out into song for no reason. That would be dumb and out of place.
But imagine a scene like this:
Clem and Sarah are in a hideout somewhere. Rebecca's baby starts crying (Rebecca herself is either dead or...no actually she's just dead). Clem starts panicking because she thinks that the crying is going to attract walkers. Sarah suggests Clem calms it down by singing to it because it worked in a book she read. Initially, Clem's like "No way, that's stupid! You do it!" but then Sarah tells Clem that she doesn't know any lullabies because her father never sang to her.
Clem thinks for a bit, breathes an exasperated sigh, and then 4 options appear on the screen: "Happy song," "Sad song," "Bittersweet song," and "Refuse to sing." Say you choose the bittersweet one. Clem starts hesitantly singing "You Are My Sunshine" in a quiet voice. Her singing is a bit weak and shaky, but has a pure and sweet quality to it. After she finishes, Sarah turns to her and asks Clem how she remembered all the words even though she must have been so young when her mother sang it to her. Clem looks down sadly and tells her that she didn't hear it from her mother and that it wasn't sung to her. She heard it from Christa.
Mhm, mhm, mhm... so how does singing make it anything like a Disney movie? A scared girl, singing to a scared baby, in the middle of a ZA.. don't think Disney has even considered that one.
Wow..... that was a beautiful scene...... You are much better at conveying ideas than I. Would the mods be angry if I opened a new thread the same as this one (and let this one die) and used ^ this ^ as the information (or you could, I just want the idea to be out there)? This post has to many people on it with the wrong idea...
I think people are getting the idea that this would be Clem randomly bursting out into song for no reason. That would be dumb and out of place… more.
But imagine a scene like this:
Clem and Sarah are in a hideout somewhere. Rebecca's baby starts crying (Rebecca herself is either dead or...no actually she's just dead). Clem starts panicking because she thinks that the crying is going to attract walkers. Sarah suggests Clem calms it down by singing to it because it worked in a book she read. Initially, Clem's like "No way, that's stupid! You do it!" but then Sarah tells Clem that she doesn't know any lullabies because her father never sang to her.
Clem thinks for a bit, breathes an exasperated sigh, and then 4 options appear on the screen: "Happy song," "Sad song," "Bittersweet song," and "Refuse to sing." Say you choose the bittersweet one. Clem starts hesitantly singing "You Are My Sunshine" in a quiet voice. Her singing is a bit weak and sha… [view original content]
Wow..... that was a beautiful scene...... You are much better at conveying ideas than I. Would the mods be angry if I opened a new thread the … moresame as this one (and let this one die) and used ^ this ^ as the information (or you could, I just want the idea to be out there)? This post has to many people on it with the wrong idea...
I don't understand why so many people get the idea of a Disney movie. I personally think it would be extremely sweet if Clementine and Sarah were together in some kind of shelter. Sarah has been bitten and Clementine is about to put her down. But Sarah has one last wish, she wants Clementine to sing the nursery rhyme her deceased mom always sang to her. Clementine knows the song and hesitantly agrees.
She starts singing quietly and with some cracks in her voice, but steadily improves her pitch. The scene ends with Sarah closing her eyes or even her collapsing like Lee does if you leave him in the end of season one. Clementine recognizes the situation and either kills or leaves Sarah depending on your choice in the aforementioned ending of season one.
And that is just one of many scenarios which would deem arguments like: ''It doesn't fit the walking dead.'' false.
Wow..... that was a beautiful scene...... You are much better at conveying ideas than I. Would the mods be angry if I opened a new thread the … moresame as this one (and let this one die) and used ^ this ^ as the information (or you could, I just want the idea to be out there)? This post has to many people on it with the wrong idea...
I was actually a bit skeptical of it myself at first but after some thought, I could definitely see it fitting. I guess the way to go about is by making it so Clem doesn't want to sing, but has to.
Comments
So, you want to hear Clementine singing? Wish fulfilled, her voice actor sang in Back to The Future The Game, another game by Telltale.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dJ3MSqeoFs
She isn't that bad of a singer actually, it just wouldn't be fitting for the walking dead.
If this happens I will boycott The Walking Dead. What, are we going to have a musical episode next?
They tried this in the TV show and it was painful to watch.
Hare Hare Yukai - Survivor Edition
What if it was the group singing this song? Lol
Click here
I enjoyed it.
Not the same, all of those say Back to the Future, not Walking Dead.
I don't watch the TV series much at all, and with different art styles, different actors, and a completely different story it could be done completely different. Look up at the Viva-La-Lee and DomeWing333 thread for some good ideas.
So how does singing softly to a newborn baby who is facing certain death go against TWD's theme? Talk about sad...
So how does singing softly to a newborn baby who is facing certain death go against TWD's theme? Talk about sad...
Ending: "Please, don't take my sunshine away." Zombie walks in...
Maybe her singing a nursery rhyme or something (Maybe to Rebecca's baby, if it lives?) Full out singing would make me cringe a lil bit too much though.
True, but it's the same voice actor who's singing those.
No, it could be sung to the baby. Imagine "You are my sunshine" being sung in a low tone to a baby that is facing certain death. That, is sad.
Singing in a low tone to a baby (Rebecca's) that is surely facing certain death? That is far from Disney...
Because The Walking Dead is not a Disney movie.
I'm just curious why you don't think it would fit into the story.
Mhm, mhm, mhm... so how does singing make it anything like a Disney movie? A scared girl, singing to a scared baby, in the middle of a ZA.. don't think Disney has even considered that one.
I think people are getting the idea that this would be Clem randomly bursting out into song for no reason. That would be dumb and out of place.
But imagine a scene like this:
Clem and Sarah are in a hideout somewhere. Rebecca's baby starts crying (Rebecca herself is either dead or...no actually she's just dead). Clem starts panicking because she thinks that the crying is going to attract walkers. Sarah suggests Clem calms it down by singing to it because it worked in a book she read. Initially, Clem's like "No way, that's stupid! You do it!" but then Sarah tells Clem that she doesn't know any lullabies because her father never sang to her.
Clem thinks for a bit, breathes an exasperated sigh, and then 4 options appear on the screen: "Happy song," "Sad song," "Bittersweet song," and "Refuse to sing." Say you choose the bittersweet one. Clem starts hesitantly singing "You Are My Sunshine" in a quiet voice. Her singing is a bit weak and shaky, but has a pure and sweet quality to it. After she finishes, Sarah turns to her and asks Clem how she remembered all the words even though she must have been so young when her mother sang it to her. Clem looks down sadly and tells her that she didn't hear it from her mother and that it wasn't sung to her. She heard it from Christa.
It just seems so cheesy to do it.
Wow..... that was a beautiful scene...... You are much better at conveying ideas than I. Would the mods be angry if I opened a new thread the same as this one (and let this one die) and used ^ this ^ as the information (or you could, I just want the idea to be out there)? This post has to many people on it with the wrong idea...
Scroll down to DomeWing333's post at the bottom, they had a better way to put it than I could have come up with.
Thanks, man. You could just edit the thread title and original post if you wanted to.
That's... kind of beautiful...
I don't understand why so many people get the idea of a Disney movie. I personally think it would be extremely sweet if Clementine and Sarah were together in some kind of shelter. Sarah has been bitten and Clementine is about to put her down. But Sarah has one last wish, she wants Clementine to sing the nursery rhyme her deceased mom always sang to her. Clementine knows the song and hesitantly agrees.
She starts singing quietly and with some cracks in her voice, but steadily improves her pitch. The scene ends with Sarah closing her eyes or even her collapsing like Lee does if you leave him in the end of season one. Clementine recognizes the situation and either kills or leaves Sarah depending on your choice in the aforementioned ending of season one.
And that is just one of many scenarios which would deem arguments like: ''It doesn't fit the walking dead.'' false.
Maybe change the title to something like "Clem's Lullaby" to make it more clear the kind of mood that you're going for right away?
Maybe, maybe not.
But I don't think the Walking Dead should be turned into 'Little Orphan Clemmie' either way.
This is actually a great idea if you think about it.
Done! Also I have two other "idea" posts. You should check them out and tell me if you agree or disagree, and why.
http://www.telltalegames.com/community/discussion/56556/the-baby-
http://www.telltalegames.com/community/discussion/55735/i-really-want-to-see-this
I was actually a bit skeptical of it myself at first but after some thought, I could definitely see it fitting. I guess the way to go about is by making it so Clem doesn't want to sing, but has to.
Can I just say this is seriously an awesome idea. I'd love to see that =3
You just ruined the game.
The picture ruined the game? =S I thought it was amusing :P
No! Clem should not sing! Badasses don't sing! Did Mel Gibson sing? How about Arnold Schwarzenegger? NEVER!
It will live, at least for a little while. Probably... maybe.
Wait... were either of them an 11 year old girl? :P
No, but they fall under the category of "badass" though :P
Funny you should bring up Mel Gibson, an actor who has actually sung in a Disney musical
And Mel Gibson Badass? Really?