Ben. He fucked so many things up, it's impossible to describe them all without a long wall of text. It doesn't make it any better that he did nothing to help throught the game (He could have just told the group that the bandits are threatening him and the group, it's not like the bandits would hear about that.) Hell, an 9 year old was a 100 times more useful then him and that shows something. That doesn't mean i didn't save him in the bell tower though, i'm not a total dickwad but still, Ben stuck around, caused trouble then died with the only thing he properly achieved was standing up to Kenny, which didn't do much good eitherway.
It's tought to choose between Lily And Ben, but i have more mixed feelings towards Lily while towards Ben they are all negative,
Lilly killed Carley (or tries to kill Ben) deliberately. That will always make her a worse person, but nobody can touch Ben's knack for horrific and deadly errors. Hell he even gets partially credit for Lilly's murder, since he was the real thief.
Comments
Obviously lilly
Lilly because she shot Carley...
For the most impactful and shocking kill: Lilly.
For the quantity of people that was killed due to ineptitude: Ben.
Ben. He fucked so many things up, it's impossible to describe them all without a long wall of text. It doesn't make it any better that he did nothing to help throught the game (He could have just told the group that the bandits are threatening him and the group, it's not like the bandits would hear about that.) Hell, an 9 year old was a 100 times more useful then him and that shows something. That doesn't mean i didn't save him in the bell tower though, i'm not a total dickwad but still, Ben stuck around, caused trouble then died with the only thing he properly achieved was standing up to Kenny, which didn't do much good eitherway.
It's tought to choose between Lily And Ben, but i have more mixed feelings towards Lily while towards Ben they are all negative,
Ben, he left to die 8 old girl and run away. He fucked too many times.
Lilly. At least Ben never intentionally killed someone from the group.
Ethically or in terms of damage done?
Lilly killed Carley (or tries to kill Ben) deliberately. That will always make her a worse person, but nobody can touch Ben's knack for horrific and deadly errors. Hell he even gets partially credit for Lilly's murder, since he was the real thief.