Another idea I have.
Clementine joins a cult in episode 4 which is strict but protects her. The cult is always being attacked by Tavias ca… moremp, and many members of the cult die because of this. The cult decides to go to war with Tavias camp. All the 400 days characters you brought as Tavia will be there. So the more people that came, the harder the war.
This decision is only there if Shel and Becca came. Becca and Clementine fight and Clementine ends up stabbing her in the chest. Becca lays there dying and Shel comes and tries to kill Clem but another cult member rescues her by killing Shel. Becca lays on the floor dying, decision:
Leave her OR shoot her.
This would satisfy all those who hate Becca and want her to die!
How about this : Carver has Luke locked up in a cell , And since he wanted to kill Clementine Kenny betrayed him and helped her and the other members of the group scape from him so he wants to kill Kenny as well , KENNY or LUKE ?
Lilly and Kenny are both in danger. Kenny has no ammo and is fighting off several walers with the butt of his rifle, then a walker grabs it an… mored he is struggeling with more close in on him. Kenny screams for Clementine help. Lilly, is shooting walkers with a pistol but it has very low ammo, a walker takes her from behind and floors her as she struggles to get it off her. Which one do you choose?
Save Kenny - Clementine runs over and shoots the walker attacking Kenny and persists at shooting the others closing in on him. Kenny thanks Clem and finishes the rest off with his rifle, both look over at Lilly. Lilly is struggling as walkers close in and finally gets it off her. She stares over at both Kenny and Clem then fights through the hoard and disappeared into the woods.
Save Lilly - Clementine runs over and kicks the walker off of Lilly, she then helps her up off the ground. They both hold off the incoming walkers but quickly look over at Ke… [view original content]
I comed up with this one last night,some sort of Carley/Doug decision.
Shell and Becca join the cabin survivors in episode 2. Shell is frie… morendly with Clementine and she helps you many time. Becca becomes pretty much a "mean" counterpart of Sarah,with the game always putting Clem in the position of stay in Becca's side or Sarah's side (pretty much like the Kenny/Lilly rivality). In the middle of the episode,Carver's group attack Clementine and the others. The noise of the guns attract the walkers and they attack,with Sarah who's about to get shot by Carver and Becca who's about to got eated.
CHOICE : Save Becca OR Sarah
If you save Sarah : Becca is bitten and Shell has to shot her to put her out of her misery,while Carlos saves Sarah and Clementine from the walkers. A tearfull Shell runs away before the group get cought by Carver. Sarah,Clementine and Rebecca are locked up in a cell by Carver and they help Rebecca while she's having the ba… [view original content]
A character that was close to Clem lay nearby, mortally wounded, slowly dying in indescribable agony. Either Kenny, Lilly (depending on which is returning) or your favorite cabin survivor. Their killer, unaware of your presence, walks away gloating about his marksmanship.
You have a gun, and one bullet.
A: Mercy: Wait for the bandit to leave, put Clem's friend out of their misery. End their suffering, prevent them from turning.
B: Revenge: Leave your dying friends side to shoot the bandit in the back, then leave the bandit to die. He won't hurt anyone else.
C: Pragmatism: Try to save/comfort your friend until they die, leave, keep the bullet for later. That bullet could save a life later.
(using separate posts so you guys can rate these separately.) Title: Who do you trust?
The Cabin group and Clem is on the run from walkers or unknown aggressors, as seen in the episode 2 teaser. Clem see's the person whom she thought dead and their group (Lilly or Kenny depending on whom you like more)
Unknown aggressors opening fire from a distant treeline interrupts the reunion, Kenny/Lilly's group runs one way, Luke's group runs in the other. You have to chose who you run with.
A: AN OLD FRIEND ("You chose to go with Kenny/Lilly")
B: NEW ACQUAINTANCES ("You chose to stick with Luke's group")
This changes the next 5-10 minutes of game play, after which the group Clem didn't go with is captured, and the group she went with saves them and the groups reunite, putting the plot back on track, but affecting future relations with the season 1 character and Luke's group.
Mh,maybe I overthinked a little :P But I actually like this scenario I camed up whit. It's basically a choice between Sarah and Carlos or Becca and Shell. And obviously,Becca's character would be very changed if you choice to save her life at the cost of another.
Luke and Crista would be hard for me. Luke and Pete are the only new characters I like at the moment but then Crista has known Clem longer and has become a bit more like a mother figure to Clem so I would really struggle with this decision.
Kenny and Crista, I'll choose Crista everytime (likewise I'll choose Luke over Kenny everytime). Kenny and Lily, I'd have to go with Kenny. Cannot forgive Lily for shooting Carley!
wouldn't be out of place in the Walking Dead nice idea. If that was in the game, I think there would be a relatively even split between player choices. I'd go for either A or C, but probably A if the bandit wouldn't be able to hear the shot and neither would any walkers. If it was presented in a powerful way though, might be pushed to choose B. But again great idea
A character that was close to Clem lay nearby, mortally wounded, slowly dying in indescribable agony. Either Kenny, Lilly (depending on which … moreis returning) or your favorite cabin survivor. Their killer, unaware of your presence, walks away gloating about his marksmanship.
You have a gun, and one bullet.
A: Mercy: Wait for the bandit to leave, put Clem's friend out of their misery. End their suffering, prevent them from turning.
B: Revenge: Leave your dying friends side to shoot the bandit in the back, then leave the bandit to die. He won't hurt anyone else.
C: Pragmatism: Try to save/comfort your friend until they die, leave, keep the bullet for later. That bullet could save a life later.
Mh,maybe I overthinked a little :P But I actually like this scenario I camed up whit. It's basically a choice between Sarah and Carlos or Becc… morea and Shell. And obviously,Becca's character would be very changed if you choice to save her life at the cost of another.
I think Sarah will have a meltdown and will be executed by one of the members of the group. There will be walkers and the group will be hiding, but Sarah will be weeping and crying and won't stop no matter what and the walkers are getting closer. Rebecca has a knife and is getting so mad, she warns to slit Sarah's throat to save the group (Sarah doesn't know what might happen). Carlos is trying to stop Rebecca and we must choose what to do. Distract Carlos so Rebecca can kill Sarah, or warn Sarah.
But if you warn Sarah, her meltdown gets even worse and the walkers hear the noise and attack and Clem escapes as Sarah is eaten. Carlos stays behind trying to help her and is killed as well. If you help kill Sarah, Carlos is so mad he starts strangling Clem but Rebecca quickly stabs Carlos and they escape together. When Clem said she does not want to promise to be Sarah's friend and then have to do something not friendly, it made me feel like something horrible would happen.
Deliver the Baby,Save Luke christa shouldnt left clem by himself lee would be disapointed and dont shoot arm off virus goes into the blood stream so spreads in seconds so be no point game over
Must resist troll blame sarah for stealing the watch and hide it under her pillow
1)Rebecca has gun to christa about to shoot and your deci… moresion is to kill her and save christa or don't and christa dies
2)See another dog in woods but this time pitbull decide to shot it or risk a fatal attack later on for food
3)Seen rebecca get bite and only way to save the baby shoot her and cut her open apologises for that choice
4)Kenny returns but wants to take control of house killing everyone but Clem Shot him or not
5) Chuck Norris and Bruce Lee returns as zombie and are unkillable but you have bazooka which one do one shoot and risk getting pissed
Sarah or Becca? I dislike both of them but what if you have to save one? What is Becca hates Clem, because Shel died or so ending. And Carlos died saving Sarah. Who would you choose?
I did kind of steal this one from JESSEC25..... Except its a bit different.
In Episode 2, Vernon returns and apologizes. He has a heart to heart with Clementine and Vernon is no longer hated. Than, Victor the bandit guy shows up. He will thank you for the water if you gave it to him. He says that he and his group didn't mean to hurt anyone. They were just paranoid due to an incident with Carvers group. He got separated from the rest of his group. Later, you are on the Ski- Lift. You are on the lift with Victor and Vernon. The Ski- Lift limit is read and the lift will fall. Who do you push off? Victor or Vernon?
Ok check it yo it turns out Rebecca is having TWINS, and in episode 3 Clementine has to choose witch one of them will live.....and witch one of them will die........
Ok check it yo it turns out Rebecca is having TWINS, and in episode 3 Clementine has to choose witch one of them will live.....and witch one of them will die........
Let's say Christa was saved from the bandtis by Carver's group. The main group is attacked by Carver's group and Clemetine, Carlos and Luke are captured. WHen they are looking them in rooms from some house they use as a prison there are only two rooms left so Christa (never letting Carver's group know she knows Clem) lets Clem pick whith whom she's stuck so she can know to wich room she will come to rescue her later. Latter in the game. After a long bonding happens between Clementine and the person she's stuck with and the person who you didn't choose constantly being tortured for information (wich you can hear the screams) the rest of the group would attack the camp and break your rooms window to save you, but, at the same time, Christa opens the door with Carlos/Luke (the person being tortured) by her side and will say that you have to go with her and the guards have noticed the keys were gone. Now you have to choose if you go through the window or with CHrista. If you go through the window, CHrista will be shoot as she waits for you and dies as Nick/Luke (whoever is with her) runs and will join the group later. If you choose to go with CHrista, Carlos/Luke (whoever stayed with you) will be shot and will die as you run with Christa and the other guy and join the group later.
This way the decision you made in the beggining of the game will inflluence the decision you make at this part of the game, and note that the person that was tortured will allways be emotionally, phisycally and psychologically damaged. If you choose to go through the window he will resent you for rejecting him twice, But if you go with Christa he will be very gratfeull to you and her (even if he's damaged anyways...). The main group will resent and bash you if you go with Christa and will respect you more if you go wthrough the window.
Decision one: With who do you choose to stay? (Luke/Carlos)
Decision two: Who you choose to run with? (Christa/Main group)
I'm gonna post another here ( I didn't posted two together because it would be too long...
Clementine and Sarah are left the two to take care of Rebecca's baby in episode 4, as Rebecca is resting and the rest of the group is out hunting or something. This cult appears and Clementine and Sarah are scared but the people say they aren't there to hurt anyone, they just want to take the baby and both of them with them, so they can have children in their new societty where they have medics and good conditions for them to grow. Now continuining my latest choice, Carlos would either be dead or complety f*cked up in the head and wouldn't be a good parent, so Sarah would accept to go. The cult will inform them that they had been watching the group for a while, so they don't want Clementine in there because they consider Sarah and the baby pura, but Clementine tainted for the choices she had to make through the eralier episodes, so Clementine has to decide if she gives the baby or not.
Now if Clementine gives up the baby, when the group returns and Clementine explains everything, Rebecca will kill herself out of desperation for loosing her child, and the group will hate for letting both Sarah and the baby go with them. If you choose not to give the baby, the cult will later return and kill Rebecca and steal the baby anyways, but the group will respect you for protecting the baby in the beggining...
This decision allways ends up with the main group trying to recover Sarah and the baby but when they get there they see that the cult is located in some sort of ruins and have a leader that believes in the purification of the world and that the appocalypse it's about God choosing who is good and who is bad, so they sacrifice people they consider pure to the walkers so they can be "saved" and both the baby and Sarah will die...
Wow, these are really good decisions you came up with, even the people in the comments. I can see them happening in the game, and they're tough choices. I wouldn't have thought of these decisions.
I did kind of steal this one from JESSEC25..... Except its a bit different.
In Episode 2, Vernon returns and apologizes. He has a heart to … moreheart with Clementine and Vernon is no longer hated. Than, Victor the bandit guy shows up. He will thank you for the water if you gave it to him. He says that he and his group didn't mean to hurt anyone. They were just paranoid due to an incident with Carvers group. He got separated from the rest of his group. Later, you are on the Ski- Lift. You are on the lift with Victor and Vernon. The Ski- Lift limit is read and the lift will fall. Who do you push off? Victor or Vernon?
I would stay with Carlos. Here's why. I know Luke won't hate me for my desicion like Carlos would. Second of all , I need Carlos, the doctor on our side. For the second decision, I would run with the main group.
Ok here's my idea (it's a bit long):
Let's say Christa was saved from the bandtis by Carver's group. The main group is attacked by Carver's… more group and Clemetine, Carlos and Luke are captured. WHen they are looking them in rooms from some house they use as a prison there are only two rooms left so Christa (never letting Carver's group know she knows Clem) lets Clem pick whith whom she's stuck so she can know to wich room she will come to rescue her later. Latter in the game. After a long bonding happens between Clementine and the person she's stuck with and the person who you didn't choose constantly being tortured for information (wich you can hear the screams) the rest of the group would attack the camp and break your rooms window to save you, but, at the same time, Christa opens the door with Carlos/Luke (the person being tortured) by her side and will say that you have to go with her and the guards have noticed the keys were gone. Now you ha… [view original content]
Comments
Nope, didn't get it.
It seems to me that this "Private discussion" system needs some fixing.
neither
I agree, I still don't even know what one looks like in my feed >-<
Save a walker without any ulterior motive
That would actually make a pretty great plot
Easy, Nutella.
Save Kenny, the man with da stache.
Not really. If people love Kenny, they save Kenny. If people love Lilly, they save Lilly. Piece a' cake.
I'm sure Telltale would get a better reputation if they took in suggestions from gamers.
Wow, too much death for just one choice.
A character that was close to Clem lay nearby, mortally wounded, slowly dying in indescribable agony. Either Kenny, Lilly (depending on which is returning) or your favorite cabin survivor. Their killer, unaware of your presence, walks away gloating about his marksmanship.
You have a gun, and one bullet.
A: Mercy: Wait for the bandit to leave, put Clem's friend out of their misery. End their suffering, prevent them from turning.
B: Revenge: Leave your dying friends side to shoot the bandit in the back, then leave the bandit to die. He won't hurt anyone else.
C: Pragmatism: Try to save/comfort your friend until they die, leave, keep the bullet for later. That bullet could save a life later.
Same here. I sure hope they put the Push Carlos or Alvin decision in. Sadly, I doubt it.
(using separate posts so you guys can rate these separately.) Title: Who do you trust?
The Cabin group and Clem is on the run from walkers or unknown aggressors, as seen in the episode 2 teaser. Clem see's the person whom she thought dead and their group (Lilly or Kenny depending on whom you like more)
Unknown aggressors opening fire from a distant treeline interrupts the reunion, Kenny/Lilly's group runs one way, Luke's group runs in the other. You have to chose who you run with.
A: AN OLD FRIEND ("You chose to go with Kenny/Lilly")
B: NEW ACQUAINTANCES ("You chose to stick with Luke's group")
This changes the next 5-10 minutes of game play, after which the group Clem didn't go with is captured, and the group she went with saves them and the groups reunite, putting the plot back on track, but affecting future relations with the season 1 character and Luke's group.
Mh,maybe I overthinked a little :P But I actually like this scenario I camed up whit. It's basically a choice between Sarah and Carlos or Becca and Shell. And obviously,Becca's character would be very changed if you choice to save her life at the cost of another.
How about a choice to save Christa or Kenny?
That could go differently depending on how to treated Christa or Kenny,what you said about who should take care of Clem,etc. etc.??
Some really good decisions in this thread.
Luke and Crista would be hard for me. Luke and Pete are the only new characters I like at the moment but then Crista has known Clem longer and has become a bit more like a mother figure to Clem so I would really struggle with this decision.
Kenny and Crista, I'll choose Crista everytime (likewise I'll choose Luke over Kenny everytime). Kenny and Lily, I'd have to go with Kenny. Cannot forgive Lily for shooting Carley!
wouldn't be out of place in the Walking Dead nice idea. If that was in the game, I think there would be a relatively even split between player choices. I'd go for either A or C, but probably A if the bandit wouldn't be able to hear the shot and neither would any walkers. If it was presented in a powerful way though, might be pushed to choose B. But again great idea
FUCK...Wall Street, I mean uh, Fuck Lilly.
Nah, nah it's perfect, now you can work at Telltale as Heart Breaker.
FUCK YEAH HAHAHA
TWAU or TWDS2
It's like an apocalypse within an apocalypse! That's just... brilliant!
I think Sarah will have a meltdown and will be executed by one of the members of the group. There will be walkers and the group will be hiding, but Sarah will be weeping and crying and won't stop no matter what and the walkers are getting closer. Rebecca has a knife and is getting so mad, she warns to slit Sarah's throat to save the group (Sarah doesn't know what might happen). Carlos is trying to stop Rebecca and we must choose what to do. Distract Carlos so Rebecca can kill Sarah, or warn Sarah.
But if you warn Sarah, her meltdown gets even worse and the walkers hear the noise and attack and Clem escapes as Sarah is eaten. Carlos stays behind trying to help her and is killed as well. If you help kill Sarah, Carlos is so mad he starts strangling Clem but Rebecca quickly stabs Carlos and they escape together. When Clem said she does not want to promise to be Sarah's friend and then have to do something not friendly, it made me feel like something horrible would happen.
Must resist troll blame sarah for stealing the watch and hide it under her pillow
1)Rebecca has gun to christa about to shoot and your decision is to kill her and save christa or don't and christa dies
2)See another dog in woods but this time pitbull decide to shot it or risk a fatal attack later on for food
3)Seen rebecca get bite and only way to save the baby shoot her and cut her open apologises for that choice
4)Kenny returns but wants to take control of house killing everyone but Clem Shot him or not
5) Chuck Norris and Bruce Lee returns as zombie and are unkillable but you have bazooka which one do one shoot and risk getting pissed
Deliver the Baby,Save Luke christa shouldnt left clem by himself lee would be disapointed and dont shoot arm off virus goes into the blood stream so spreads in seconds so be no point game over
Sarah or Becca? I dislike both of them but what if you have to save one? What is Becca hates Clem, because Shel died or so ending. And Carlos died saving Sarah. Who would you choose?
That is insanely awesome!
This is not that big of a choice but i think this would be a cool little thing to have.
The cabin group is attacked and Luke and clem are separated from the rest and are wondering hen they will find the rest of the group again.
Luke: "Look, i dont know what happened.. but i'll look after you until then ok?
Clem hears Lee's words echoe in her head from episode 1 when they first met and sees Lee in Luke for a split second.
Response 1: (looks down) "Ok"....
Response 2: "You cant promise that.."
Response 3: "Listen, Im fine.. I dont need a babysitter.."
Response 4: .... (Looks away sadly)
Soup or salad?
I did kind of steal this one from JESSEC25..... Except its a bit different.
In Episode 2, Vernon returns and apologizes. He has a heart to heart with Clementine and Vernon is no longer hated. Than, Victor the bandit guy shows up. He will thank you for the water if you gave it to him. He says that he and his group didn't mean to hurt anyone. They were just paranoid due to an incident with Carvers group. He got separated from the rest of his group. Later, you are on the Ski- Lift. You are on the lift with Victor and Vernon. The Ski- Lift limit is read and the lift will fall. Who do you push off? Victor or Vernon?
Ok check it yo it turns out Rebecca is having TWINS, and in episode 3 Clementine has to choose witch one of them will live.....and witch one of them will die........
Um.... Why
Ok here's my idea (it's a bit long):
Let's say Christa was saved from the bandtis by Carver's group. The main group is attacked by Carver's group and Clemetine, Carlos and Luke are captured. WHen they are looking them in rooms from some house they use as a prison there are only two rooms left so Christa (never letting Carver's group know she knows Clem) lets Clem pick whith whom she's stuck so she can know to wich room she will come to rescue her later. Latter in the game. After a long bonding happens between Clementine and the person she's stuck with and the person who you didn't choose constantly being tortured for information (wich you can hear the screams) the rest of the group would attack the camp and break your rooms window to save you, but, at the same time, Christa opens the door with Carlos/Luke (the person being tortured) by her side and will say that you have to go with her and the guards have noticed the keys were gone. Now you have to choose if you go through the window or with CHrista. If you go through the window, CHrista will be shoot as she waits for you and dies as Nick/Luke (whoever is with her) runs and will join the group later. If you choose to go with CHrista, Carlos/Luke (whoever stayed with you) will be shot and will die as you run with Christa and the other guy and join the group later.
This way the decision you made in the beggining of the game will inflluence the decision you make at this part of the game, and note that the person that was tortured will allways be emotionally, phisycally and psychologically damaged. If you choose to go through the window he will resent you for rejecting him twice, But if you go with Christa he will be very gratfeull to you and her (even if he's damaged anyways...). The main group will resent and bash you if you go with Christa and will respect you more if you go wthrough the window.
Decision one: With who do you choose to stay? (Luke/Carlos)
Decision two: Who you choose to run with? (Christa/Main group)
In your Luke/Christa decision, I'd say Luke. So Christa can be with Omid and Omid Jr.
I'm gonna post another here ( I didn't posted two together because it would be too long...
Clementine and Sarah are left the two to take care of Rebecca's baby in episode 4, as Rebecca is resting and the rest of the group is out hunting or something. This cult appears and Clementine and Sarah are scared but the people say they aren't there to hurt anyone, they just want to take the baby and both of them with them, so they can have children in their new societty where they have medics and good conditions for them to grow. Now continuining my latest choice, Carlos would either be dead or complety f*cked up in the head and wouldn't be a good parent, so Sarah would accept to go. The cult will inform them that they had been watching the group for a while, so they don't want Clementine in there because they consider Sarah and the baby pura, but Clementine tainted for the choices she had to make through the eralier episodes, so Clementine has to decide if she gives the baby or not.
Now if Clementine gives up the baby, when the group returns and Clementine explains everything, Rebecca will kill herself out of desperation for loosing her child, and the group will hate for letting both Sarah and the baby go with them. If you choose not to give the baby, the cult will later return and kill Rebecca and steal the baby anyways, but the group will respect you for protecting the baby in the beggining...
This decision allways ends up with the main group trying to recover Sarah and the baby but when they get there they see that the cult is located in some sort of ruins and have a leader that believes in the purification of the world and that the appocalypse it's about God choosing who is good and who is bad, so they sacrifice people they consider pure to the walkers so they can be "saved" and both the baby and Sarah will die...
decision: give up baby/protect baby
Wow, these are really good decisions you came up with, even the people in the comments. I can see them happening in the game, and they're tough choices. I wouldn't have thought of these decisions.
Is "both" an option?
Clem happens upon another seemingly friendly stray dog that's lost its owner.
Does she kill it?
I would stay with Carlos. Here's why. I know Luke won't hate me for my desicion like Carlos would. Second of all , I need Carlos, the doctor on our side. For the second decision, I would run with the main group.