Well let's be honest... Carlos is 'doctor-esque' at best.
Yeah, you could say that. Apparently he has some knowledge on first aid (similar to Katjaa's role in S1) after giving an opinion on Clementine's "suturing skills" or maybe he just knows his first aid.
Not to mention misdiagnosis isn't really the right terminology to use in this situation. The diagnosis was fine, she was bit and needed to be stitched and cleaned. In a normal world the question "how did it happen" would only be a part of the diagnosis if the cut/bite/etc was from a rabid dog or a rust wire or what ever. Seeing as I doubt they had any tetnis shots around I don't think it really would have factored into the 'diagnosis'.
All I'm saying is I don't think Carlos so be judged from the perspective of him being a bad doctor, but only being a bad person (for locking her in a shed with little hesitation and without contemplating other ways of handling the situation).
So the right term would be...misinterpretation then? Anyways, yes Carlos should not be judged on his "medical abilities" but rather his morality and judgment.
Well let's be honest... Carlos is 'doctor-esque' at best. Also misdiagnosis is 'not often' by todays standards, with modern tools and tests an… mored exams, etc. You take away all of those thkngs and you are in a state more similar to the middle ages, and they had a lot of misdiagnosis' at that point in time if I remember correctly
Not to mention misdiagnosis isn't really the right terminology to use in this situation. The diagnosis was fine, she was bit and needed to be stitched and cleaned. In a normal world the question "how did it happen" would only be a part of the diagnosis if the cut/bite/etc was from a rabid dog or a rust wire or what ever. Seeing as I doubt they had any tetnis shots around I don't think it really would have factored into the 'diagnosis'.
All I'm saying is I don't think Carlos so be judged from the perspective of him being a bad doctor, but only being a bad person (for locking her in a shed with little hesitation and without contemplating other ways of handling the situation).
Comments
Yeah, you could say that. Apparently he has some knowledge on first aid (similar to Katjaa's role in S1) after giving an opinion on Clementine's "suturing skills" or maybe he just knows his first aid.
So the right term would be...misinterpretation then? Anyways, yes Carlos should not be judged on his "medical abilities" but rather his morality and judgment.