Have you ever regretted a few choices that you have made?

edited February 2014 in The Walking Dead

Like title, have you ever regretted choises or dialogues that u made? If yes, Would you go back to do them again?

«1

Comments

  • Yes I have, and no I wouldn't go back because if it was a real life situation I wouldn't be able to go back either

  • CathalOHaraCathalOHara Moderator
    edited February 2014

    Lee: "Put the gun down bitch!"

    Brenda didn't put the gun down. :( She kinda shot me instead.

  • I regret saying to Sarah we were best friends just to get the medicine, but i wanted to be sure to get it. But no i wouldnt go back

  • xD Same here

    CathalOHara posted: »

    Lee: "Put the gun down bitch!" Brenda didn't put the gun down. She kinda shot me instead.

  • edited February 2014

    In "All That Remains" I'm questioning my decision on whether or not I should have called out Carlos for the way he takes care of Sarah. I know what he is doing is dangerous for her, but I am a total stranger and am in no position to even be at the cabin, much less question his parenting.

  • I regret saving Nick. It's not because I want him to die (I really like his character for some reason), it's just that I know he's going to be pissed at me for not helping Pete instead. And judging by the trailer, it looks like it's a possibility that Nick survives no matter what.

  • edited February 2014

    Not killing the St.Johns. I do kinda wish I could go back and change that choice but I never will because I don't change any choice I make on my canon save.

  • In Season 1? Dropping Ben. I thought someone else would die if I saved him, so I let him go. After seeing that he COULD be saved, I really wanted to go back. Thankfully, I didn't. That's the only choice I really regret in either Season, and even 400 Days.

  • Same here

    Rock114 posted: »

    In Season 1? Dropping Ben. I thought someone else would die if I saved him, so I let him go. After seeing that he COULD be saved, I really wan

  • my only ones are when when I picked doug and nick I watched carily and pete die

  • In my first playthough i knocked some sense into Kenny...i immediatelly regreted my decisions and went back to talk him down...

  • Same here, I don't regret anything.

  • Don't regret that Doug choice...

    He's so awesome.

    stitchfan08 posted: »

    my only ones are when when I picked doug and nick I watched carily and pete die

  • TeamSockzNSandalz

    Don't regret that Doug choice... He's so awesome.

  • So did mine, twice. I'm not even sure I made the same decisions I did the first time anymore.

  • edited February 2014

    yeah,that's why I rewind that part :p especially since we don't know what exactly sarah's condition is

    In "All That Remains" I'm questioning my decision on whether or not I should have called out Carlos for the way he takes care of Sarah. I kno

  • Yep. Sure it was hard for her to have to do that, but, at least it taught her even more that she has to do whats necessary.

  • On my first ever playthrough, I made Kenny shoot the boy in the attic in episode 4. And on my 5th playthrough of All That Remains, I was kinda mean to Sarah :(

  • Don't know why, but I regret killing Danny.

    He got caught in his own bear trap with no release latch. Threat neutralized. But I still killed him out of anger, I gave him Mercy too which is bullshit. Should have left him for the Walkers. -_-

  • Yeah, I somehow missed the "bitch" part when I first chose that. Not the best decision I've made.

    CathalOHara posted: »

    Lee: "Put the gun down bitch!" Brenda didn't put the gun down. She kinda shot me instead.

  • edited February 2014

    Choking the stranger out with one arm, so nice. But cutting Lee's arm off I would have not done that if I knew he would have died anyway... One other thing is, I like Nate so I had Russell stay when Nate kills the old folks. I wonder if that makes Russell a bad person in season 2 if he shows up.

  • I regret leaving Beatrice, dropping Ben, setting Roberto free, and above all... killing Sam.

  • CathalOHaraCathalOHara Moderator
    edited February 2014

    Killing Sam? That was worse than leaving him to suffer? Yes, it's horrible putting down an animal like that but it's worse leaving him suffering. He was in horrendous pain.

    EDIT: Had a brain-fart. My comment was supposed to be replying to o0HeaDShoT0o.

  • Only 'befriending' Sarah. Seems like I was scamming her.

  • I regretted killing Danny, but mainly because i upset Clementine because of it. I used the rewind button because i thought clementine would lose trust in me, the last thing i would want.

    Also i stole the watch in season 2 episode 1. That was on pure accident though, it was just my exploration instincts kicking in "Oh, there's an item i can pick up! Must be useful for later, i'll grab it!"

  • edited February 2014

    many but I didn't turn back to reverse them since as others said "in real life you don't have a way to go back" , here are 2
    1. I regret not killing Larry - after thinking about it ... Kenny was right , the guy was huge and if he turned we would all be f* or at least 1 of us
    2. Not leaving Lily on the roads - the bitch deserved it and she stole our vehicle later

  • I kind of regret stealing the supplies from the Station Wagon. Not that I'd go back and change it, because I never go back and change my decisions first time around. I am however keeping a second save file for The Wolf Among Us to go back through and change some decisions the second time around with that, but I won't do that with The Walking Dead.

    I think the only other decisions I've made that I've regretted would be shooting Danny in Vince's Story in 400 Days... But I still wouldn't go back to change that.

  • OzzyUKOzzyUK Moderator

    Leaving Lee, i didn't want the noise of the gun to attract any walkers to Clementine but after i made that choice i felt guilty for leaving him to reanimate as a walker, i never rewind my decisions but i did shoot him on my second playthrough.

  • nothing i regret
    even choices i thought i will regret it later and rewind it(like saving ben)
    but after rewinding i found it getting worse than i thought
    so my choices was not bad at end

  • I regret not shooting the bandit in Shel's story. He came back with his group and killed that nice old man Boyd who was against stealing Lee's boat.

    I also regretted knocking some sense into Kenny. The man was suffering emotionally and I didn't want to add physical pain to that. I think I immediately rewinded that one so I could talk him down properly.

  • I got in a hurry and , pressed the wrong button and, accidentally told Omid and Christa to find another boat.Then later Lee told Clem "find Omid and Christa, they're looking for a boat" I thought to myself.. omg i just killed Clem, she'll never find them.

  • I wanted clem to shoot Lee first season so that he wouldn't turn but accidentally hit not to shoot him. The feels got to me. At least she cries a lot less if you dont have her shoot lee.

    (image

  • I did not question his parenting in my first playthrough

    In "All That Remains" I'm questioning my decision on whether or not I should have called out Carlos for the way he takes care of Sarah. I kno

  • I tried to kill the stranger but I couldn't, maybe I just didn't do the qte right. (note: I cut off lee's arm)

  • I did both of those things, killed larry left lilly

    rz1986 posted: »

    many but I didn't turn back to reverse them since as others said "in real life you don't have a way to go back" , here are 2 1. I regret

  • I regret fighting with Lilly from the moment I met her and called her a bitch. That and killing Larry seemed like big factors in Carley getting killed. Then I kept her for some reason and she jacked the rv.. Only time I've ever used rewind.

    I also regret choosing Nick over Pete. I was in full panic mode after Pete got bit and the walkers showed up.

  • Now that I think back on it, I don't have any regrets from season 1, 400 Days or All That Remains. Oh wait, I do wish I would've knocked on the window to get the almighty juice box on my original playthrough but not that big of a deal to rewind.

  • I...actually rewinded because of the juice box.

    I'm not even kidding.

    AdamBizzle posted: »

    Now that I think back on it, I don't have any regrets from season 1, 400 Days or All That Remains. Oh wait, I do wish I would've knocked on the window to get the almighty juice box on my original playthrough but not that big of a deal to rewind.

  • Lol just too tempting to pass up huh? I kept thinking about knocking on the window but I chickened out and just snuck under the house.

    Pride posted: »

    I...actually rewinded because of the juice box. I'm not even kidding.

  • I regret burning kennys photo, i didnt even realize there was a wood, but no , i didnt change it.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.