If it really comes down to it...? (MAJOR SPOILERS)
In a life or death situation would you choose Luke or Kenny? If you were forced to to make a timed decision that would determine that one of them dies?
I personally would choose Luke. I mean, Kenny's my bro but he is still the same irrational, depressed alcoholic he was in the first season. I don't think I could really trust him to not do something stupid, or he would be the dominant one and too overprotective of Clem. With Luke I feel like it would not only newer, but more dynamic where you would get to make more choices. Thoughts?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
MAKE THIS A CHOICE. I like to suffer.
I (think) would choose Luke for more or less the same reasons, but damn it is tough just thinking about it.
Kenny ofcourse. I only know Luke for a week.
Kenny may be going through stuff, but ill never give up on him.
Kenny no doubt. This will probably be the "Pizza or Ice Cream" they were hinting in the tweets some days ago.
What if he snaps in episode three? Do you think that would effect it for you?
Great, now they'll delay Ep5 because we figured that out...
If that happens, it happens and ill live with the consequences, but i won't just assume things will go wrong. I give Kenny more credit
Before either die the foreigner from Shel's story I spared will appear and save them both and say "Sorry my English was bad I thought you said 'please come back here and kill Boyd', my bad Im really a nice guy"
Luke, sorry as much as I like Kenny; he's a broken man.
He's lost his family, his best friend; everything.
He needs a release, he has nothing left.
This new girl of his? He's trying to replace Katjaa.
If he doesn't move on, I think he needs death.
Well that's depressing. I love both pizza and ice cream
I know! It's a choice I want to make but don't want to make at the same time.
Well, It's ep5. We still have to see how they both end up being. But we know they are both gonna make it to ep5.
Well okay then.
Luke.
As happy as I was to see Kenny again, the dude's a total train wreck at this point.
Kenny, we been friends till now, i barely know luke, and kenny i think has a better survivor mentality
I like Luke and all, and I wish him the best, but my Clem's with Kenny.
This would be difficult I had a hard time choosing who to sit with!
Anyway I'd have to go with Kenny, even though he's a bit unstable and might end up doing something stupid because of that hot temper he's the only one Clem can truly trust, Clem hasn't gotten to know Luke well enough to let him have the privilege.
I honestly don't know what I'd do... Like almost everyone else, I had enough of a hard time trying to figure out who to sit with! Ever since they started having a power struggle relationship similar to how it was in Season One with Lilly, I've been ninety percent sure that this will eventually happen. To quote Kenny, we may be looking at a "Larry" situation here. I did end up sitting with Kenny because he was my friend and I got along with him back then. Plus, I wanted to catch up more. But something feels... Different about him. It's making me nervous. Then again, I'm having doubts about Luke now too. Carver seems to be really familiar with him due to his comment on how he's not surprised that he ditched the group and how he warned Carlos not to let him lead.
I care about both characters. My emotional attachment with those two is different compared to each other, and yet my bond to them is currently equally as strong as the other for some reason. And it's probably too early for me to decide (I'll wait for the next episodes to make a proper decision if we do indeed need to choose), but at the moment I think I'd choose Luke. He seems more trust worthy... For now.
Luke hasn't been showing signs of snapping, losing it, or being irrational or stupid. Kenny has- dating back to season 1. I like Kenny but I think Luke has his @#$% together more so at this point than Kenny. I'd choose Luke.
Ahhhh i couldn't answer this yet its too early... for all we know Luke could do something bad in the next few episodes but Kenny seems unstable. So its a hard decision!
I think he is which is why I stopped trusting him toward the end of last season. Like I said- he's shown signs of coming undone- Luke hasn't yet.
I think I need another episode to determine this choice, which would be a dam hard one. Kenny is my bro but he just seemed off in Ep 2. I need more dialogue with him to see how damaged he really is. But I really don't know. I'm kind of leaning towards Luke because he seems to be more rational and in control than Kenny at the moment.
LOL
Wow, he can just say that?
Revealing the future plot and everything?
But damn... I can't pick between Pizza and Ice Cream :[
My heart is shattering to pieces already in anticipation.
I'd choose Kenny. I mean, Luke's nice and all, but Clem's known him for what, a week? She knew Kenny for nearly half a year, and in my playthrough, Kenny and Lee were like brothers.
Still, I don't think it will come down to a clear cut choice like that. I think there will probably be a little more complexity to the situation.
I say Kenny, she knew him way longer and trusts him more. Play through season 1 and look at the relationship between the 2.
That moment of choice is sure to come. But i hope we will have much time to spend with both of them before the choice.
Sure, but both will make you morbidly obese.
Honestly..., I'd hate to decide, but in a twisted, cruel way, this is an easier choice for me to make than sitting at the table, given our current knowledge. At the table, I had to choose who of the two I'd like to shun. In both scenarios, it would mean they're both alive, but Clem's relationship with one of them would be harmed. If I choose Luke, then Kenny, who I've met after thinking he was dead for about two years, would feel betrayed, leaving him for some 'new friends'. On the other hand, if I choose Kenny, then I've chosen the weird, impulsive guy over Luke, who I was saved by, and have saved the life of.
In a life or death situation, though, Luke has a bigger group, seems more stable, less violent, and is pragmatic over emotional. Kenny is friendly, but more 'unhinged' prone to alcoholism, selfish, and impulsive. So I'd pick Luke, since if Kenny's dead, I don't have to worry about him, only Sarita, but if Luke's dead, I have his group to worry about.
Of course, this is only from what I know NOW; we'll have to wait and see if Luke is alive, dead, good, selfish, bitten, etc.
Man, this is REALLY hard. I like both of them, but in the end I think I'd go with Kenny. He and Lee were bros in my game, and he really need someone to help him out with his issues. It would suck though, having Luke die.
The answer is obviously Luke because Kenny clearly has an immunity to death. So he'll be back in Season 3 anyway.
Depending on Kenny's crazyness level and his actions in the next episodes,it could be the hardest choice so far. But as in right now,I'd probably pick....
..... [long silence].....
Give me 10 minutes. :P
I think people have some serious nostalgia goggles on with regards to Kenny. I recall in S1 an awful lot of people hated his guts.
I don't trust Luke or Kenny not do do something stupid, but I do trust Luke not to underestimate Clementine.
I sat with Kenny though, so if I have to choose between Luke and Kenny, I'll probably end up choosing Kenny....though it depends on who does more for Clementine up until that point and who I sympathize with more. Neither of them are hot women so my decision isn't as easy(Carley and Doug lol).
It depends on what they both show me in episodes 3-5. Hard to say I'd go with Luke when I don't even know his status right now. It boils down to:
Luke: does he truly care about Clementine, how sincere is his loyalty and above all else is he even alive currently. (I'd say 95% chance he is.)
Kenny: is he broken or not and does he make good decisions. (We know that can be loyal if you're loyal to him. He needs to show some give and take. I don't want to be forced on a boat or any equivalent of that that's a dead-end plan.)
Kenny, without a doubt. I truly like Luke, I do, but Kenny's been my bro ever since Season 1.
Kenny, without a doubt. I truly like Luke, I do, but Kenny's been my bro ever since Season 1.
What i think is going to happen, is that "Pizza or Icecream" are actually GROUPS
Any chance we will have to decide between which group to save instead? Cabin group or Kenny with Sarita? or even worse, 400 Days Group?
Another theory would be, the end of a season would be us deciding who to go with, what group to pick? there's going to be 3 groups to pick from:
Cabin group
Kenny and Sarita (basically New Kenny's family)
400 Days group
After you choose what group to join, Episode 5 ends, with a possible hint to Season 3?
Eh, if it's the apocalypse I wouldn't care haha.
I had a hard enough time deciding who to sit with.
At this moment in time in the Season I would choose to save Luke over Kenny. Of course depending how the rest of the Season goes my choice may change.