Maybe Luke is the real bad guy not Carver here's why.
I get a very psycho vibe when it comes to Luke. Yes he's a great character but here is why I think he's a bad guy and not Carver:
In episode 1 you can tell Luke that everyone seems to die around you and you killed Lee. It says Luke will remember that.
Maybe since you told him that he will try to come after you in the other episodes. Luke seems to like killing walkers for fun which gives him a Lizzie type personality. Luke also tells Clem he's really good with children and women. It seemed like every time someone mentions Carver Luke looked like he's hiding something and knows about things the group don't know.
What if it was Luke who killed those people by the lake here's why. When you told Luke about the dog she killed in the woods he got upset. When they locked Clem inside the shed Luke could have went back into the woods to find the dog. Instead he found the remaining bandits killed them. Met Krista and asked where she was headed. She told him Wellington and about the mountain side. How else do you think he knew things? He went back to the river side and found a group and the last bandit. killed them to avoid witnesses for his crime and dropped Clem's bag that Krista gave to him to give to Clem. She described the little girl she was with and Luke knew exactly who she was talking about. The bandit by the river was probably gonna say Luke before he died. After that he went inside the house meeting which was starting. Luke and Krista agreed if they get lost they will meet at a certain spot.
Now Carver I doubt he killed those people by the river because he lied to Clem when he told her his people live down by the river. His group lives in a shopping mall area as shown in episode 3, so there's no way Carver killed those people. Carver has only 1 intention so far and that's get his baby. He can care less about Rebecca but wants peace among his community. He killed people because the rage that consumes Kenny and Carlos. Kenny's vengeance will end up making carver kill more people. He gives people a chance to side with him at least.
Luke went missing and will probably come with Krista who will be a bandit now. She will tell Clem better ways to survive. Clem will lose hope depending who they killed off. Clem will lose her hat as shown in episode 4 and put blood on her face to survive. Or she probably have to kill someone and looses her innocence.
I don't know it just seems something's not right with Luke lol. They even said this season's theme is trust. I think what Kenny asked Clem about do you trust Luke with your life will play a huge part in this season. So maybe Luke is leading everyone to their death as Carver stated. Or a twist Luke is working with Carver.
Do you think Luke is the bad guy instead of Carver? Sometimes the enemy can be in your group which you don't know. Example in Tomb Raider the recent one everyone thought that guy with the glasses who was one of Lara's friends leading the group could be trusted. In the end he was just working with the enemy to gain power. Plus Clem still does not know anything about the group she's with.
Comments
your saying no but please explain XD. I would like others opinions why or why not. lets discuss
. Well at least try to
You get a psychological vibe? You get a vibe pertaining to the mind and state of emotion? Is that good or bad? You may be getting a psychotic vibe, that would make sense, well no it wouldn't, but at least the wording would make sense.
When does he have fun killing walkers? Lizzy loved walkers, that reference makes no sense. They were all being shady about Carver, not just Luke.
The paragraph about Luke killing everyone at the river ya da ya da... that is the most baseless conjecture I've ever seen. How would he have killed 10 people alone? How would he have the bag? Where did Christa go? Why didn't anyone in the group notice he was gone for such a long period of time?
While I slightly agree with you that carver didn't kill the people at the river (only slightly, I'm not sure on that one yet) your justification has no ground. He wouldn't have told Clem where he was really from, or who he was. He lied to her, the bad guy often does.
She has already killed people. She has already lost her innocence. Christa may return with Luke as a bandit, nothing to really disprove that. But I doubt it and more so it's just more conjecture.
I could see Luke being a bad guy. I don't think he is, but it wouldn't shock me if that was a twist they decided to go with.
How did like kill the people at the river if he was at the house meeting...
i said he probably went to the meeting after killing the people on the river. Did you even read or did you just skim it?
Luke is the true villian. He will bring a group of bandits back to carver's place and it will be an all out war!!! Kenny shouldn't have let luke leave because now he will get revenge
I think what he meant was how would Luke have enough time to go down to the river, kill those people, converse with Christa, kill the last remaining guys, and then make it all the way back to the house meeting on time. Because what happens between Clem being locked in the shed and then her sneaking off into the house to get medical supplies doesn't take very long at all.
Also, I can't really see Luke being able to take out an entire group of people on his own, especially if they all had guns while HE only has a gun and a machete.
The concept of the theory is ok but your proof makes no sense.
okay
Luke didn't actually know about Wellington. In episode 2, if you don't answer Kenny's question about Wellington right away, Luke will chime in and ask about it.
Anyway, I feel like Luke could potentially be less trustworthy than he seems, but I don't think it would be that overt. If he does lose Clem's trust, he'll probably do it by putting her in a dangerous situation to save his own skin, which would show that he's using her status as a little girl to protect himself, because nobody wants to kill a little girl or the guy looking after her. That would sort of make him the antithesis of Lee.