Season 1 VS. Season 2
I know we only got to play 202 right now, but I think season 1 is better than season 2 right now. Season two has some great moments which I enjoyed so far though.
Season 2 has great potential to be the best, but we only know little about the characters so far, and the only great episode there seems to be is episode 202. I enjoy playing as Clementine.
I feel season 2 is going to fast XD with the death rate of characters at 60%. They just introduced characters to us and played with our emotions, and killed them off. Season 1's death rate was like 30% characters just didn't die off in one episode.
Disclaimer: I'm a huge Walking Dead fan so please don't think I'm saying season 2 is stupid which it isn't. It's just not as great as season 1 yet. My thoughts will change as the season continues. I enjoyed episode 202 which was scary and suspenseful. I didn't expect Bonnie to show up with Carver lol, and Troy might be mute or mentally challenged I don't know.
So my question is what are your thoughts? Which is better so far? And yes dislikes I'm ready XD.
Comments
season 1 is better at the moment obviously because season 1 is finished, season 2 is ongoing. I liked/am liking both seasons right now like I said I think S1 is better but I think if telltale can keep going where House divided left off then I think S2 has a great chance at being better. I can already say that it looks like S2 might surpass S1 in the villain department. In S1 we didn't really have a HUGE villain ya we had small villians like the st. johns and the stranger but I feel carver is going to be our first big bad guy character
agree
S1 was special, i'm not saying that s2 isn't great or wont be great but it's different. It isn't really a fair comparison in my opinion.
He is like the governor from the TV show
I disagree a new day will always be the oddball episode everyone in it acted differently and the entire gamestyle seemed different I still enjoyed it but some parts of it felt strange. Especially when playing it again
Also we've only lost 3 of the original group (and two of them are determinant). There is also Omid but I almost feel that was a sort of opening flashback.
Apart from that anyone else that died was pretty much killed the episode they were introduced Matthew, Walter were only found and lossed in this episode (simaler to The St Johns and Mark)
Also like other have said its only episode 2. We'll see the whole season as much better once it is released.
I love Season 1 a lot, it was a very concise story and had an amazing arc with Lee, but I'm not ready to say it's better than Season 2.
How can you compare Season 1 to 2 if there are only 2 episodes out right now?
I never compared them. i just asked which is better so far then gave my thoughts. I also made disclaimer stating my thoughts will change as the season continues XD. I just said episode wise and death rate season 1 is better. We only have two episodes for season two and 202 seems to be better that why i asked
Season 1 had longer episodes, and was more toned down in action. It was story driven with believable characters and a clear realistic goal/plot. Also much more emotional connections with every single character.
Season 2 has shorter episodes feels like an action zombie flick with a big bad villain named carver and a little girl who kicks zombie ass on bridges and solves puzzles that the grown ups can't.
This.
Also how can I forget clem performing stitches on herself? God this little girl is indestructible. She can take on the entire zombie menace by herself.
there has only been two episodes so I don't think we can say S1 had longer episodes yet. after all look at house divided it was a longer episode and its in S2 and I think the characters are believable in S2 also. I also think their is a good amount of emotional connections to the characters EX: Luke, Nick, Alvin, and pete.
As for the more action in S2 I'm liking the action its cool and fun.
Season 2 just doesn't feel the same without lee. So I have to say season 1
There is on thing i like about in S2. Theres more colours than just gray. I know its kinda of a theme, everything's miserable and all but it's very numbning after a while. I think S1 is maybe better for now, but to me they're both equally awesome.
I don't think you can really make a decision until the end of season 2. Your comparing 5 episodes to 2 so it's not a fair comparison at this stage.
Well it is kinda too early to even compare the two since season 2 is not over yet but when season 1 was at the point where season 2 is now it had episode 1 and 2 with episode 1 being a great start not amazing but great then episode 2 came along and blew our minds (at least my mind) same thing happened with season 2 episode 1 came around and it was just great then episode 2 came around and it blew our minds you can't really compare the two until season 2 is finished so for now they are equally awesome
also anyone who says season 2 is not that good cause Lee is not in it is a complete retard and should just stop playing
S1 toyed with and tore my heart but I loved it so much. I'm a huge fan too or else I wouldn't be here.
For now, I think if we're going to compare the two, we should compare all of S1 to episode 2 and all of S2 we have right now (which is episode 2).
I don't think it's fair yet to compare them until S2 is actually finished.
I like the tv show but let's face it the governor sucked the comic gov was 10x better
Season 1 is way better so far but im waiting for Season 2 to surpass it.