Theory: Lily Holly's sister was also glamoured to look like Faith...

Okay I know this theory has to make since I think.

Okay we learned that Lily was supposed to be at Woodsman's house for an appointment. Lily went to Woodsman's house but disguised as Faith. How do I know? I know because Lily was the only prostitute who could have known where he lived. After the night Bigby met her she went back to the Pudding & Pie and reported back to Georgie.

Next thing that happened was Lily decided to talk to Vivian and Narrisa about getting a new glamour. Lily knew she had to glamour as someone because she was a troll. Lily, Narrisa, and Vivian went to Georgie to ask where they could buy a glamour using black magic. He told them Aunty Green Leaf's house. Before buying the new glamour Vivian, Narrisa, and Lily took a picture near the street. Dee was in the picture somehow. Lily and the girls went back to the stripper room and took the glamour of Faith off. Lily stayed in the club until Narrisa got back with the new glamour. Narrisa hide the glamour body of Fath and put the head of the glamour on the stairs of The Woodlands Motel. This explains why Narrisa wants to talk to Bigby on episode 4.

Narrisa came back with a glamour tube which allowed Lily to look like Snow. Now Lily glamoured as Snow and had an appointment with Crane.

Vivian and Narrisa I think were accomplices to murder, but wasn't the actual murderers. Vivian was the one who would give Crane wine and massages, and set up appointments which explains why there was a wine bottle in the room. Narrissa also had a key to one of the rooms in the open arms motel. Maybe Lily isn't really dead because as episode 4 In Sheeps Wool foreshadows someone is playing games and buying glamours to look like people.

Faith and Lily a probably alive and disguise themselves to look like others. Now the scene at the open arms is similar to the death scene from the comics.

In the comics Rose Red Snows sister fakes her death by taking blood and putting the blood bags in the microwave. This caused and explosion that made blood go everywhere. So yea Lily probably faked her death like Rose Red. The body they buried could be another glamour. Faith could be glamoured too.

Now the killer is Goldie Locks we find out she been killing off Fables in the comics. Snow kills her though after trying to kill Bigby. So yea case is probably Closed now. Goldie Locks killed everyone and Narissa knows about it....

Comments

  • This is my theory feel free to look if you want...

  • Honestly, i don't think Goldie did it. But i guess i just gotta sit back and wait.

  • There're lots of spambots here

    Azlyn posted: »

    Shut the fuck up.

  • Wouldn't the glamoured Faith body, be Lily? I don't think a body is left when a person glamours into someone else? I might have misunderstood what you were saying though.

  • I don't think Telltale's staff are that much of assholes to not close the story and make you read the comic to find out Goldie is the killer. It doesn't seem like they made this game where you have to know much about it, hence it being a prequel.

  • Yea I mentioned that Lily was glamoured to look like Faith first. Then Narrisa hide the Faith glamours body and put the head on the door step of the woodslands motel. That explains the picture and the real reason she was at the woodsman's place. Lily's a troll so she needed to look pretty using glamours. So yea Lily, Vivian, and Narrisa all set this game up to screw with Bigby. The real Faith is still alive glamoured as someone else. In the comics I think Rose Red used a glamour that looked like Faith to escape her past. So yea Faith is probably disguised...

    Mariana238 posted: »

    Wouldn't the glamoured Faith body, be Lily? I don't think a body is left when a person glamours into someone else? I might have misunderstood what you were saying though.

  • It's pretty obvious tho. The Butcher is a axe man who chops Fables heads off at the farm. So episode 4 we will probably go to the farm to meet The Butcher. Goldie locks is a revolutionary Fable who kills off other Fables. She also works for Baba Yaba who is another vilian. Tell Tale doesn't expect players to read the comics first. They are opening up the series to people so they can read the comics. But those who already read the comics knows the villians and who the killer is.

    YepYepSyk posted: »

    I don't think Telltale's staff are that much of assholes to not close the story and make you read the comic to find out Goldie is the killer. It doesn't seem like they made this game where you have to know much about it, hence it being a prequel.

  • Bigby isn't allowed anywhere near the farm -_- And The Butcher is just that, a simple butcher. http://fables.wikia.com/wiki/The_Butcher,_the_Baker_and_the_Candlestickmaker
    And we know Lily is dead for sure, so your theory has 0 basis. Also, the reason Faith was at Woodie's place was because Lily asked her to go there for her, while she was going to get her Snow glamour and go to The Open Arms with Crane. So, sorry to say this but, your theory is just plain ridiculous and wrong. Also, Faith could possibly still be alive. The head we found could belong to someone glamoured to look like her, mostly because we didn't find her body or a glamour tube that could dispel the glamour from the head. The ribbon she had in her mouth could have been a random ribbon and her ring was probably stolen or something. Maybe she faked her own death, so she can escape the Tweedles who wanted a compromising photo of Crane she stole. I'm guessing that photo she stole was the same one Bigby found at the Open Arms. I'm guessing she might have been in that room with Crane once also glamoured as Snow, mostly because Crane was all like "WTF?!" when he found out the one glamoured to look like snow was Lily, a troll and not a human like Faith. So yeah, that's about all that happened.

    It's pretty obvious tho. The Butcher is a axe man who chops Fables heads off at the farm. So episode 4 we will probably go to the farm to me

  • We will go to the farm in episode 4. It's why we see a pig.. Either Colin or his brothers

    It's pretty obvious tho. The Butcher is a axe man who chops Fables heads off at the farm. So episode 4 we will probably go to the farm to me

  • Colin is clearly in Bigbys apartment still.

    We will go to the farm in episode 4. It's why we see a pig.. Either Colin or his brothers

  • So you don't think there will be any clues at the farm or anything?

    We are running out of leads.. Pretty sure your going to the farm 1 way or another

    Ascari posted: »

    Colin is clearly in Bigbys apartment still.

  • nope bigby ain't allowed there

    So you don't think there will be any clues at the farm or anything? We are running out of leads.. Pretty sure your going to the farm 1 way or another

  • Why not? Did I miss something

    zeke10 posted: »

    nope bigby ain't allowed there

  • Read the comics, seriously, read them. You can get digital versions for cheap.

    Why not? Did I miss something

  • There is one point that makes no sense:
    Lilly was glamoured as Faith when they took the photo, because she was a troll. But is the girl on the right? Vivian glamoured as Lilly? She wouldn't need to, because she is a human.

    Oh, and glamours don't produce "extra bodies" when they wear off.

  • Lily dun need glamour for woodie, nor does she need to pretend either. Woodie may not recognize her as faith she could just told him.

    Yea I mentioned that Lily was glamoured to look like Faith first. Then Narrisa hide the Faith glamours body and put the head on the door ste

  • Maybe because this is the prequel bigby allowed until something happens in ep4 witch prevents him from ever going back . Just a guess I haven't read the comics yet
    zeke10 posted: »

    nope bigby ain't allowed there

  • How would you know Vivian to be human?
    Grafite posted: »

    There is one point that makes no sense: Lilly was glamoured as Faith when they took the photo, because she was a troll. But is the girl on

  • 2 problems with this theory. 1. They actually have Faiths head and lily's head so the prediction that Lily was Faith went right out the window. 2. Lily told Faith to go to the woodsman's as confirmed by a note found in the pudding and pie in episode 2. Also, I doubt that Lily would let woodsman beat on her just to pretend she doesn't know him.
  • We wasn't allowed since the 18th century, basically ever since Fabletown existed. He is allowed after he marries Snow White in the comics.
    Mclovesth posted: »

    Maybe because this is the prequel bigby allowed until something happens in ep4 witch prevents him from ever going back . Just a guess I haven't read the comics yet

  • edited May 2014
    I don't, but the game would be very confusing if everyone was glamoured at some point:
    Vivian as Lilly, Lilly as Faith and then Snow, and Faith alive glamoured as someone else. (And Lilly too)
    If this theory was correct, I couldn't be sure that any Fable at all is what they look like and wouldn't be able to trust anyone!

    How would you know Vivian to be human?

Sign in to comment in this discussion.