How did you speak to ******? [SPOILERS]

sardines

Carver, I mean. During the little 'chat' he has with you in his office.

I ... actually really regret how I spoke to him, because I basically agreed with everything he said. Not because I really wanted my Clem to believe those things, but because I thought it would be lying, that it would keep her safe. ("I understand" etc etc.)

But then it seemed like... she really believed what she was saying. My brother pointed out afterwards that none of the options had [LIE] next to them. I think I may have royally fucked up. I might need to replay the whole game (making all the same decisions otherwise) just for this reason...

Did anyone else have Carver tell them he knew what Clem was like, before Kenny killed him? Like, he implied that Clem was the same as him, and hiding it. I walked away, but I realized then maybe I'd made a serious mistake in making Clem say those things. :/ I don't know. I'm probably overreacting, but...

SergeantSnookie

I didn't deny him, but I wasn't going to give him the luxury of seeing Clem agree with him either.

He admired her ability to look him in the eye with a glare, so that's exactly what I did.

RazorRed1313

I was as defiant as possible, called him a murderer and told him Kenny should have killed him.....and he respected me because nobody had the "balls" to talk to him like that but clementine. He seemed to think that clementine was what the future generations needed to be, strong enough to lead them out of the apocalypse. Out of curiosity what was his reaction to you agreeing with what he said ?

sardines

Similar to that, actually, if in a different way? If that makes sense. Me agreeing with him had Clem acting coldly, and he basically said (since I can't remember the exact wording) that she was just like him and she and him were the only people who knew how to survive in the apocalypse. I felt genuinely pretty sick agreeing with him, so I didn't the third time I was given a choice of what to say (I asked if the baby could be Alvin's instead.)

TheseTearsAreReal

I told him that I was nothing like him, and the thing is that I wasn't sure I believed it myself.

Omid

I gave him a total death stare and them proceeded to tell him Kenny should have killed him...

He loved it.

Mafon2

I noticed that too. That game needs [Lie] options.

My Clem told him that he's a murderer, errr... then i don't remember, but nor about the Kenny, nor about "Yavole" and [...]. I've choosen quite many [...]s and [stare at him] in this episode.

Piggs

I agreed with him. I figured I'd humor him. Let him think he had some power. Then I watched Kenny bash his skull in.

I'm a great person, I know.

Saltlick304

I was neutral agreeing and disagreeing with him and being silent once.

Fallen_Angel41

My Clem was honest about her dislike and hatred of him and his bullying ways. He still commented on how similar they are... and given the ending, I cannot help but agree with him.

thewatcheruatu

Just kept my mouth shut and let him keep talking. He's a narcissist, so I knew he wouldn't mind. I wasn't about to let Clem agree with him, but wasn't going to court another blow to the face, like the one he gave Clem at the beginning of the episode.

Rock114

I decided to let him know what I thought of him. I called him a murderer and said that I wish Kenny had killed him back at the lodge. And then, to my surprise, he approved of my responses. I can't actually believe telling him that I wished him dead made him so fond of me.

Welcome_to_Woodbury

I agreed with him, even when I didn't mean it. I wanted to get on his good side. I told him I'd help him out with the baby and stuff. Plus, at the very beginning, when Clem was supposed to get smacked, I apologized, so he didn't hit me.

Midian13

My Clem called him a bully, a murderer, and said she wished Kenny had killed him. He praised her ability to say that to his face where as others 'didn't have the balls' to, as well as her ability to look him in the eye back at the cabin even though she was afraid. He said she was raised right, and she was how he wanted his child to be. How the new generation should be, that the current one was weak. Yeah... I really didn't know how to take that.

Lee4ever

Ya I did the same to put on the best poker face. I hope TTG dosn't reuse that conversation.

RandomPrecision

I told him I wished Kenny had killed him as well and as others said he approved. As an aside,I was half expecting and full on wanting the ability to kick Carver before Kenny reconstructed his face. I don't regret having Clem watch one bit, despite what the others might think. I expect that to help her in the long run.

Ryudo_Tenjin

I told him what he wanted to hear... I was planning on betray him.

DingoEnderZOE2

I just glared at him and said I was nothing like him. The problem with just BLINDLY agreeing with someone or even "lying" is because even though you tell yourself you're lying, a part of you might just subconsciously actually believe the lie, which would be clever as hell if that was the reason behind telltales lack of "Lie" in front of those options.

ShadowHunter94

I glared at him and told him that I wished Kenny had killed him

Mr. Masamune

I told him he was a murderer and that we were nothing alike. Really, I spent most of the episode being as defiant as possible towards him. Took a beating for it, too.

Qipoi

I gave that guy the silent treatment! YEAH TAKE THAT CARVER!

....