sarita...(spoilors GET BACK)

danthedude1218

holy fuck my heart was pumping throughout this episode
good job telltale.
should i have cut saritas hand off? i didn't but it said at the end everyone else did. I feel so guilty but if I did cut her hand off she would of just bled out and died from blood loss

what did you do?

eblocksonian

I cut her hand off, and I don't feel guilty. I obviously feel BAD about it, but if you DIDN'T cut her hand off, the likelihood of her being zombified shoots up, even if you decide to cut it off later.

That said, there are some issues with cutting her hand off then and there. First, you cut off her hand with axe that has fresh zombie blood on it. You might not have actually helped much in that case. But let's say she doesn't get infected with immediate zombie death. She still has a regular infection to deal with. Third, she's going to bleed out. Unrleated to the injury, she yelled in pain and shock to seeing her hand gone. That's likely to draw the attention of the walkers.

If you choose to not cut her arm off, she might live if she doesn't get taken out by walkers in the herd, but saving her becames much less likely even if you decide to cut her arm off later. If you choose to cut her arm off there, you have to worry about the possible zombie infection from your blade anyway, and she has to contend with regular infection and bleeding. On top of that, she screamed at the top of lungs. If she manages to survive a possible zombie or non-infection, bleeding, AND makes it out of the zombie herd, she'll live, albeit with one hand.

It's a no-win situation. The first choice guarantees she lives for a short time while maximizing her chances of making it ouf of the herd, while second choice reduces her immediate survival, but if she doesn't get a zombie infection, she will have a bigger chance of survival.

Clayton_Boylan

This episode truly had my blood pumping. The whole time I was trying not to get Clem hit, but help out members of the group. It was hard as hell.

danthedude1218

ya dude talking to bonnie i didn't know if i should be truthful with her or not because i didn't want her to snitch on me to carver. and i was freaking out at the walking talkie stealing part because i thought Tavia was looking RIGHT at me and I was caught but I guess she's blind apparently.

glad troy got what he deserved

cameroncr95

I cut it off. It was her best chance. If we waited later, it would be irreversible like Lee.