What are your thoughts on Carver's death?
Do you think he deserved to die?
Do you think he needed to die?
Do you think Kenny was the right person to do it?
And, if you had killed Carver, how would you have done it?
#1: For the harm he did, and for all the innocent people he killed, I'd say Carver deserved to die.
#2: if Carver hadn't been killed, he would've just come after the group again. So yes I believe he needed to die.
#3: Despite what Carver did to him, I do not think Kenny should've necessarily been the one to do it.
#4: If it would've been me, before I killed him, I would've told him: " This is for Walter, Alvin, and Reggie, and for the harm you've inflicted on my friends who are still alive."
And then, since he's already incapacitated and unable to move, I would've left him for the walkers, like I did Andy St. John in my very 1st play through of season1.
Carver once he saw he was defenseless, wanted someone to kill him.
Cause it would lower that person to his level.
His attitude was: If I'm going down, than I'm taking someone down with me."
That's how evil he was!
And unfortunately Kenny fell for it, out of anger.
While Kenny's hatred and anger towards Carver were more than reasonable, and in many respects I can't fault his actions.
And, if Carver had killed Sarita, Kenny as her next of kin, would have the God-given right to avenge her death.
But bottom line is, Carver deserved and needed to die.
Whether or not Kenny should've been the one to kill him, and he did so, are questionable.
You'll have to decide that for yourself.
Do you think he needed to die?
Do you think Kenny was the right person to do it?
And, if you had killed Carver, how would you have done it?
#1: For the harm he did, and for all the innocent people he killed, I'd say Carver deserved to die.
#2: if Carver hadn't been killed, he would've just come after the group again. So yes I believe he needed to die.
#3: Despite what Carver did to him, I do not think Kenny should've necessarily been the one to do it.
#4: If it would've been me, before I killed him, I would've told him: " This is for Walter, Alvin, and Reggie, and for the harm you've inflicted on my friends who are still alive."
And then, since he's already incapacitated and unable to move, I would've left him for the walkers, like I did Andy St. John in my very 1st play through of season1.
Carver once he saw he was defenseless, wanted someone to kill him.
Cause it would lower that person to his level.
His attitude was: If I'm going down, than I'm taking someone down with me."
That's how evil he was!
And unfortunately Kenny fell for it, out of anger.
While Kenny's hatred and anger towards Carver were more than reasonable, and in many respects I can't fault his actions.
And, if Carver had killed Sarita, Kenny as her next of kin, would have the God-given right to avenge her death.
But bottom line is, Carver deserved and needed to die.
Whether or not Kenny should've been the one to kill him, and he did so, are questionable.
You'll have to decide that for yourself.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
2) Yeah but not too soon
3) I wouldn't say "right" but umm hey at least he got his revenge
4) I would've have just shoot him when I got the chance lol
2 I think yes, him dead means something less to worry about.
3 Yeah, Kenny lost his eye and his friend because of him, for me it was more than just revenge, it was something that had to be done.
4 you sure you wanna know? (Goes dark) I would have made him eat his eye, then i would have chopped his legs and arms with Luke's machete, and before he died of blood loss i would have threw him to walkers. Like i said he deserved more than dead.
2. You bet.
3. No. I would have preferred that Rebecca or Carlos do it, but I'm not completely against Kenny having the final say.
4. I would have just blown his head off, personally. I'm not in the habit of making things painful for people. Even though I wouldn't have taken the crowbar to his face, I feel no sympathy whatsoever for him and I can't exactly blame Kenny for doing it.