The Crooked Man did not kill Faith.
Ok, so I've seen a lot of people assuming that Crooky killed Faith and or Lilly. but he didn't kill Faith. He couldn't possibly have. why? Because he sent Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dum to investigate Faith's apartment. Dee says: "Easy Bigby, we're on the same side here. I'm trying to figure out who killed her, same as you are." Why would The Crooked Man have Faith killed then send Dee to find out who killed Faith? He wouldn't. What do you guys think? Yes? No? You're so stupid Thewalkingcommenter just stop making discussions? Fire away!
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
It was Larry.
If by Larry you mean Johan the Butcher, then yes, it might be.
So....... does anyone have an idea as to who killed faith?
It was Brenda St.John.
Hans.
Hm, you do have a good point there, but you have to keep in mind that episode 1 is different from the others in that from 2 onwards there was a significant change in the plan of how the plot would develop. So I'm thinking that some parts of Ep 1 are now moot, until we see otherwise.
It would be nice if it turned out Crooks ain't the main bad guy, but as I've said a few times on this forum, that would potentially leave us with a cliffhanger at the end of episode 5 and I'd rage like a motherfucker if that happened.
Well, maybe the murderer could be Bloody Mary. She is the type to enjoy killing and she is fucking insane so...
Georgy Porgy works for the Crooked man yes? Then the Crooked Man is responsible for the ribbons on their necks so he still killed them.
I have a feeling Bluebeard's involved.
faith and lilly are most probably killed by different people and for different purposes.
And that's why her body hasnt been found.
It was possible that he was there to collect evidence from her house. Possibly to frame the Woodsman or someone?
He actually sent Dee there to find the compromising photo that would have led to the incarceration of TCM's cash cow, Crane, which Faith stole in a conspiracy to overthrow TCM.
EDIT: Here.
http://www.servimg.com/image_preview.php?i=17&u=18464767
He's in the comics
No no no, that doesn't work from a narrative standpoint. She's already been revealed, and to have her tell us she's the killer all the time would leave episode 5 as one big chore. A 1.5-2 hour long fight scene or hunt. I don't want that. I don't play Telltale's games for action, I play them for the story, plot, characters, attention to detail. Action is a distant fifth or sixth item on my list of important things I want from Telltale.
If you've read enough book, seen enough movies, played enough games you get a feel for the rhythm and rhyme of storytelling, and if you've studied, even casually from home, how story structure works, you'll too notice how Telltale is walking a thin line between giving us a great ending and a disappointing one.
Don't give us an ME3 or Halo 2 here, TT. For the love of god, don't. Get. LAZY.
The killer is TCM
Again, that would just lead to an over-extended hunt or action sequence. Crooky has to have some piece of info we've overlooked.
The Crooked Man ordered either Vivian or Bloody Mary to kill Faith. The most realistic evidence in episode 1 is Faith's line "I won't be doing this for much longer, so now's your chance." And Bigby's line that always ends in "or they wanted to get out".