S2E3 How did this happen?
How does Luke get the walkie talkie? It was decided that Clem would find Luke and give him one but Clem didn't find him. So, how did he get one? Did someone else give him one or are we supposed to assume he went snooping and found one himself? This may not matter for the story but it baffles me. Maybe I've missed something. I've played this thru a couple of times and I wish it was a little more clear. If he would have met Clem like the plan then perhaps they wouldn't have gotten caught or at least Kenny would have both eyes.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
This honestly confused me too. I had thought about it for a good while. I had my issues with Episode 3 but I thought the story was good except for this now noticeable plot hole.
Wait Luke got one after? I didnt know about this
Well Clementine took two radios. I believe Carver found the radio they were keeping for themselves so they could talk to Luke. Of course with no confirmation, this is just a theory.
There was a thread about that someone in the group might be a traitor. Maybe this is true and someone told Carver.
I agree. Clem took the other walkie talkie with her to give to Luke.
yea i think sarah did she was left on roof with him alone he could ask her to come speak to him if the group makes plans to escape or threatened her
Didn't Kenny take a walkie talkie as well?
Clem took two, right?
WHERE DOES IT SAY that Carver got the talkie from Luke?
There might be a traitor!!
Plan with walkie talkies was super dumb. They should have dug a tunnel. During night. Morgan Freeman's pal did it in the movie.
I KNOW!!! I THINK SOMEONE SNITCHED OUT LUKE!
That actually would make sense. I did wonder what they were talking about.
No clem was only given one.
She took TWO though. She gave one to one of the members in the group and took the other one to give it to Luke.
My theory is that Kenny and Mike knowing Clem could not give her walkie talkie to Luke thanks to Bonnie intervening, took it upon themselves to give the other walkie talkie to him. They somehow dropped it off to Luke at the comic shop when the worst guard ever Troy was not looking and then went to work. Luke then failed his sneaking QTE trying to get something to eat and then got busted. The rest is pretty much history and I do realize that this all happens under a very small time frame, but it does seem to fit.
Yeah, I misunderstood the above post. I was meaning when he got caught.
That all would make sense.
This topic came up before on this forum, so I'll say my theories:
Guards just caught Luke and made him confess the plan which prompted Carver to get the first radio from the group, regardless of whoever had the first one.
Someone in the group might've just misplaced it and someone like Troy found it. He gave a sad look when Carver was beating Kenny, maybe because of regret?
There is a traitor. Bonnie?(Clem could reveal the plan to her), Jane?(mysterious & interested in her own goals), Sarah?(Carver could've brainwashed her to "do what's good for the community")