›

Been thinking

ulop22ulop22
in The Walking Dead

When you had the choice of cutting off Sarita's arm (if you cut it off) maybe it was a mistake?
The axe had been in zombie's stomach so you should probably wash it before cutting off anyone's hand.
Now Sarita still has the infection (maybe) and she will turn. If you chose to kill the zombie you'll find some clean weapon to cut it off.
But then Sarita could not stand the pain so she's not going to let that happen.
So this leaves Sarita dead no matter what you do.

Let the dislikes come.

Comments

  • that1personthat1person

    Yes, I had the same thought Sarita would die anyways, no matter what you chose to do. :( Too bad we can't save her for the next episode.

  • SymbolzSymbolz

    Here's the way I think about it:

    If you don't cut off the arm, Sarita will die. If you do cut off the arm, Sarita might die. Cutting off the arm is Sarita's only chance at living, however slight those odds are. Even if the odds are as low as 1% chance to live, it is still better than 0%.

  • ulop22ulop22
    edited June 2014

    Yeah, I liked her. It's sad that telltale decided to make her die. (If not by cutting or not cutting off the arm then some other way if she's determinant )

    Symbolz posted: »

    Here's the way I think about it: If you don't cut off the arm, Sarita will die. If you do cut off the arm, Sarita might die. Cutting of

  • Team_PurpleTeam_Purple

    Either way I think she's dead. If you cut her arm off, it's likely she'll pass out from pain or bloodloss, and even if she does survive she will have an open and festering wound. And on the point of the axe infecting her, I highly doubt that it would circulate. Killing the walker would probably give her a better chance of surviving. She can walk and move and has a better chance of getting to a safe place for an amputation.

  • AnawerAnawer

    IMO If you dont cut it and wait, it will be Lees situation allover again.
    We saw two situations. Lee - amputation after hour or so. And he turned.
    Reggie - fast cut after few seconds. He did not turn.
    And i dont think that we would be able to find "clean" tool to amputate her hand fast enough.

    So if you kill zombie it is 100% chance she will turn. If you cut her hand, she has slim chance that she will survive.

  • snakecharmerofborgsnakecharmerofborg

    True, but that was only Reggie's account of what happened. Personally I believe Carver did the deed, but cutting it straight away should give her at least some slim hope.

    Anawer posted: »

    IMO If you dont cut it and wait, it will be Lees situation allover again. We saw two situations. Lee - amputation after hour or so. And he

  • MrAppleJuiceMrAppleJuice

    I think it would be cool if she actually survives when you don't cut her arm off. It would be a good way to trick the player, you think your making the right decision by cutting off her arm straight away but your actually making it worst.

  • ulop22ulop22

    Yeah that's what I thought too :D

    MrAppleJuice posted: »

    I think it would be cool if she actually survives when you don't cut her arm off. It would be a good way to trick the player, you think your making the right decision by cutting off her arm straight away but your actually making it worst.

  • MrAppleJuiceMrAppleJuice

    Great minds think alike :P

    ulop22 posted: »

    Yeah that's what I thought too

Sign in to comment in this discussion.