DId you kill the st john brothers?

Comments

  • Yep, killed both of them.

  • I only killed danny but I didnt know clementine was watching and i kinda regretted it when I first played episode 2.

  • dojo32161dojo32161 Moderator

    I didn't kill either of them.

  • Killed Em both, not taking chances... Plus, they f*cked with the wrong ninja.

  • I killed Danny with the pitchfork, left Andy to get eaten by his mommy. Fair trade.

  • Killed them both.

  • edited July 2014

    Killed Andy and left Danny to suffer.

  • I killed them both, witnesses be damned. I know this is strongly worded, but the men who killed Mark, deceived us into eating human meat, forced us into a situation where Larry dies, Kenny gets shot, Duck becomes a hostage, and Clementine is threatened deserved nothing more than a swift execution. Morals dictate that I kill the men who killed and ate so many people.

  • Exactly how I felt.

    I killed them both, witnesses be damned. I know this is strongly worded, but the men who killed Mark, deceived us into eating human meat, fo

  • An eye for an eye, you should have eaten them.

    I killed them both, witnesses be damned. I know this is strongly worded, but the men who killed Mark, deceived us into eating human meat, fo

  • Wasn't an option.

    Viva-La-Lee posted: »

    An eye for an eye, you should have eaten them.

  • Lee's choices reflected what I would have done. I'm a pretty merciful person, but if I found out some crazy fuckers tried to feed us my buddy's legs, I would probably lose it and react accordingly.

    So that's what Lee did.

  • Not even a nibble?

    Wasn't an option.

  • i wouldn't sweat it... if she knew what kind of danger they were in...i would assume she would do the same...

    Saltlick304 posted: »

    I only killed danny but I didnt know clementine was watching and i kinda regretted it when I first played episode 2.

  • i only killed Danny in my first playthrough, then i played it again and spare both, ( i left the second as my main one)

  • Let them both live, but i don't know if that was right, I'm kinda like Luke, If i don't have to kill someone I won't because even if i hate their guts that still does not justify murder and doesn't make me killing them any less wrong, the reason I say im not sure if it was the right choice is because they most likely suffered painful death, but I gave them a chance and didn't take their lives and I don't regret it

  • edited July 2014

    Didn't kill either, why get blood on your hands when you know they're going to die anyways

  • First time I killed Danny only because I didn't see the option to leave him be (I would have picked it if I saw it). I didn't know Clem was watching and replayed it to see if there was any other way I could not kill Danny. I found it, face palmed and left him in that trap.

    With Andy, I always walk away.

    Therefore I didn't kill either :)

  • edited July 2014

    I killed them both....Sometimes someone have to do that whether people like it or not. In that case, It was me.
    I was sure that if i didn't kill them, they would try to avenge to us....

  • I killed Danny because I knew Lilly would be all "u fkn kil mi daddy but not dis ashol? fk u lee" So, yeah. Then Clementine saw it and I was like "FUCK."

  • I didn't kill either of them. The first brother was already screwed since he was caught in a trap and I didn't want Clementine to see it. I left the other brother alive to deal with losing his family (hey, if they didn't try to feed us meat then it wouldn't have happened so) and having his farm be overrun by zombies.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.