Would you still like Luke if......
Mrwalto69
Banned
Okay so all i see with Luke is people fighting over who's better out of him and Kenny so i thought i'd post something different.
There's a lot of speculation as to why Luke keeps taking off and not saying why he keeps doing it and now some say in the new trailer his with the group but then his not so my question is to all the Luke fans.
If and this is a BIG IF not saying it will happen, Luke ends up betraying the group or turns against them, would you still like Luke? Trust is a big thing in the ZA and if he did broke that trust, how could someone forgive him? If he did it once, then yes but numerous times? No disrespect but i can't see how people trust him.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
I don't see Luke betraying the group, he may run away because of his phobia of being bit, but i'm sure he would come back and try to help anyway he could.
I'm not sure how to feel about Luke. We still don't know what happened that caused him and Kenny to get separated. Even then, he spent days tracking Carver's prison caravan back to the Howe's and tried to break them out (that didn't work out but I doubt it was intentional). I think he could be trusted. If he does end up disappearing without good cause, then...
So...his betrayal would be him taking off with another group?
Well to me it just seems like he's playing devil's advocate. He's telling the group basically what he said back in the pen at Carver's camp: "He just wants to make the best of a bad situation."
If it was a situation where Kenny's becoming suicidal, and he starts attempting suicide, maybe letting him be with Katjaa, Duck, and Sarita would be the best. But he's he's still alive and well and he doesn't seem to be making any suicidal threats, then I would be pretty angry if Luke just abandoned us with the rest of the group.
Could be anything, him with another group, kills one of the members of the group, doesn't help save someone from walkers.
My biggest question that i don't get is why does he got taking off? There must be something behind it, otherwise telltale wouldn't keep doing it.
Where are you going with this?
Kenny appears to be in the majority's favor at the moment in the Pizza VS Ice Cream wars. Why do you suggest that LUKE would be the one attacked with such negative writing and character flaws? Why make the choice easier for those who want more Kenny and harder for those who want more Luke development?
But in any case, it would not change anything as long as Telltale would write his betrayal decently.
I have had enough of Kenny's personal drama. It is Luke's turn to develop.
Well...the only time in Episode 4 that I saw any hint of him being gone was in the teaser trailer, and we all know that's not usually close to being relevant to the actual episode. I know he didn't show up for most of the trailer, but I don't think he left.
Equally, if Kenny ends up betraying the group or turns against them, would YOU still like HIM?
Don't change anything for me. I still like Luke. I don't think he betrayed the group. She like Clem (bro-sis), so this betrayal won't happening in my option.
I do agree that Kenny has had enough character development to the point where that most of us like him and we know enough about him to sort of guess what he'd probably do next. I also agree that Luke should have some more time for character development. If the famous pizza vs ice cream decision (the one we all think will happen ie. Kenny vs Luke) occurs, it'd be nice for players to have a harder time deciding between Kenny and Luke. For me it's already a tough decision but I think more Kenny "deterioration" and more Luke "heroics" might make for a harder decision for players. Of course some people already know or think they know who they might choose already and won't change their minds but for others it might change their minds on who they'll pick if something huge happens.
Why would Luke betray the group? The guy tracked Carver for days, on foot, without any food or sleep just to get the group back. Him betraying them after going to such lengths to save them, even if he failed in the end, seems unlikely at best.
How does he 'keep taking off'? He disappeared once and he explained why, to follow the group back to camp, which he did at great personal risk. As for episode 4, we have no context as to what's happening with him there yet, so I don't see why that's being used against him. Luke had his chance to leave the group to save his own neck and he did the complete opposite, why would he suddenly do it now?
To be honest, a lot of the 'I don't trust Luke' complaints seem more about him clashing with Kenny then anything Luke's actually done to make himself seem suspicious.
I don't trust Luke
If Luke is making the best choice for survival, then yes.
It's simple. He is a threat to Kenny, his character contradicts Kenny's. Which upsets some of the more "hardcore Kenny fans."
I don't trust him because he's too nice ran away and i don't believe his excuse for running away
Yep
I love Luke, I pray to him every night untill i summon him, it hurts, but i do it for Luke
Well then I'm sure most Luke fans would feel the same way.
I certainly wouldn't like either of them if they did that.
This. This. This.
People are finding faults because they are searching for them in desperation, as they perceive Luke as a threat to Kenny.
But him running away can't have been him betraying the group, otherwise he wouldn't have returned to find them at great personal risk.
Plus lines like those are typically very misleading. Luke could pop in literally two seconds later if they keep that line in.
He's going to have to be around for most of the episode if they're setting up Luke vs. Kenny. He's going to be around for the end of the episode too, since Rebecca giving birth will be near the end and Luke is seen in the background during that part of the trailer.
And that line:
Luke: Hey; you okay?
Clem: No.
That's obviously at a lower, more calm point in the episode. If there's one.
I've always had the feeling that maybe Luke and Kenny, once again, disagreed on how to deal with Carver and his people at the ski lodge (hence Kenny saying that Luke was "whining about something"). Kenny looks pretty angry if you tell him that they should look for Luke instead of immediately trusting his plan. Luke may of went his own way, looking for a way to help, and then realized he couldn't at that particular time. Luke couldn't have gone against Carver's team without getting killed or captured as well. Honestly, it's probably best to have someone on the outside helping.
What i think is Luke has another group and that's where he ran off too and his group he ran off too is spying on Clems group and Luke is a spy.
Agreed. Their postures don't look tense, as if they're anticipating a fight or anything similar. Luke is leaning pretty casually against the railing and Clem has her legs hanging over.
What a weird question. Is there anyone you wouldn't dislike if they betrayed you numerous times?
Problem is…what is she so sad about…?
Maybe somebody died. Or something bad happened.
I could see it being after Sarita passes. Clem could feel guilty for not being able to save her or do very much.
Or perhaps she blames herself for Sarita's death, or feels responsible.
Well, telltale ain't exactly hiding the fact that Luke does disappearing acts, as per the teaser for episode 4. Personally I don't think there is any trust issues between Clem and Luke specifically, because it's obvious that he cares about her and is prepared to protect her. However, his disappearances could go beyond just being 'flakey'. Surely he is better off being in a big group, unless he believes that they are dragging him down and wants to convince Clem that this is the case?
Could be he is running and hiding from something or someone, we don't know.
Edit: Double-post. Sorry
Ironically, the character in you profile pic is the reason we're still gonna have a lot of character development from Kenny this episode!
Uh...based on what evidence?
I would understand Kenny, because look what this group has brought him.
None of them are having the best time mate.
Did you still like Lilly after she killed Doug/Carley? Because she went through similar emotional damage to what Kenny has gone through this season.
This is grassy knoll levels of conspiracy theories here.
Unless you're suggesting that Luke was involved with that as well.
This is a stupid question. . . clearly if he betrays the group I, nor most of his "fans", would still trust him.
Yep, and i still hopes she comes back. Cant blame her for what happend
Nah.
thats a good question and if he did do that i would be angry with him but if he did something that endangered clem if i had a choice to kill him i would