theory about the dog
Anyone else think that killing(or leaving to suffer) Sam will come back to bite us in a similar fashion that stealing from the van in S1 had. What if the owner came after us for revenge in the finale? What do you guys think?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
i hope not but i doubt that the dog even had an owner as it was obviously starving otherwise it wouldn't have tried to rip Clementines arm off
" your choices still matter " - cliché
I think the owner was the guy that was tied on the tree, the one where you get the knife.
I don't see how that could be possible since Clem was talking to the stranger in s1 and there was no one around when we kill Sam but you never know
My theory was that it was really sad
I highly doubt it. Sam's purpose was to lure you into a false sense of security.
Nice theory, very doubtful but I like ya train of thought, take my like.
How would they know Clem did it?
Thanks.
. . . Is this serious? This is exactly what I mean by stupid threads. Sorry for being rude but like, what goes through your head where you think this is any sort of a plausible theory?
While I agree that this is very douptful for a hand full of reason why is it any less plausible than the stranger in S1 ep5? you dont get anymore nuts than that.
Hey anything could happen!
How did the T-rex show up inside the Visitor Center in Jurassic Park, without atleast alerting them to it's presence since it shook the ground whenever it walked? There's always implausible situations in movies, games, ect. They could say the man/woman was watching Clementine from the trees, when it happened. There was a photo of the a family, with Sam, in that old broken down van. Let's say the woman in that picture came back for the photo and the dog but some Walkers showed up so she climbed the tree to get away, even fell asleep while waiting for the Walkers to leave, but woke up and saw a little girl kicking her dog over a rock. The woman doesn't alert Clementine, just watches in horror as her dog is suffering...
I thought this through before posting the thread and find this more plausible then some of the other crazy crap I've seen in movies...
ok first it was a rock not a car second you can see clem's hurt arm and three clem says sorry sam if she knows his name al that happens really quick
First, I edited it. Don't know why I said car. Ty for pointing that out. Second, seeing the bite or Clementine saying sorry doesn't bring the dog back to the owners I saw in the photo, if their alive(again, this is a THEORY). Not everyone is as forgiving as the Matthew situation so the owner could still be absolutely livid. "sorry" doesn't bring people back to life, that includes pets.
true but even from the trees you can see clem's arm is bleeding bad and the dogs mouth is caked with her blood no mother will hunt a little girl for killing her dog in self defense
Fair enough but that doesn't mean someone else wouldn't. There was more then one person in that photo with Sam. What if the kid from the photo lost his parents and only had the dog left. Kids would definitely hurt other kids. Besides, it's an insane world now in TWD. People's humanity isn't as in tact as it was before...
that was a girl dude and she was like 6 in the photo so she might be 9 now in the photo sam was a about 3 years younger i lived with dogs all my life so i can make a good guess
Sorry. I didn't get a good look at the kid in the photo. Still though. I don't think I diserve 8(and probably more soon) dislikes for having an opinion on what MIGHT happen in the finale. I know I wasn't expecting "welcome back to the forums" but this much hate over an opinion is BS. I have a dog and would be livid, if someone killed him. I don't think I'd kill someone but I figured some psycho would.
Anyways, thanks for having a rational discussion with me instead of just flat out calling my theory stupid.
no problem i got a relatively good memory for details. I had fun with the discussion
Triple H: Ya see, here's the thing...
Punk: (zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz...)
That's very stupid..Very fucking stupid. The dog died regardless if we put it out of it's misery or not.
I left that mutt to suffer.
feels good man
Yea, so? People stole from the fucking van in season 1, no matter what you choose, and that fucking Stranger came after us anyway! Why don't you, instead of automatically shooting down my idea so rudely, actually think about it!
i dislike that downvote
No need for that web head...
stationwagon that's the stranger's car and you do have a point we need to think outside the box
I'm fairly certain that the entire family is dead.