The Walking Dead Game VS The Walking Dead Show
Which do you think is better? Comment below...
Me personally i like the game more due to the fact that it comes to conclusions and you really grow fond of the characters. This game is the only one that has actually made me cry, and emotional ;_; And by the way, Clementine is so bad ass!
The show is also good, but no way near the game. Good job Tell tale! This game easily deserves 10/10!
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
game by far
I like them both for different reasons.
I would have to say the show because I'm a fan of the comics.
The TV Series is good, but it's NOT as good as the game in any way. (Aside from the action, The TV Series does action better) but the game pretty much does everything else better.
The game is MUCH better IMO, but I'm still a fan of both.
Shit man I would cry like a bitch too if my son shot my wife.
Definitely the game IMO.
Rick still is and always was a Badass! (Even though i didn't like the way he got beat up by the Governor, in the TV show)
It's the bad writing, that makes the TV show less enjoyable.
Well...
JUDITH GRIMES FOR LIFE.
I really like both of them. My journey with The Walking Dead started with TV Show.
But... I think I like game more. Slightly but yeah - I like game more. Why? Characters, story, impact of the story and emotions that you feel during your playthrough. I mean TV Show also has good story, characters etc. but I still think that in this aspects game is much better.
lolol that second picture is not so pleasant because she's about to get stabbed.
Well it kind of did make sense for Rick to lose the fight due to the fact of how he was shot in the leg, and had a broken hand. During the battle, the only mishap with the Governor was that he only had one eye. Either way, the Governor is known to be skilled for hand-to-hand combat.
Both have their strengths, I guess. Still, the game does have more than the tv show.
I won't say the game is leagues above the show, no, but it is better. I actually like the show, but words cannot express how much I hated the second half of the forth season! It's like they took every thing that is wrong with the show, and then they shoved it in our faces for the next 8 episodes with cheesy moments, ridiculous sub plots and stupid fillers....Carl "growing up", the whole Daryl and Beth episode(God, that must be one of the worst things I have ever watched), Maggie's obsession with finding Glenn, even though her sister was still out there, the list goes on....but I would rather not remember all the cringing moments that happened.
It's really a shame, because the first half of the forth season is probably my favorite, or at least on par with the first season.
Oh, and Daryl better bite the dust in the next season, or I'll swear to God...
Well...i guess that makes sense to some extent. But i still didn't like the way, Rick lost this fight. He was starting to beat the shit out of the Governor and suddenly he started to get beaten by him. Anyway, Rick still is and always was a Badass!
She is a motherfucking teleporting baby! There is one episode where she is with Carol, Tyreese and the two girls (forgot their names) after the groups get split up and she just keeps teleporting in and out of the scene. What sorcery is this?
TWDG all the way.
Mainly because Carl annoys the shit out of me; whereas Clementine is really likable. Seriously though, will that kid ever die? I just want to shotgun that damn hat off of his head.
On top of that I never accepted the transition of why the group considered Rick to be their leader so fast; while with Lee it was much more realistic that he became their group leader.
The only reason I even like TWD TV show is because Daryl is OP. He's character is awesome. Really, really great character development with him as well.
Yeah i know right. The governor was beating him into a pulp afterwards. But yeah, Rick and Daryl are my favorite from the show. From the game, easily Clem and Lee.
At the start of Season 2 of the game, I would have easily said the game. But let's be real here, the game got a lot worse since Season 1, it's still one of my favourite games, but it's nowhere near the level of Season 1 anymore.
Shorter Episodes, less hubs, sometimes bad character development (Rebecca and Carlos attitude change in 202,...) and not really that important choices.
The show was and still is great, better than Season 2 of the game imho.
You can't compare them that much, as one is produced by a giant TV-label and the other one by a (former) indie company, and the show has way more time at it's hand to develop characters and tell more storylines etc.
But I think the show is better as the game at what they are each trying to do, making it more enjoyable for me at this point.
Imo:
Season 1 game > Season 1 show > Season 3 show > Season 4 show > Season 2 game > Season 2 show
How about both? * mexican music starts playing *
I love both and I really don't want to pick one over the other, and I don't see any reason to.
my opinion is the comic blows both the show and game out of the water, but the game is far better than the show. id much rather sit down and play the walking dead game than watch the tv show.
The comic.
Game > Comic > Show
I love both but I have to say that the Game has a better story.
Every episode that I play from Telltale makes me more pissed off at the show. After the first season, each of the rest balance from 70%-80% boring, lame, and monotonous to 20%-30% actually good.
I love the show but the game is so much better to me.
Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game. Game.