Who will be our "Judge" this Season?
Since Season 1 had the Stranger and The Wolf Among Us had The Crooked Man or the people of Fabletown to yell at you for your choices, who will it be this time? I also find it weird if someone yells at a child's choices. Anyway, I think it's Christa.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Well, there isn't anyone who'd know what we were choosing. And having some other person judging you again would feel a little copy and paste, you know?
How are people like Christa and Lilly going to be our judges? They weren't there for most of season two.
Ghost Lee
It can't be Christa. She hasn't been around for a long time.
Also there's already a thread exactly like this
Maybe it's Luke. Clementine told him that 'sometimes people die because of me' and he knows about Lee, too.
I don't know, just a thought.
Clomid
Luke is really the only living character that would work, since he seems to have not lost his morality in the apocalypse. I'm guessing it might be a Lee hallucination though, no living character was there for all of your choices, and it has potential for a VERY emotional scene.
Maybe because Kenny and/or Luke will explain what happened after they were separated.
I don't know, If Luke told me I made bad choices my Clem would be like "Really? You're gonna judge me over my choices when you made some bad ones yourself?"
I think Clem will have a short conversation with Christa, Clementine can choose to lie about her choices or not. But I think this episode the judge thing won't be a big part of the episode.
You might as well say that about the Stranger too. He judged Lee when he carried around the severed head of his dead waifu. Yes. I said waifu.
I think that Luke has made some stupid choices, but he hasn't made any bad/evil ones or anything. He didn't even want to kill Carver, who he has acknowledged he REALLY hates. He's one of the only morally good people left IMO.
I like Luke. I really do. He's not like the stranger, I wasn't making that comparison. I was just saying, if we are talking about who has the right to judge, Luke is far better in comparison to the psycho stranger dude.
One thing I remembered about all the "BLANK will remember that choices." One of the biggest ones that made me go, HUH, was when you watch Kenny killed Carver. It says, THEY will remember that. The only person left of THEY who could remember that is Luke, Kenny (who won't judge you for it) Bonnie, and Mike. Luke would be the only person in my opinion who could bring up your choices.
Stealing the supplies from the group (even though he was in your defense)
Going with the dying Pete or the living Nick
Sticking up for Nick
Faking Friendship or having a real friendship with Sarah
Sitting with him or Kenny
Watching Carver be killed
Stealing from Arvo
Trying to Save Sarah
All these decision, Luke has been there for. He's the prime candidate as Judge. But I don't think Luke is going to really 'judge' Clem unless she was habitually evil or bad through the whole game. But he's no Stranger, and I'm NOT comparing the two.
Lilly perhaps?
I agree with you, I was addressing how bloop said he had made bad choices.
Arvo?
The Crooked Stranger Man?
Amazing theory 10/10 -IGN
IMO it was implied to be luke back in ep.1 (you don't kill dogs) and ep.4 (when he can (optionally) talk to you about carver)
Either Christa or Ghost Lee.
Well, they will remember a little girl watched a man get brutally killed. lol
I'll be the judge of that...
I call it now, the judge will be Clem making a choice herself. If we let her be ruthless, she will be ruthless,and that is how the season shall end.
Lee in a dream...
The Racoon.
Raccoon. Proof is in my thread http://www.telltalegames.com/community/discussion/comment/1494708#Comment_1494708
I'd like clem to be the judge of herself. Imagine this: she's the only person still alive, seriously injured, and starts thinking about everything she did. And if she dies (I hope not) she can die smiling or with a sad face depending on what choices you (she) made.
More like this: HORRIBLE graphics, confusing story, terrible menu's, and HORRENDUS gameplay... 10\10 -IGN (number one site for paid reviews)
As much as this sounds like a joke, since they've shown in this new trailer that they aren't afraid to use visions of Clem's mind, I would think she might have a moment to talk to Lee again as a vision, or dream. It'd be awesome. Lee then points out everything shes done to correct her for how she's strayed from his teachings and remind her of her goals again. Dunno though seems a longshot. Then again everything sounds like a longshot.
Uh...
How did they show they aren't afraid to use visions of Clem's mind in the trailer?
I don't think the treehouse scene was her dream or imagination, I think we were just seeing it happen. Otherwise we would have seen it from the perspective of clem, not Sandra.
You are your own worst judge.
Because they cut to Clem at the end of it, like it was a memory she had. Sure it was from Sandra's point of view but it was a technique that was showing Clem was thinking about that time, to me at least.
I'd say Luke as he seems to have kept his humanity the most out of all of the living characters however he already did 'judge' us in episode 4 when he could either say "you watched your friend murder Carver not just kill but, Clem you didn't even blink" and if you say "what Kenny did bothered me" then Luke says "There's still hope for you then." I'm not sure whether he would say it again then, maybe if you choose to shoot Rebecca Luke might say "you didn't even hesitate" and then Clem will think over her choices, and if you called for help Luke may say "you did the right thing" or something
EDIT: I didn't know that someone also posted this/something like this. Sorry.
It's probably the racoon, you can see him in the trailer (foreshadowing?). Theory: He was following and watching Clem in both Season 1 and 2. We will meet him near the end of the episode and he will point a pistol at Clem, and will confront her about her choices. Then ghost Lee appears smacking the racoon in the head with a bottle.
It's already been Kenny. He judged us in Episode 4, he'll do it again.
Amazing theory
10/10 -IGN
I'm not sure if she was thinking of it, it was just a home video showing Clem at her house. It does have meaning though.
Yep. Besides, raccoon judges all.
I still think it was just to show how far she's come, not that she was reminiscing