Armour withstands 900kg?
Really?
I'll take your word for it, I assume you're running on superior knowledge. I know that people do die from having horses fall on them, but I'll defer to your judgement.
who say's he's dead in the first place? a singer, in the books. Survived both a horse and a man landing on him. Rodrik only had a horse landing on him and a stab in the back of the leg. Surely the leg wound wouldn't of contributed much.
I'm not sure if you've noticed yet, but Telltale doesn't seem to care much about who can realistically survive what. TWD Season 2 featured a little girl dropping into a frozen lake and then being shot and basically shrugging it off as if it never happened.
It's just that bullshit lazy writing excuses from Telltale is what will bring them down and they don't need that. If they are going to bring Rodrik back, they better have a good fucking excuse, hence my theory.
I'm not sure if you've noticed yet, but Telltale doesn't seem to care much about who can realistically survive what. TWD Season 2 featured a… more little girl dropping into a frozen lake and then being shot and basically shrugging it off as if it never happened.
It's just that bullshit lazy writing excuses from Telltale is what will bring them down and they don't need that. If they are going to bring Rodrik back, they better have a good fucking excuse, hence my theory.
I like your thinking, but I don't think Rodrik gets revived by Thoros.
[Spoiler]
In the book, it's noted that when Lady Stoneheart is revived, Beric Dondarrion dies. This leads me to believe that if Rodrik was revived it would kill Beric leaving him unable to bring back LS, making the theory impossible.
His death was pretty fast paced in comparison to most other deaths in this episode where character are run clean through. They could easily … morejust try to justify him managing to survive a la Tyrion style.
Edit:
Oh and the first thing he'll say is "Wheres that asshole of a squire, I mean what the actual fuck? Im fighting three guys unprepared and the prick distracts me twice, what a prick"
Wait, Rodrik survives? Dammit! you had one job Gared,One job! :P lol, I hope that happens, it would be hysterical when they reunited considering Gared told Lord Forrester that he had died leaving Rodrik squished and abandoned under a horse in the middle of the Red Wedding >_<
Nah, its not confirmed yet but there a lot of things sort nodding toward that Telltale will bring him back. This is just a likely theory to explain how he could have survived.
Wait, Rodrik survives? Dammit! you had one job Gared,One job! :P lol, I hope that happens, it would be hysterical when they reunited conside… morering Gared told Lord Forrester that he had died leaving Rodrik squished and abandoned under a horse in the middle of the Red Wedding >_<
Right but Henry VIII was probably taken care of immediately after he fell. Rodrik would have fallen in the middle of a bloody battle where all his comrades are being slain around him.
Henry VIII survived a horse falling on him during a tournament, though a leg that was injured in the fall never fully recovered.
Rodrik surviving the forse falling him isn't entirely far-fetched.
I think I know the answer. I played again and noticed that the horse wasn't real. It was PANTOMIME HORSE. Rodrik hid inside and escaped.
No doubt Forresters are clever.
I'd like to think it's somehow related to Bowen. Like Bowen and Norren found Rodrik alive and managed to get him to safety. So if you chose to save Bowen as your first major choice, then Rodrik is still alive. If you didn't, he's dead.
It can happen. For Rodrik to come back i mean. He'll probably appear as a prisoner of the Freys, or something else.
I mean, a horse, being as heavy as you like, can't kill a man outright. Also, he fell on his lower torso only, where no vital (but equally important) organs are situated. But he most probably broke both is legs in the process. If rescued fast enough, he could've survived. Maybe Norren saved him?
Rodrik being dead or alive might also be incidental on wheter you saved Norren's squire ot not. I don't think Norren can lift a horse on his own, but maybe with his squire helping him...
Comments
Well he has a beard.
You know as well as I do what's going to happen. It's pointless debating a fictional story.
who say's he's dead in the first place? a singer, in the books. Survived both a horse and a man landing on him. Rodrik only had a horse landing on him and a stab in the back of the leg. Surely the leg wound wouldn't of contributed much.
I'm not sure if you've noticed yet, but Telltale doesn't seem to care much about who can realistically survive what. TWD Season 2 featured a little girl dropping into a frozen lake and then being shot and basically shrugging it off as if it never happened.
It's just that bullshit lazy writing excuses from Telltale is what will bring them down and they don't need that. If they are going to bring Rodrik back, they better have a good fucking excuse, hence my theory.
He got lucky. Real lucky.
Can you pm me?
Did you get my PM? I might have accidently cancelled it.
If you are talking about Lady Stoneheart, i heard that she is being left out of the show entirely.
I think I know the answer. I played again and noticed that the horse wasn't real. It was PANTOMIME HORSE. Rodrik hid inside and escaped.
No doubt Forresters are clever.
You can't possibly mean that...he might have got lucky?!
real lucky
I like your thinking, but I don't think Rodrik gets revived by Thoros.
[Spoiler]
In the book, it's noted that when Lady Stoneheart is revived, Beric Dondarrion dies. This leads me to believe that if Rodrik was revived it would kill Beric leaving him unable to bring back LS, making the theory impossible.
I thought the same thing, what an annoying little dick face.
How do we know about his face scar and broken arm?
Lady Stoneheart won't be in the TV series, unfortunately, even though the viewers could've used the satisfaction of a Frey being hanged on screen.
Wait, Rodrik survives? Dammit! you had one job Gared,One job! :P lol, I hope that happens, it would be hysterical when they reunited considering Gared told Lord Forrester that he had died leaving Rodrik squished and abandoned under a horse in the middle of the Red Wedding >_<
Nah, its not confirmed yet but there a lot of things sort nodding toward that Telltale will bring him back. This is just a likely theory to explain how he could have survived.
Henry VIII survived a horse falling on him during a tournament, though a leg that was injured in the fall never fully recovered.
Rodrik surviving the forse falling him isn't entirely far-fetched.
Right but Henry VIII was probably taken care of immediately after he fell. Rodrik would have fallen in the middle of a bloody battle where all his comrades are being slain around him.
HE BECAME AN UNICORN !!!!!
That's the best theory I can see.
It's not confirmed yet, she'll be.
We need to wait for Brienne's arc to reach her first, which when we first see her. (not considering the first time when that WHO Frey is hang)
http://theweek.com/speedreads/index/263756/speedreads-no-lady-stoneheart-wont-be-appearing-in-game-of-thrones
No she won't. There are plenty of articles confirming she won't be.
I'd like to think it's somehow related to Bowen. Like Bowen and Norren found Rodrik alive and managed to get him to safety. So if you chose to save Bowen as your first major choice, then Rodrik is still alive. If you didn't, he's dead.
Hmm...Rodrik returning. I don't know. It could possibly happen. But at the same time, I don't know.
It can happen. For Rodrik to come back i mean. He'll probably appear as a prisoner of the Freys, or something else.
I mean, a horse, being as heavy as you like, can't kill a man outright. Also, he fell on his lower torso only, where no vital (but equally important) organs are situated. But he most probably broke both is legs in the process. If rescued fast enough, he could've survived. Maybe Norren saved him?
Rodrik being dead or alive might also be incidental on wheter you saved Norren's squire ot not. I don't think Norren can lift a horse on his own, but maybe with his squire helping him...