Spoilers - Questions about Lily
I finally finished the first season of The Wolf Among Us last night, and had a great time with the whole season. When I started replaying the major moments in my head though, one thing stuck out that I couldn't explain.
So...spoilers follow...if anybody can shed some light here, it would really help me.
From the finale, we learn that Georgie Porgie was responsible for killing "Faith" and Lily. What bothers me, from putting the pieces together is...how was Lily killed?
We know that Georgie did the actual deed...but it seems fairly plain that she met Crane in room 207. If the meeting was a setup, and Georgie was actually in the room, why would she go through the role-play, and biting the apple?
If she was killed AFTER Crane finished and left....did Georgie just arrive in room 207? If so, why was Lily on the bed? Wouldn't there have been some kind of struggle while Georgie pulled off her ribbon? I wouldn't expect her to be laying (and then dragged off of) the bed, unless the apple actually DID put her to sleep - but Bigby claims that he'd smell any poison or drugs.
I'm probably not supposed to be reading this much into it, but I can't help but feel that I've missed something somewhere.
Comments
Lily is still a bit of a mystery unfortunately, hopefully TellTale will shed some light on her in Season 2 (When it fucking comes that is!!)
Gerogie probably said to go up there because Crane called, which is where there is a note to "faith" saying thanks for covering for me from Lily. She was suppose to be asleep when Crane enters the room for him to kiss her, so she glamoured up, bit the apple, and pretended to sleep. Then Georgie came in, probably didnt say anything, and Lily assumed it was Crane, then he just took her ribbon off
Yes, there is no clarity with the Lily situation. I don't think you should go by the picture. The dress was torn and there was no blood on the dress or the Snow outfit she was wearing. It's a complete mystery. One thing I do question is Bigby entering the dressing room and finding those clues on the floor. The note seemed a Lil' too convenient a clue. And I don't know or remember if that note was vague enough to override the ribbon spell.