Choices are finally up [SPOILERS]

edited March 2014 in The Walking Dead

Alt text

Comments

  • Awesome! I did all of those except the Kenny-Pro ones. I sat with Luke and gave myself up. Carlos saved my life and I ought repay him.

  • Weird that the status of Alvin and Carlos isn't included.

  • Carlos can die?

    Tyranniac posted: »

    Weird that the status of Alvin and Carlos isn't included.

  • he cant but nick can die

    Shane.Z posted: »

    Carlos can die?

  • Actually yes, Carlos can die.

    vivec posted: »

    he cant but nick can die

  • 1) I told Carlos that it was Sarah's idea to take the photo. It was, she should own up for it. I was told to entertain her. I didn't pick up the camera and I'm not going to say 'no' to a mentally unstable 15-year old.

    2) Kenny. I thought he was dead and wanted to spend time with him to make sure I wasn't seeing things. Anyone's got a problem with that, they can deal with it.

    3)I abstained because it wasn't my call. I tried to lead him on about it so that he wouldn't go off the deep end but he wouldn't listen and I knew that Nick was coming up behind me to tell him the whole story.

    4) Saved Nick's ass because he's a good kid and I knew the teacher to be a rational person. Also I promised his uncle I'd look after him so I owed him that much. If we're looking at another Ben situation though I dunno how I'll deal.

    5) Why is this number so small?! Leaving to find Luke and Kenny means getting a plan and a gun. I ensured Alvin's safety and tried to save Walter too but I think that's impossible :(

  • Are we talking in game or in a "man is mortal" kind of way? Can I have some specifics here because this is interesting news to me.

    Twistee posted: »

    Actually yes, Carlos can die.

  • he can actually have his throat slit by carver so were talking in game

    Shane.Z posted: »

    Are we talking in game or in a "man is mortal" kind of way? Can I have some specifics here because this is interesting news to me.

  • To be fair for the Sarah one even if you say it was your ideas Sarah admits it was her idea so she did own up to it

    Shane.Z posted: »

    1) I told Carlos that it was Sarah's idea to take the photo. It was, she should own up for it. I was told to entertain her. I didn't pick

  • JohnBuroJohnBuro Banned
    edited March 2014

    I believe you can save Walter if you stop Kenny from shooting the very first person

    Shane.Z posted: »

    1) I told Carlos that it was Sarah's idea to take the photo. It was, she should own up for it. I was told to entertain her. I didn't pick

  • Two questions, What happens if you sit with Luke ? And how does Carlos die ? Haven't seen that anywhere

  • I believe Walter, Nick, Carlos, and Alvin are all determinant by what you say and do.

    Green613 posted: »

    he can actually have his throat slit by carver so were talking in game

  • edited March 2014

    Huh, my choices actually mirror the image, just with slightly different numbers. Maybe more data was collected between when I took my screenshot and when that was was taken?

    http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=234865158

  • Can't stop him.

    JohnBuro posted: »

    I believe you can save Walter if you stop Kenny from shooting the very first person

  • Will I never get my choices statistics? It's just blank.

  • im pretty sure walter dies no matter what

    JohnBuro posted: »

    I believe Walter, Nick, Carlos, and Alvin are all determinant by what you say and do.

  • If you try to find Luke or Kenny. Carlos will die.

    Shane.Z posted: »

    1) I told Carlos that it was Sarah's idea to take the photo. It was, she should own up for it. I was told to entertain her. I didn't pick

  • I did and Carlos still lived, just had been beaten by Carver. Unless you take too long in which case I did not or some other factor which determines whether Carlos lives or not.

    If you try to find Luke or Kenny. Carlos will die.

  • For number 5:
    I was afraid that option would lead to Carlos' death.

    Shane.Z posted: »

    1) I told Carlos that it was Sarah's idea to take the photo. It was, she should own up for it. I was told to entertain her. I didn't pick

  • Yeah I just tried that to be sure and Carver is just breaking his fingers like they're crab legs. I wonder if the kitchen knife plays a part in the determinant though. Is there any way for Carver to get his hands on it or...something? I made him put it in the drawer in the cabin.

    Art2Heart posted: »

    I did and Carlos still lived, just had been beaten by Carver. Unless you take too long in which case I did not or some other factor which determines whether Carlos lives or not.

  • I've literally tried everything that could save Walter. Guy dies. The end. Just like Chuck.

    Green613 posted: »

    im pretty sure walter dies no matter what

  • edited March 2014

    -Did not take the blame for Sarah's photo

    -Sat with Luke and co. for dinner

    -Did not tell the truth about Matthew

    -Convinced Walter to forgive Nick

    -Surrended, did not go for Kenny and Luke

  • I did exactly the same as you. And I feel kinda stupid that the dinner choice was the one that took me 5 minutes to decide...

  • If you hadn't already figured it out, restart your game. It should fix it.

    Art2Heart posted: »

    Will I never get my choices statistics? It's just blank.

  • 1) Stayed silent, and the game counted it as not taking the blame. Understandable, I suppose. I wasn't going to cover for Sarah after she shoved a GUN in my face. Bullets or no, I bet Clem's life flashed before her eyes.

    2) I sat with Kenny. I didn't even have to think about it, I just saw him and knew what I had to do. He seemed so happy.

    3) I told Walter the truth. As soon as I showed Nick the photo and he wanted to come clean, I thought it was the right call. Walter was a good guy (who deserved far better than he got, I might add) and deserved to know.

    4) I convinced Walter to forgive Nick. Nick isn't a bad person in the slightest. He's had a rough time in the apocalypse, and Pete had JUST died. It was a tragic misunderstanding that Nick wanted to own up to and make right, so I told Walter he was a good man.

    5) I went to go find Kenny and Luke. Carlos never told him where Rebecca was, so I wouldn't either. He didn't want them to be caught, and finding Luke and Ken was the only way to possibly rescue everyone. I managed to get Ken to surrender before Alvin died, so the situation turned out about as well as it possibly could.

  • 1) Didn't take the blame for Sarah's photo because I didn't touch the camera.

    2) Of course I had to sit with my boy K-Dog! Didn't want Luke to get all butt hurt but he should of understood that I had been through alot with Kenny and wanted to shoot the shit with him.

    3) Told Walter the truth about what happened to Matthew. He seemed like a pretty cool guy and deserved to know, plus I didn't want it to come back and bite Clem in the ass if he found out she lied.

    4) Convinced Walter to forgive Nick. Nick really pissed me off when he shot Matthew but in a way I could kind of understand why he did it. He isn't some blood thirsty guy that is just out to kill people for no reason, he just made a really stupid mistake.

    5) Went off to find Kenny and Luke. I was thinking I could find them both and that they could somehow rescue the group but I only found Kenny and I totally regret telling him to take the 2nd shot at Carver because it got my boy Alvin killed.

  • edited March 2014

    -I took the blame for Sarah's photo. It didn't feel right to let Carlos yell at his own daughter. And I did take the picture.

    -Sat with Kenny for dinner. This was really a tough decision, but after thinking for... a while, I picked him. After not seeing the guy for over 2 years, I felt like I just wanted to be able to spend more time with him. (He may have grown a beard, but his stubbornness hasn't changed a bit.)

    -I showed Nick Matthew's photo and told Walter the truth about Matthew. Like I had mentioned to Luke beforehand, it's the right thing to do. I thought lying would've just made things worse.

    -Convinced Walter to forgive Nick. I told him that Nick is a good guy (despite going off once in a while) and I'm glad that he saved him and didn't just stand there to just let him die.

    -I went to go find Kenny and Luke. I was hoping that we could maybe save the others from being hostages, but that went to shit. I was able to keep Alvin from being killed though.

  • 1) I said "You told me to distract her" because...well...he DID. It's not my fault that Sarah had the camera. How in the world was I supposed to know that Carver would show up and find that picture? He didn't want me to tell her the truth so the best thing I could do was play along with her and hope that it would keep her happy. I was a little irritated with how the question was framed in the end but, well, I don't think I should've taken the blame in that situation. Particularly since I was being kept in the dark on the whole Carver thing.

    2) I sat with Kenny. I feel a little bad about it since it ended up with me being against Luke quite a bit in this episode (I argued with him the whole time about the Matthew thing) and I actually like Luke...but I know Kenny better than Luke and it'd been over a year since I last saw him!

    3) I told Walter the truth. I was scared to death about it, but I decided to trust that his previous talk about wanting me to be a peace keeper was an honest sign that he was a good man.

    4) And then I convinced him to forgive Nick. I was terrified he was going to kill him, which I didn't want, since although I thought Nick was REALLY STUPID when he shot Matthew I knew it wasn't something he did out of cold blood, just an accident. I was so relieved when he not only threw the knife away, but later saved Nick's life during the zombie attack. You were a good man, just like I hoped you were, Walter. I'm so sorry you ended up dead anyway. :( RIP.

    5) I chose to surrender. I was just about to decide to go find Luke and Kenny when Carver put a blade to Carlos' neck and I knew I couldn't do it. I honestly don't like Carlos much, but he doesn't deserve to die and I didn't want Sarah to have to see her father killed in front of her. To my relief, Walter was the only one that died (although I bum rushed Carver to try to keep him from killing Alvin. I don't know if that changes anything or not.)

  • You just talk to Luke and then Kenny will come sit with you instead. And I don't think Carlos dies though but I do think his right ear got cut off because Carver had a knife next to it and he was screaming in pain if you ran out and looked for Luke and Kenny.

    Two questions, What happens if you sit with Luke ? And how does Carlos die ? Haven't seen that anywhere

  • edited March 2014
    1. I took the blame for the photo. I did take the picture, after all. The only reason my Clem would lie is if it is to save others or her life is at risk.
    2. Sat with Luke, as Kenny was acting off and I like Luke as a character
    3. Told Walter the truth. He was a great character, and while I feared that could make the situation worse, I could see him appreciating honesty.
    4. Convinced Walter to forgive Nick. I think Nick was an idiot for doing what he did, but I understand how it was a mistake on his part. He was genuinely guilt ridden, and I like to think of Clem's role in the game as the character who keep everyone from turning into monsters.
    5. I surrendered. A very hard choice, and I may give that part a replay just to see what would have happened for myself. However, I think i will stick to my choice. My Clem would not risk the life of Carlos on a chance like that.
  • You and I are polar opposites, man.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.