No Way. At his worst Kenny is a pain in the ass, at his best he is a good friend, he gets hugs. Lilly on the other hand, at her best is just a pain in the ass and at her worst is a murdering psychopathic bitch. She gets no Clem hugs.
Well I would hug her but I doubt that could be an option after she killed YouKnowWho(Not Voldemort). I think it could possible be an option since she was from the original group at the pharmacy and she was just happy to see a familiar face again. Honestly I am a Lilly fan and I feel bad for her. Life in the zombie apocalypse for Lilly is not as easy. She is so stressed because she has so many problems to take care of.
A. Her dad needs pills from the pharmacy. If they don't get them he could have a heart attack and die.
B. Fights with Kenny can be exhausting. How do you lead a group when one member wants it differently?
C.Paranoia. Your supply stocks are being stolen by one of the group members.
D.New People. Ben and Mr Parker/Travis come to the motor inn. Its more mouths to feed. But this was the only thing I disagreed with Lilly because we couldn't just leave them in the woods...
E. Starvation and lack of food. Hard to function when you can't eat.
F. A salt lick was dropped on her dad's head killing him in the process.
G. Bandit attacks. All the arrow shafts in the wall probably meant they went through a lot of shit.
H. Leaving the motor inn because someone was giving bandits supplies.
My Clem would hug her. She killed Carley, but it was Ben who caused her death. Carley believed him and he lied her and the whole group. How can you forgive Ben, but still hate Lilly? At first I didn't like her either, but some playthroughs later I started to think that she almost always was reasonable, tried to defend her group. I was shocked she killed Carley, but I couldn't leave her. I understood her motivation, and hell, she was right about Ben. So I forgave her, but it doesn't mean that I forget her killing Carley, she made horrible mistake, but I definitly don't hate her and want her back sometime.
My Clem would hug her. She killed Carley, but it was Ben who caused her death. Carley believed him and he lied her and the whole group. How … morecan you forgive Ben, but still hate Lilly? At first I didn't like her either, but some playthroughs later I started to think that she almost always was reasonable, tried to defend her group. I was shocked she killed Carley, but I couldn't leave her. I understood her motivation, and hell, she was right about Ben. So I forgave her, but it doesn't mean that I forget her killing Carley, she made horrible mistake, but I definitly don't hate her and want her back sometime.
**A. Her dad needs pills from the pharmacy. If they don't get them he could have a heart attack and die.
B. Fights with Kenny can be exhausting. How do you lead a group when one member wants it differently?
C.Paranoia. Your supply stocks are being stolen by one of the group members.
D.New People. Ben and Mr Parker/Travis come to the motor inn. Its more mouths to feed. But this was the only thing I disagreed with Lilly because we couldn't just leave them in the woods...
E. Starvation and lack of food. Hard to function when you can't eat.
F. A salt lick was dropped on her dad's head killing him in the process.
G. Bandit attacks. All the arrow shafts in the wall probably meant they went through a lot of shit.
H. Leaving the motor inn because someone was giving bandits supplies**
cracks knuckles
A, Her dad was a complete selfish prick and wanted to throw a little boy out onto the street, for the slim chance that under the dry blood on him was a bite.
B. She wasn't elected, no one actually directly said they wanted her too lead, she just assumed that role. And when we (Lee) took over, Carley for one thought he was a better leader.
C. No reason at-all for her actions
D. She was a complete dick about that, what did she expect them to do leave Ben, Travis and Mr Parker to die in the woods. Although admittedly if we had done, we might all have lived because Ben wouldn't have constantly fucked up for us.... but....... still would have been immoral
E AND EVERYONE ELSE WAS STUFFED WITH FOOD! - oh wait no they weren't - ever one else was hungry too but they didn't act like complete and utter mother-fooks.
F It needed to be done, her dad was dead as a dodo. EVEN IF she had managed to CPR him back into life, there was no hospital, no medicine to help him, his death was always going to happen sooner or later. Kenny/Lee done her a favour, if they didn't kill him not only would she have had to see her dead as a stinking corpse but a stinking corpse that would have killed her and a little girl.
G AND EVERY ONE ELSE DIDN'T EXPERIENCE THAT? again everyone else went through shit, that doesn't excuse her.
H OH COME ON, i will say this one last time - did that not happen to everyone else?
Lilly had no excuses, she was a heartless, selfish bitch who cared about no-one but herself. She bossed everyone else around and only Kenny had the nuts to put her in her place. If it was Kenny or Lee who had the heart attack in that meat locker Larry or Her would not have hesitated for a second to Salt lick their ass. And more importantly she killed my only chance to get laid/have happiness in the apocalypse. I hope that bitch rots in hell.
Well I would hug her but I doubt that could be an option after she killed YouKnowWho(Not Voldemort). I think it could possible be an option… more since she was from the original group at the pharmacy and she was just happy to see a familiar face again. Honestly I am a Lilly fan and I feel bad for her. Life in the zombie apocalypse for Lilly is not as easy. She is so stressed because she has so many problems to take care of.
A. Her dad needs pills from the pharmacy. If they don't get them he could have a heart attack and die.
B. Fights with Kenny can be exhausting. How do you lead a group when one member wants it differently?
C.Paranoia. Your supply stocks are being stolen by one of the group members.
D.New People. Ben and Mr Parker/Travis come to the motor inn. Its more mouths to feed. But this was the only thing I disagreed with Lilly because we couldn't just leave them in the woods...
E. Starvation and lack of food. Hard to functi… [view original content]
Damn fine points right there. So that's how its going to be? cracks knuckles
A. I will explain in a quote "My dad can be an ass sometimes I know that. But hes not a bad guy. Hes just... Hes got a lot of pain. Hes been through so much. And lost... pretty much everything. And its hardened him you know? Yeah hes bitter and hateful but thats all to protect himself, and me. All hes got left in the world is me. And that goes both ways so yeah hes probably going to keep treating you like crap but that's just because he has one thing left to care about. So don't judge him and don't judge me by sticking by him. Hes my dad and I love him" --Lilly Seriously bro. Just... Just Back off on Larry.
B. No one elected Kenny either. No one cares that shes in charge except Kenny. Nobody else wants to lead. Nobody has stepped up to be leader except Kenny. Kenny wants it to be a democracy but Lilly had the role first. If you don't like her leadership then leave. Oh wait... no one left. Carley gets angry because its always a power struggle. Doug just watches. Larry defends his daughter. Katjaa and Duck do nothing. Ben does nothing. Mark walks away. Lee chooses.
C.Obviously if you are losing supplies you'll act angry, and pissed.
D.Yeah it would be wrong to leave them in the woods. Her point is valid though. When the group is starving you bring more people, more people to feed. People will be even more hungry and survival will be harder.
E.Maybe some people react to situations differently. Maybe Lilly couldn't handle starving and does crazy shit when starving. Look at the bandits in the woods killing for food, and the St Johns eating people. People do crazy shit when they're hungry...
F. I have said this before. I would rather let Larry eat everyone in the meat locker then let Clementine witness that shit. What do you think that does to a kid? Who wants their 8 year old daughter to watch a salt lick fall on a mans head killing him. I agree it had to be done but only if it was necessary. I find that there is no point of living if your not human.
G.Yes but she is the leader. You are in charge of keeping everyone safe. If one of them dies it most likely will be blamed on you.
H. Yes but Lilly loved the motor inn the most. She had plans to stay there for the winter. Her dream of survival is as crazy as Kenny's boat. She wanted to stay there but it didn't work out and she was pissed because someone in the group ruined it.
Heartless? That was just cruel. Selfish?
Okay so when you get the keys to the pharmacy "God your amazing thank you" Lilly grateful to Lee
"You can't blame yourself your only one man" Lilly consoling Lee
"GOD MARK! ARE YOU OKAY?" Lilly asking about Mark
In Jolene's video she bends down to talk to Clementine
"I don't give a shit about what happens to you. But if anything happens to my daughter or that little girl you got with you heh you watch your ass" Larry to Lee
And obviously she would salt lick Kenny because she hates the man but Lee I think she would try to save him. Larry might have tried to killed him but that would only be because Lee is a killer.
**A. Her dad needs pills from the pharmacy. If they don't get them he could have a heart attack and die.
B. Fights with Kenny can be exha… moreusting. How do you lead a group when one member wants it differently?
C.Paranoia. Your supply stocks are being stolen by one of the group members.
D.New People. Ben and Mr Parker/Travis come to the motor inn. Its more mouths to feed. But this was the only thing I disagreed with Lilly because we couldn't just leave them in the woods...
E. Starvation and lack of food. Hard to function when you can't eat.
F. A salt lick was dropped on her dad's head killing him in the process.
G. Bandit attacks. All the arrow shafts in the wall probably meant they went through a lot of shit.
H. Leaving the motor inn because someone was giving bandits supplies**
cracks knuckles
A, Her dad was a complete selfish prick and wanted to throw a little boy out onto the street, for the slim chance that under t… [view original content]
A still don't buy that excuse personally but moving one
B Exactly Kenny wanted a democracy, no one else stood up because they didn't want the hassle/have the balls to tell Lilly. A democracy was (argue ably) the right thing for the group.
C Still Lilly took angry and pissed to a whole new world
D Meh
E Still not an excuse, do you think Duck or Clem could handle being or hungry? Or that Kenny/Lee could handle the emotional pain of seeing the kids that way. I bet Kenny and Lee were going crazy inside but they kept their shit together.Not to mention wasn't Lilly in the army or something like that, you would think she'd be able to handle pressure (i think she said she was only a engineer but still - it's a high pressure job)
F WHAT you would rather a little girl get eaten then turn around and cover her ears whilst We deal with a threat........Moving swiftly on from that
G Not really, no one really expected Lilly to keep everyone safe/lead them. She just kinda took that in her stride and it was there-fore her fault if she couldn't handle the weight of the world/people blaming her for stuff.
H Again that was her selfishness. I don't think many other people in the group were very keen on staying, it was coming up for a winter and the motel wasn't exactly a sauna. Kenny's boat was a much better plan. It was not her decision if everyone stayed it should have been voted on. Ben just sped up the inevitable.
Meh, she may have showed the odd bit of moral but on the whole she was thoroughly selfish.
Damn fine points right there. So that's how its going to be? cracks knuckles
A. I will explain in a quote "My dad can be an ass sometimes… more I know that. But hes not a bad guy. Hes just... Hes got a lot of pain. Hes been through so much. And lost... pretty much everything. And its hardened him you know? Yeah hes bitter and hateful but thats all to protect himself, and me. All hes got left in the world is me. And that goes both ways so yeah hes probably going to keep treating you like crap but that's just because he has one thing left to care about. So don't judge him and don't judge me by sticking by him. Hes my dad and I love him" --Lilly Seriously bro. Just... Just Back off on Larry.
B. No one elected Kenny either. No one cares that shes in charge except Kenny. Nobody else wants to lead. Nobody has stepped up to be leader except Kenny. Kenny wants it to be a democracy but Lilly had the role first. If you don't like her leadership the… [view original content]
She shot Carley so no. No hugs. Will not forgive her for shooting an innocent woman who was part of our group!
Difference between Lily shooting Carley and Nick shooting Matthew is that Nick thought his group where in trouble and was therefore helping. Lily however, knew Carley. She was part of our group and Lily had no proof it was Carley stealing supplies (because she wasn't and I don't think it should be a shoot-able offence.) and she wasn't at risk of putting the group in danger either!
She shot Carley so no. No hugs. Will not forgive her for shooting an innocent woman who was part of our group!
Difference between Lily sh… moreooting Carley and Nick shooting Matthew is that Nick thought his group where in trouble and was therefore helping. Lily however, knew Carley. She was part of our group and Lily had no proof it was Carley stealing supplies (because she wasn't and I don't think it should be a shoot-able offence.) and she wasn't at risk of putting the group in danger either!
Who's to say she won't do it again?
If there were a negative option, I would have chosen that. If not, then just silence. Then after that, I would have chosen all the negative, or at least neutral options. And I would have told the group that she is not to be trusted.
I never liked Lilly, ever, even in playthroughs where I went through and made opposite choices, she's simply an unpleasant, negative person. Sure, she's a familiar face, but not one I particularly want to see. She's a murderer, I know that you can make arguments about her "snapping", but she stilled killed a close friend. It's completely unforgivable, in my eyes at least.
So yeah, I wouldn't be thrilled to see her, and I'd make sure that the group knew what she did, and that I didn't trust her.
She still killed someone, and she was actively trying to kill a member of the group. The fact that she killed Doug doesn't really matter, it only happened because she was trying to kill Ben.
Ahh watch the fan boys post their hate..
I'm almost glad Lilly didn't come back and Kenny did - it means he's probably going to die and I'll be the one laughing
Clem liked Ben alot remember? And untill the point where Lilly decided to cold hearted murder Ben out of pain and sorrow (and crazyness), we didn't even have proof that he was the one giving the bandits supplies!
It really made me mad when she killed Carley in S1, since Carley was my favorite then, so I'd be conflicted, but probably not... I'd just acknowledge her in a somewhat warm way, since I did side with Lilly over Kenny throughout the game.
" Depends on your Clem. "
Clem liked Ben alot remember? And untill the point where Lilly decided to cold hearted murder Ben out of pain and sorrow (and crazyness), we didn't even have proof that he was the one giving the bandits supplies!
Sure, but I guess in that situation it wouldn't really have any bearing on whether clem would hug her or not, considering Clem can hug Kenny who also wanted to kill ben
She still killed someone, and she was actively trying to kill a member of the group. The fact that she killed Doug doesn't really matter, it only happened because she was trying to kill Ben.
Oh, he was indeed, however Lilly believed that by stealing supplies Ben was essentially killing all of them.
Especially judging by the fact that Clem and Lilly seem to have had an okay kind of relationship (she's nice to her, and gives her hair 'thingies' to tie her hair back while she sleeps, which clem holds on to), I think Clem would still hug her.
Just my opinion. Besides, there would still be a choice! There would be no harm in providing the option
B. Yes but if no one took his side then there was no point in a democracy because no one chose his idea or stood by it which is the whole idea of democracy. If they don't have the balls than that's their fault not Lilly's fault
C. Well this is the zombie apocalypse. It is a new world and it changes people. In E1 Lilly was nice. E2 shes really stressed out. E3 she lost it since her dad died and people are stealing stuff.
D. "Meh"
E. As I said. People handle things differently. Everyone was made unique for good or for bad. This sadly was one of her bad's. Again she has changed so she could probably handle more pressure before than now.
F. Well.... She still knew what was going to happen. When she turned around she saw a dead man with a salt lick in his head. That was just horrible..
G. Its the responsibility of the leader. She took on the role but didn't see the consequences. It is her fault for making that mistake of taking all the pressure but it doesn't make her a bad person.
H. Kenny's boat was a better plan?... Look at what happened in Savannah and tell me it was a better plan. Lee even says something like this "I would do anything to go back fighting over the motor inn"
Mostly she cared about Larry her father. But later on she learns to trust Lee and obviously Clementine. Kenny was like her arch nemesis and he brought out the worst in her. She still cared about them though. Lee killed the Senator in anger, and Lilly killed Carley in anger. I forgive her and I honestly hope everyone else does to.
A still don't buy that excuse personally but moving one
B Exactly Kenny wanted a democracy, no one else stood up because they didn't want t… morehe hassle/have the balls to tell Lilly. A democracy was (argue ably) the right thing for the group.
C Still Lilly took angry and pissed to a whole new world
D Meh
E Still not an excuse, do you think Duck or Clem could handle being or hungry? Or that Kenny/Lee could handle the emotional pain of seeing the kids that way. I bet Kenny and Lee were going crazy inside but they kept their shit together.Not to mention wasn't Lilly in the army or something like that, you would think she'd be able to handle pressure (i think she said she was only a engineer but still - it's a high pressure job)
F WHAT you would rather a little girl get eaten then turn around and cover her ears whilst We deal with a threat........Moving swiftly on from that
G Not really, no one really expected Lilly to keep everyone safe/lead… [view original content]
" Oh, he was indeed, however Lilly believed that by stealing supplies Ben was essentially killing all of them. "
Lilly " believed " that Ben was stealing supplies, Kenny knew that Ben stole the supplies and was responsible for his familys death. That's a huge difference. Lilly pointed a gun at Ben's head and tryed to shot him without any evidence that Ben stole the supplies, Kenny just tryed to beat the shit out of this fucking shitbird! If he would have wanted to shot him, he could have done so. Ofcouse Kenny was happy if you decided to " let Ben (aka that fucking shitbird) go ". But in fact, Kenny tryed to save Ben's life in the alleyway and forgave him, even after all the terrible things he had done!
" Especially judging by the fact that Clem and Lilly seem to have had an okay kind of relationship (she's nice to her, and gives her hair 'thingies' to tie her hair back while she sleeps, which clem holds on to), I think Clem would still hug her. "
Ofcourse Clem liked her, untill her cold hearted murdering Carley/Doug Clem had no reason not to like her. That doesn'´t necessarily mean that she still likes her.
Oh, he was indeed, however Lilly believed that by stealing supplies Ben was essentially killing all of them.
Especially judging by the fa… morect that Clem and Lilly seem to have had an okay kind of relationship (she's nice to her, and gives her hair 'thingies' to tie her hair back while she sleeps, which clem holds on to), I think Clem would still hug her.
Just my opinion. Besides, there would still be a choice! There would be no harm in providing the option
Comments
LIlly would get the claw end of Clem's hammer !
You really think I'd welcome her back with open arms after what she did to Carley?
She'd have to do a hell of a lot to convince me that she was really sorry for what she did.
rtu2d2 does not approve of Lilly hate.
Hell no! Wouldn't hug her in a lifetime. She shoot Doug, I liked him. (Yes, I saved Doug, not Carley)
I also think that HUG LILLY wouldnt be first choice you would get as it was with Kenny.
It would probably say KICK LILLY, at the very least.
She killed Carley or Doug right in front of Clem.
(?) GD3232 Noticed your negativity towards Lilly
No Way. At his worst Kenny is a pain in the ass, at his best he is a good friend, he gets hugs. Lilly on the other hand, at her best is just a pain in the ass and at her worst is a murdering psychopathic bitch. She gets no Clem hugs.
Well I would hug her but I doubt that could be an option after she killed YouKnowWho(Not Voldemort). I think it could possible be an option since she was from the original group at the pharmacy and she was just happy to see a familiar face again. Honestly I am a Lilly fan and I feel bad for her. Life in the zombie apocalypse for Lilly is not as easy. She is so stressed because she has so many problems to take care of.
A. Her dad needs pills from the pharmacy. If they don't get them he could have a heart attack and die.
B. Fights with Kenny can be exhausting. How do you lead a group when one member wants it differently?
C.Paranoia. Your supply stocks are being stolen by one of the group members.
D.New People. Ben and Mr Parker/Travis come to the motor inn. Its more mouths to feed. But this was the only thing I disagreed with Lilly because we couldn't just leave them in the woods...
E. Starvation and lack of food. Hard to function when you can't eat.
F. A salt lick was dropped on her dad's head killing him in the process.
G. Bandit attacks. All the arrow shafts in the wall probably meant they went through a lot of shit.
H. Leaving the motor inn because someone was giving bandits supplies.
Come at me down votes...
I think if she it was Lilly Clem would grab Nicks rifle and shot her in the head. No offence.
Nick would probably beat you at it haha
Ahh watch the fan boys post their hate..
I'm almost glad Lilly didn't come back and Kenny did - it means he's probably going to die and I'll be the one laughing
My Clem would hug her. She killed Carley, but it was Ben who caused her death. Carley believed him and he lied her and the whole group. How can you forgive Ben, but still hate Lilly? At first I didn't like her either, but some playthroughs later I started to think that she almost always was reasonable, tried to defend her group. I was shocked she killed Carley, but I couldn't leave her. I understood her motivation, and hell, she was right about Ben. So I forgave her, but it doesn't mean that I forget her killing Carley, she made horrible mistake, but I definitly don't hate her and want her back sometime.
I didn't forgive Ben either, he stayed in Crawford.
Sorry, Carley and Clem are tied next to Daryl.
XD lol
I wouldn't have taken Nicks gun to kill her, i'd have taken my hands and strangled that bitch to death.....damn i hate Lilly.
I would rather choose an option to say 'Oh, it's you.' then tell Nick to shoot her.
**A. Her dad needs pills from the pharmacy. If they don't get them he could have a heart attack and die.
B. Fights with Kenny can be exhausting. How do you lead a group when one member wants it differently?
C.Paranoia. Your supply stocks are being stolen by one of the group members.
D.New People. Ben and Mr Parker/Travis come to the motor inn. Its more mouths to feed. But this was the only thing I disagreed with Lilly because we couldn't just leave them in the woods...
E. Starvation and lack of food. Hard to function when you can't eat.
F. A salt lick was dropped on her dad's head killing him in the process.
G. Bandit attacks. All the arrow shafts in the wall probably meant they went through a lot of shit.
H. Leaving the motor inn because someone was giving bandits supplies**
cracks knuckles
A, Her dad was a complete selfish prick and wanted to throw a little boy out onto the street, for the slim chance that under the dry blood on him was a bite.
B. She wasn't elected, no one actually directly said they wanted her too lead, she just assumed that role. And when we (Lee) took over, Carley for one thought he was a better leader.
C. No reason at-all for her actions
D. She was a complete dick about that, what did she expect them to do leave Ben, Travis and Mr Parker to die in the woods. Although admittedly if we had done, we might all have lived because Ben wouldn't have constantly fucked up for us.... but....... still would have been immoral
E AND EVERYONE ELSE WAS STUFFED WITH FOOD! - oh wait no they weren't - ever one else was hungry too but they didn't act like complete and utter mother-fooks.
F It needed to be done, her dad was dead as a dodo. EVEN IF she had managed to CPR him back into life, there was no hospital, no medicine to help him, his death was always going to happen sooner or later. Kenny/Lee done her a favour, if they didn't kill him not only would she have had to see her dead as a stinking corpse but a stinking corpse that would have killed her and a little girl.
G AND EVERY ONE ELSE DIDN'T EXPERIENCE THAT? again everyone else went through shit, that doesn't excuse her.
H OH COME ON, i will say this one last time - did that not happen to everyone else?
Lilly had no excuses, she was a heartless, selfish bitch who cared about no-one but herself. She bossed everyone else around and only Kenny had the nuts to put her in her place. If it was Kenny or Lee who had the heart attack in that meat locker Larry or Her would not have hesitated for a second to Salt lick their ass. And more importantly she killed my only chance to get laid/have happiness in the apocalypse. I hope that bitch rots in hell.
Look what the cat dragged in XD
Next to Daryl? Alright, now you're just yanking my chain...
Damn fine points right there. So that's how its going to be? cracks knuckles
A. I will explain in a quote "My dad can be an ass sometimes I know that. But hes not a bad guy. Hes just... Hes got a lot of pain. Hes been through so much. And lost... pretty much everything. And its hardened him you know? Yeah hes bitter and hateful but thats all to protect himself, and me. All hes got left in the world is me. And that goes both ways so yeah hes probably going to keep treating you like crap but that's just because he has one thing left to care about. So don't judge him and don't judge me by sticking by him. Hes my dad and I love him" --Lilly Seriously bro. Just... Just Back off on Larry.
B. No one elected Kenny either. No one cares that shes in charge except Kenny. Nobody else wants to lead. Nobody has stepped up to be leader except Kenny. Kenny wants it to be a democracy but Lilly had the role first. If you don't like her leadership then leave. Oh wait... no one left. Carley gets angry because its always a power struggle. Doug just watches. Larry defends his daughter. Katjaa and Duck do nothing. Ben does nothing. Mark walks away. Lee chooses.
C.Obviously if you are losing supplies you'll act angry, and pissed.
D.Yeah it would be wrong to leave them in the woods. Her point is valid though. When the group is starving you bring more people, more people to feed. People will be even more hungry and survival will be harder.
E.Maybe some people react to situations differently. Maybe Lilly couldn't handle starving and does crazy shit when starving. Look at the bandits in the woods killing for food, and the St Johns eating people. People do crazy shit when they're hungry...
F. I have said this before. I would rather let Larry eat everyone in the meat locker then let Clementine witness that shit. What do you think that does to a kid? Who wants their 8 year old daughter to watch a salt lick fall on a mans head killing him. I agree it had to be done but only if it was necessary. I find that there is no point of living if your not human.
G.Yes but she is the leader. You are in charge of keeping everyone safe. If one of them dies it most likely will be blamed on you.
H. Yes but Lilly loved the motor inn the most. She had plans to stay there for the winter. Her dream of survival is as crazy as Kenny's boat. She wanted to stay there but it didn't work out and she was pissed because someone in the group ruined it.
Heartless? That was just cruel. Selfish?
Okay so when you get the keys to the pharmacy "God your amazing thank you" Lilly grateful to Lee
"You can't blame yourself your only one man" Lilly consoling Lee
"GOD MARK! ARE YOU OKAY?" Lilly asking about Mark
In Jolene's video she bends down to talk to Clementine
"I don't give a shit about what happens to you. But if anything happens to my daughter or that little girl you got with you heh you watch your ass" Larry to Lee
And obviously she would salt lick Kenny because she hates the man but Lee I think she would try to save him. Larry might have tried to killed him but that would only be because Lee is a killer.
A still don't buy that excuse personally but moving one
B Exactly Kenny wanted a democracy, no one else stood up because they didn't want the hassle/have the balls to tell Lilly. A democracy was (argue ably) the right thing for the group.
C Still Lilly took angry and pissed to a whole new world
D Meh
E Still not an excuse, do you think Duck or Clem could handle being or hungry? Or that Kenny/Lee could handle the emotional pain of seeing the kids that way. I bet Kenny and Lee were going crazy inside but they kept their shit together.Not to mention wasn't Lilly in the army or something like that, you would think she'd be able to handle pressure (i think she said she was only a engineer but still - it's a high pressure job)
F WHAT you would rather a little girl get eaten then turn around and cover her ears whilst We deal with a threat........Moving swiftly on from that
G Not really, no one really expected Lilly to keep everyone safe/lead them. She just kinda took that in her stride and it was there-fore her fault if she couldn't handle the weight of the world/people blaming her for stuff.
H Again that was her selfishness. I don't think many other people in the group were very keen on staying, it was coming up for a winter and the motel wasn't exactly a sauna. Kenny's boat was a much better plan. It was not her decision if everyone stayed it should have been voted on. Ben just sped up the inevitable.
Meh, she may have showed the odd bit of moral but on the whole she was thoroughly selfish.
She shot Carley so no. No hugs. Will not forgive her for shooting an innocent woman who was part of our group!
Difference between Lily shooting Carley and Nick shooting Matthew is that Nick thought his group where in trouble and was therefore helping. Lily however, knew Carley. She was part of our group and Lily had no proof it was Carley stealing supplies (because she wasn't and I don't think it should be a shoot-able offence.) and she wasn't at risk of putting the group in danger either!
Who's to say she won't do it again?
Depends on your Clem.
What about in the case where Lilly tries to shoot Ben, if you saved Doug?
If there were a negative option, I would have chosen that. If not, then just silence. Then after that, I would have chosen all the negative, or at least neutral options. And I would have told the group that she is not to be trusted.
I never liked Lilly, ever, even in playthroughs where I went through and made opposite choices, she's simply an unpleasant, negative person. Sure, she's a familiar face, but not one I particularly want to see. She's a murderer, I know that you can make arguments about her "snapping", but she stilled killed a close friend. It's completely unforgivable, in my eyes at least.
So yeah, I wouldn't be thrilled to see her, and I'd make sure that the group knew what she did, and that I didn't trust her.
She still killed someone, and she was actively trying to kill a member of the group. The fact that she killed Doug doesn't really matter, it only happened because she was trying to kill Ben.
And if he doesn't die because he's still the second most important character in the series, that means we get to laugh at you some more, right?
Also, how can you tell that they are "fan boys" simply because they dislike Lilly?
" Depends on your Clem. "
Clem liked Ben alot remember? And untill the point where Lilly decided to cold hearted murder Ben out of pain and sorrow (and crazyness), we didn't even have proof that he was the one giving the bandits supplies!
i think i would still bang her
It really made me mad when she killed Carley in S1, since Carley was my favorite then, so I'd be conflicted, but probably not... I'd just acknowledge her in a somewhat warm way, since I did side with Lilly over Kenny throughout the game.
Well, Kenny also wanted to kill Ben, and she can hug him so
Well Ben is responsible for killing Kenny's entire family so...
Sure, but I guess in that situation it wouldn't really have any bearing on whether clem would hug her or not, considering Clem can hug Kenny who also wanted to kill ben
Oh, he was indeed, however Lilly believed that by stealing supplies Ben was essentially killing all of them.
Especially judging by the fact that Clem and Lilly seem to have had an okay kind of relationship (she's nice to her, and gives her hair 'thingies' to tie her hair back while she sleeps, which clem holds on to), I think Clem would still hug her.
Just my opinion. Besides, there would still be a choice! There would be no harm in providing the option
A (skipping)
B. Yes but if no one took his side then there was no point in a democracy because no one chose his idea or stood by it which is the whole idea of democracy. If they don't have the balls than that's their fault not Lilly's fault
C. Well this is the zombie apocalypse. It is a new world and it changes people. In E1 Lilly was nice. E2 shes really stressed out. E3 she lost it since her dad died and people are stealing stuff.
D. "Meh"
E. As I said. People handle things differently. Everyone was made unique for good or for bad. This sadly was one of her bad's. Again she has changed so she could probably handle more pressure before than now.
F. Well.... She still knew what was going to happen. When she turned around she saw a dead man with a salt lick in his head. That was just horrible..
G. Its the responsibility of the leader. She took on the role but didn't see the consequences. It is her fault for making that mistake of taking all the pressure but it doesn't make her a bad person.
H. Kenny's boat was a better plan?... Look at what happened in Savannah and tell me it was a better plan. Lee even says something like this "I would do anything to go back fighting over the motor inn"
Mostly she cared about Larry her father. But later on she learns to trust Lee and obviously Clementine. Kenny was like her arch nemesis and he brought out the worst in her. She still cared about them though. Lee killed the Senator in anger, and Lilly killed Carley in anger. I forgive her and I honestly hope everyone else does to.
" Oh, he was indeed, however Lilly believed that by stealing supplies Ben was essentially killing all of them. "
Lilly " believed " that Ben was stealing supplies, Kenny knew that Ben stole the supplies and was responsible for his familys death. That's a huge difference. Lilly pointed a gun at Ben's head and tryed to shot him without any evidence that Ben stole the supplies, Kenny just tryed to beat the shit out of this fucking shitbird! If he would have wanted to shot him, he could have done so. Ofcouse Kenny was happy if you decided to " let Ben (aka that fucking shitbird) go ". But in fact, Kenny tryed to save Ben's life in the alleyway and forgave him, even after all the terrible things he had done!
" Especially judging by the fact that Clem and Lilly seem to have had an okay kind of relationship (she's nice to her, and gives her hair 'thingies' to tie her hair back while she sleeps, which clem holds on to), I think Clem would still hug her. "
Ofcourse Clem liked her, untill her cold hearted murdering Carley/Doug Clem had no reason not to like her. That doesn'´t necessarily mean that she still likes her.