Well no, it wasn't. Luke was already gone, and the rest of the group was captured and/or being tortured. That is definitely not the time to be talking.
And it was Kenny shooting that got a member of the group (or 2) killed. Shooting was not the correct course of action at that point. Having an extra gun would have gotten more people killed.
Wait, talking about Luke's whereabouts so we can have an additional capable member is not the right time? It was a better idea for Kenny to start shooting by himself rather than having an extra gun to back him up?
True, but I meant from Kenny's perspective. Obviously, Kenny was not up for the "live to fight another day" plan. Even though is was the best course of action. Also, asking where Luke was so we know that he didn't just bail on us would've been nice.
Well no, it wasn't. Luke was already gone, and the rest of the group was captured and/or being tortured. That is definitely not the time to … morebe talking.
And it was Kenny shooting that got a member of the group (or 2) killed. Shooting was not the correct course of action at that point. Having an extra gun would have gotten more people killed.
You are completely taking my words out of context. I never said the group should have shared there back story to Clem or anything like that. In a previous statement I've written that I acknowledge everyone in TWDU has a back story, and that's fine and dandy. All I wanted was to express to players they should maybe take Carver's words into consideration. There are two sides to the story, and as of right now for me personally I think I want to hear more of his side.
That's great that you have both the group and Carver figured out, but I don't and want more to go on before I can say I can trust this group.
Well, from what I can tell, the group aren't complete monsters. They seem like decent people. Everybody has a dark past. Even Lee. It took L… moreee 4 months to tell Clementine that he killed someone. You think the cabin group are just going to spill the beans to Clem in just one week?
You are completely taking my words out of context. I never said the group should have shared there back story to Clem or anything like that.… more In a previous statement I've written that I acknowledge everyone in TWDU has a back story, and that's fine and dandy. All I wanted was to express to players they should maybe take Carver's words into consideration. There are two sides to the story, and as of right now for me personally I think I want to hear more of his side.
That's great that you have both the group and Carver figured out, but I don't and want more to go on before I can say I can trust this group.
Luke seems like a good guy, but I don't get why some people seem ready for him to replace the void Lee left when he died. No one will ever fill that void. As of how the game is going right now, I think at best Luke and Clem will just be good friends.
I saw Lee as more of a father figure, while Luke is more of a big brother type. While Lee was definitely all about protecting Clem, Luke is more on an equal footing with Clem. They are both capable and work well together. It's a very different dynamic in their relationships. Hence the fun, yet slightly awkward interactions between the two.
Luke seems like a good guy, but I don't get why some people seem ready for him to replace the void Lee left when he died. No one will ever fill that void. As of how the game is going right now, I think at best Luke and Clem will just be good friends.
I like Luke but he is definitely hiding something. Like after Carver shows up and they have to leave the cabin, Clem asks "Why would he still be following you?" He just looks away and changes the subject. It's kind of annoying when he does that.
I like Luke but he is definitely hiding something. Like after Carver shows up and they have to leave the cabin, Clem asks "Why would he still be following you?" He just looks away and changes the subject. It's kind of annoying when he does that.
Actually what Carver said was Alvin killed George because he didn't like Carver. this doesn't make sense why do you kill the friend of the person you wanted to kill >_>, but there is a chance that happen when they were trying to escape.
Alt least, not attractive ones. The most generally considered attractive male ass is actually quite similar to the female one, except less triangle shaped and more rectangle shaped.
I do think it's interesting, could something bad happenend between Luke and Kenny, other than just a heated conversation? Honestly until now the thought didn't even cross my mind.
You assume he would even know. If the "take a hike" conversation happened before Carver arrived he'd assume Luke went back to the others. In… more which case Clem's question would just confirm for him that he ran off or got lost. And generally when you tell someone to take a hike you're not concerned where they go to begin with.
"Take a hike! But just tell me where you're going first!" Who does that?
I could see it. They've got more than enough topics to argue about; be it Clementine, Matthew (Kenny noticed his prolong absence), or Carver's group (Kenny mentions it at dinner if you sit with him). I don't see things escalating to murder though.
I do think it's interesting, could something bad happenend between Luke and Kenny, other than just a heated conversation? Honestly until now the thought didn't even cross my mind.
I could see it. They've got more than enough topics to argue about; be it Clementine, Matthew (Kenny noticed his prolong absence), or Carver's group (Kenny mentions it at dinner if you sit with him). I don't see things escalating to murder though.
I really don't know what to think about him.. I want to like him, he seems like a cool guy... but I don't trust him yet. Finding out wherever he went at the end of the episode will be the determining factor for me, I think.
I really don't know what to think about him.. I want to like him, he seems like a cool guy... but I don't trust him yet. Finding out wherever he went at the end of the episode will be the determining factor for me, I think.
Thinking on it again, the "take a hike" line made it sound like Luke was talking about something Kenny wasn't interested in hearing. So that probably rules out the Matthew thing since I don't see him letting Luke walk away from that argument. If Carver had already taken the group hostage, I can see Luke hesitating because he knows what the man is like and any warnings to Kenny probably fell on deaf ears. And that's likely when he was told to take a hike because his precautions would be viewed as 'whining' to Kenny.
Luke didn't change the subject, he just gave you a subtle hint.
Clem: Why would Carver be after us?
Luke: What's the most important th… moreing in this world?
Clem: Family?
Luke: Yes, family. nudge nudge
It was a hint that Carver is after Rebecca's baby. -_-
I honestly see them as having a brother/sister relationship in the near future. It's already kind of showing in the way that Clem (depending on how nice you are through the game) is getting used to Luke and I think she as a character, despite how you play it, is beginning to trust him. As of now, obviously, Luke is missing but I don't think they'll kill him off that easily. Anything could happen, but I feel like telltale would like to add more to his character so you'll miss him more whenever his time does come, which I predict will be towards the end of the season.
Luke seems like a good guy, but I don't get why some people seem ready for him to replace the void Lee left when he died. No one will ever fill that void. As of how the game is going right now, I think at best Luke and Clem will just be good friends.
I honestly doubt it. If he was a con artist, he wasn't very good at it considering Nick and his back story where Nick said that Luke and him were "flat broke".
Luke: "Oh shit... look, we gotta get outta here! You don't know this guy, we're gonna need a battle plan!" Kenny: "I ain't backin down! If you're so scared, why don't you go take a hike?"
Thinking on it again, the "take a hike" line made it sound like Luke was talking about something Kenny wasn't interested in hearing. So that… more probably rules out the Matthew thing since I don't see him letting Luke walk away from that argument. If Carver had already taken the group hostage, I can see Luke hesitating because he knows what the man is like and any warnings to Kenny probably fell on deaf ears. And that's likely when he was told to take a hike because his precautions would be viewed as 'whining' to Kenny.
I agree. Its an easy conversation to imagine.
Luke: "Oh shit... look, we gotta get outta here! You don't know this guy, we're gonna need a battle plan!"
Kenny: "I ain't backin down! If you're so scared, why don't you go take a hike?"
Yeah they probably would rather let the player see it before their very eyes, to get more of a reaction? Although it is telltale games... you never know.
I don't think Luke is as good as a guy as people think he is, here's why. He acts all nice after the shits been handled (shed) but not once has he protected Clementine. You could argue about the bridge scene but he left Clem with 2 walkers just to handle one and than he fell. But if Clem had fallen would he have helped her? What if there's a part in the next episode where Clementine is surrounded by a horde of Zombies and Luke is there but does nothing (out of fear like Ben in episode 4, maybe Christa will appear and save Clementine ) but I doubt he is a bad guy but if it came to the point of risking his life to save Clem I think he wouldn't save her since it seems he values his own life more.
Well, he DID save Clem's life in Episode 1. She was about to be eaten by a walker when he cut its head off. And that was before he even knew who she was.
I don't think Luke is as good as a guy as people think he is, here's why. He acts all nice after the shits been handled (shed) but not once … morehas he protected Clementine. You could argue about the bridge scene but he left Clem with 2 walkers just to handle one and than he fell. But if Clem had fallen would he have helped her? What if there's a part in the next episode where Clementine is surrounded by a horde of Zombies and Luke is there but does nothing (out of fear like Ben in episode 4, maybe Christa will appear and save Clementine ) but I doubt he is a bad guy but if it came to the point of risking his life to save Clem I think he wouldn't save her since it seems he values his own life more.
Carver said Alvin killed George because "you didn't like him". Note that Carver said "him" and not "me" which is obviously stating that he was referring to someone else but not himself.
Actually what Carver said was Alvin killed George because he didn't like Carver. this doesn't make sense why do you kill the friend of the person you wanted to kill >_>, but there is a chance that happen when they were trying to escape.
Carver said Alvin killed George because "you didn't like him". Note that Carver said "him" and not "me" which is obviously stating that he was referring to someone else but not himself.
Luke didn't change the subject, he just gave you a subtle hint.
Clem: Why would Carver be after us?
Luke: What's the most important th… moreing in this world?
Clem: Family?
Luke: Yes, family. nudge nudge
It was a hint that Carver is after Rebecca's baby. -_-
Comments
Well no, it wasn't. Luke was already gone, and the rest of the group was captured and/or being tortured. That is definitely not the time to be talking.
And it was Kenny shooting that got a member of the group (or 2) killed. Shooting was not the correct course of action at that point. Having an extra gun would have gotten more people killed.
True, but I meant from Kenny's perspective. Obviously, Kenny was not up for the "live to fight another day" plan. Even though is was the best course of action. Also, asking where Luke was so we know that he didn't just bail on us would've been nice.
You are completely taking my words out of context. I never said the group should have shared there back story to Clem or anything like that. In a previous statement I've written that I acknowledge everyone in TWDU has a back story, and that's fine and dandy. All I wanted was to express to players they should maybe take Carver's words into consideration. There are two sides to the story, and as of right now for me personally I think I want to hear more of his side.
That's great that you have both the group and Carver figured out, but I don't and want more to go on before I can say I can trust this group.
Fair enough. Now we just wait for episode 3 before we continue this conversation.
Luke seems like a good guy, but I don't get why some people seem ready for him to replace the void Lee left when he died. No one will ever fill that void. As of how the game is going right now, I think at best Luke and Clem will just be good friends.
I saw Lee as more of a father figure, while Luke is more of a big brother type. While Lee was definitely all about protecting Clem, Luke is more on an equal footing with Clem. They are both capable and work well together. It's a very different dynamic in their relationships. Hence the fun, yet slightly awkward interactions between the two.
My thoughts on Luke...
He likes taking hikes!
My thoughts on Kenny...
He likes telling people to take hikes!
I like Luke but he is definitely hiding something. Like after Carver shows up and they have to leave the cabin, Clem asks "Why would he still be following you?" He just looks away and changes the subject. It's kind of annoying when he does that.
she got skinny ass too hhhhhhhhhh
Luke didn't change the subject, he just gave you a subtle hint.
Clem: Why would Carver be after us?
Luke: What's the most important thing in this world?
Clem: Family?
Luke: Yes, family. nudge nudge
It was a hint that Carver is after Rebecca's baby. -_-
Well then, they'll get along just fine.
I don't trust him. I don't trust anyone I don't already know from season 1.
Well, guys don't have skinny asses.
Alt least, not attractive ones. The most generally considered attractive male ass is actually quite similar to the female one, except less triangle shaped and more rectangle shaped.
I do think it's interesting, could something bad happenend between Luke and Kenny, other than just a heated conversation? Honestly until now the thought didn't even cross my mind.
I could see it. They've got more than enough topics to argue about; be it Clementine, Matthew (Kenny noticed his prolong absence), or Carver's group (Kenny mentions it at dinner if you sit with him). I don't see things escalating to murder though.
Definitely agreeing with you, no murder. But come to think of it the whole 'Take a hike!' thing monologue by Kenny was weird.
I really don't know what to think about him.. I want to like him, he seems like a cool guy... but I don't trust him yet. Finding out wherever he went at the end of the episode will be the determining factor for me, I think.
Yup, can totally see where you're coming from. It's going to be interesting to see what will happen.
Thinking on it again, the "take a hike" line made it sound like Luke was talking about something Kenny wasn't interested in hearing. So that probably rules out the Matthew thing since I don't see him letting Luke walk away from that argument. If Carver had already taken the group hostage, I can see Luke hesitating because he knows what the man is like and any warnings to Kenny probably fell on deaf ears. And that's likely when he was told to take a hike because his precautions would be viewed as 'whining' to Kenny.
Round 3: Coming "soon".
CLAMentine??
Derp. Don't mind me, I'm just an airhead sometimes.
Luke strikes me as a con artist type. I think he'd fit in really good with Danny on that prison bus. Just my opinion.
I honestly see them as having a brother/sister relationship in the near future. It's already kind of showing in the way that Clem (depending on how nice you are through the game) is getting used to Luke and I think she as a character, despite how you play it, is beginning to trust him. As of now, obviously, Luke is missing but I don't think they'll kill him off that easily. Anything could happen, but I feel like telltale would like to add more to his character so you'll miss him more whenever his time does come, which I predict will be towards the end of the season.
I honestly doubt it. If he was a con artist, he wasn't very good at it considering Nick and his back story where Nick said that Luke and him were "flat broke".
I agree. Its an easy conversation to imagine.
Luke: "Oh shit... look, we gotta get outta here! You don't know this guy, we're gonna need a battle plan!"
Kenny: "I ain't backin down! If you're so scared, why don't you go take a hike?"
I hope that's what happened and not the reoccurring theory of Kenny killing Luke just out of pure jealousy...
You mean Justin. Danny was the statutory rapist.
I think they would never ever do such a thing offscreen! (Hopefully, haha)
TV Tropes terminology +1
Yeah they probably would rather let the player see it before their very eyes, to get more of a reaction? Although it is telltale games... you never know.
Inside and out eh? Luke gets all the ladies I suppose
I don't think Luke is as good as a guy as people think he is, here's why. He acts all nice after the shits been handled (shed) but not once has he protected Clementine. You could argue about the bridge scene but he left Clem with 2 walkers just to handle one and than he fell. But if Clem had fallen would he have helped her? What if there's a part in the next episode where Clementine is surrounded by a horde of Zombies and Luke is there but does nothing (out of fear like Ben in episode 4, maybe Christa will appear and save Clementine
) but I doubt he is a bad guy but if it came to the point of risking his life to save Clem I think he wouldn't save her since it seems he values his own life more.
Well, he DID save Clem's life in Episode 1. She was about to be eaten by a walker when he cut its head off. And that was before he even knew who she was.
Carver said Alvin killed George because "you didn't like him". Note that Carver said "him" and not "me" which is obviously stating that he was referring to someone else but not himself.
Look at 2:30. He says "me."
Oh, my bad. Thanks for clarifying it for me.
Am i the only one who find that Alvin is the only one who doesn't know that Carver is the father kind of silly.