**** or **** Poll. Who would you save? CLOSED

1234579

Comments

  • edited March 2014

    I think the majority of us are less "fans" of each other and more just friends... For example, I consider Saltlick a pal, someone I get along with. I'm by no means his fan.

    Lemoncakes posted: »

    You know how I know you're mad? You're still here after saying you were going to leave half-a-dozen times. You know how I know you kno

  • It's pretty funny, him now asking for a debate when it started by him dismissing the actual debate. :p

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    Isn't if funny how he is so hungry for a Luke/Kenny argument when the reason this argument started was him dismissing any opinion supporting Luke ? He lost it.

  • I never called people retarded. I claimed that a fanclub had gone retarded, not that the individuals within the fanclub are inherently, genetically retarded.

    That would be ableist. And rude!

    But Luke is not a nice guy, nor is he necessarily a good person, for reasons I listed above. Taking into account the thematic and narrative trappings around the events so far, I think it's fair to say Luke is bad news.

    If you agree, then you agree and we're in agreement and we're both right.

    If not, you're wrong.

    Zyphon posted: »

    Calling people retarded is not truth, it's fucking rude. We're both going to say that we "won", so instead, let's let the general public

  • LemonCakes went on a RAMPAGE after everyone told him he was delusional asshole.

    That many people can't be wrong, Nothing you post make sense and you're extremely biased when replying to someone.

    What else can I expect from a guy that openly said an opinion different to his is irrelevant ?

    Lemoncakes posted: »

    You've reached a point where you literally have no conception of an argument, SaltLick305. "Hey guys is funny how he wants a Luke/Kenny argument in a Luke/Kenny thread where he made argument about Luke and Kenny? huhuhuh"

  • Don't be like SaltLick305, Zyphon. You're better than that.

    Zyphon posted: »

    It's pretty funny, him now asking for a debate when it started by him dismissing the actual debate.

  • Yes, that's true, but he don't care Clem in those moments. So Kenny nor a big angel, who always protect Clem with his life.

    Kartal5 posted: »

    perhaps the fact that his whole family died a few hours prior to that had something to do with it.

  • edited March 2014

    Saltlick doesn't do that other places, and I like him. I think he's a good person, regardless of whatever "forum ethics" or "rules" that you're going off of, I simply think that he is a better person than you. In my theory threads both of us have been able to look at either side of an argument, and see it from another person's point of view(something you seem to be incapable of), and he's a nice guy when legitimately debating someone on a point. most of the time. So yeah, I think he's a good poster. Hey may do one thing that I don't like in this one place, but why does that have to mean that I think he's a bad poster and my judgement is clouded if I think anything other than that?

    Lemoncakes posted: »

    First off, you're objectively incorrect. SaltLick305 is a bad poster. In fact he's done something you "hate" repeatedly throughout his posti

  • Oh SaltLick305, ad populum fallacies this late in the game?

    I mean I didn't know you were this bad at posting...

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    LemonCakes went on a RAMPAGE after everyone told him he was delusional asshole. That many people can't be wrong, Nothing you post make se

  • All of these arguments because of two fictional characters. lol

  • but that is exactly what is going to happen . . .I mean telltale literally could not set it up any more obviously. Sarita (spelling? / pronunciation ?) will die- that is a guarantee- by the end of the season.

    2epicpanda posted: »

    Although i sat with luke, im more inclined now towards kenny, as long as he doesn't loose it and go all physco (Especially if Katjaa 2.0 dies) Even then, We still don't know enough about luke..HARD CHOICE

  • Kenny was willing to go against everyone in the initial group in S1 for the decisions that he believed were to be the right ones, so your assumption is flawed, the truth is that neither of us know for sure how he would react initially, but at least im basing my assumption on how Kenny actually behaved in S1.

    Swindler posted: »

    Luke didn't want to lock Clementine in the shed. The group did. Kenny wouldn't want to lock Clementine in the shed if he didn't know her, bu

  • At least Ten other people didn't come in here and tell me that unlike.... You ? Everyone knows it Lemon, You're a Troll incapable of having a real argument.

    Lemoncakes posted: »

    Oh SaltLick305, ad populum fallacies this late in the game? I mean I didn't know you were this bad at posting...

  • edited March 2014

    No, if I disagree with you, which I do, then that means I have a different opinion, not that I'm wrong. Luke has been nice to Clem, and he seems to be a good guy. We can't look into the future, so right now, that's all we've got to go with. Everyone in the group was sorry about locking Clem up, even Rebecca. Luke didn't go against the group, that's true, but I don't really blame him for that because he was sorry, he didn't want to in the first place, and he did save Clem, something that neither Nick or Rebecca, or maybe even Carlos, would have done.

    Stop trying to prove other's opinion as true or false. It's one of the things that I hate most on the internet.

    Also, you did call someone a retard. Right near the beginning of when all this started, you said this to Juice Box:

    "Why, are you retarded? Let me know if you are and how, I'll tailor my posts so you'll better understand them."

    No matter what, it's rude. And still, even just insulting a group of people, or the school of thought they belong to, is incredibly rude. Stop trying to justify your insults.

    Lemoncakes posted: »

    I never called people retarded. I claimed that a fanclub had gone retarded, not that the individuals within the fanclub are inherently, gene

  • What? You can't seriously think that you were contributing when you said that everyone on one side of the argument was wrong, can you?

    Lemoncakes posted: »

    Don't be like SaltLick305, Zyphon. You're better than that.

  • Oh he may be a good person in real life, I don't feign to know him just as you shouldn't feign to know me. Doing so would be incredibly judgmental and a terribly premature mistake.

    But he's a reaaaaally bad poster. Childish, churlish, a tantrum thrower that's awful in almost every respect when his fragile ego's wounded.

    I can easily look at the other side of an argument: It's how I know it's objectively wrong and stems from some sort of warped perspective rooted in a lack of reasoning or proper assessment.

    In regard to your judgment clouded, that's something you've demonstrated. You gave examples of things you hate or think are lame. You say SaltLick305 is a "great" poster. SaltLick305 did things you hate and are lame repeatedly in this thread. He did so out of anger and frustration at being unable to bully me into any sort of submission, which I understand, but it's pretty damning evidence alongside your anger toward me that your emotions play an inordinate role in your reasoning.

    Zyphon posted: »

    Saltlick doesn't do that other places, and I like him. I think he's a good person, regardless of whatever "forum ethics" or "rules" that you

  • What were some of the things that Kenny went against the group and did in season 1?

    Kartal5 posted: »

    Kenny was willing to go against everyone in the initial group in S1 for the decisions that he believed were to be the right ones, so your as

  • Well buddy I have to leave, My phone has no battery.

    I wouldn't stay here If I was you a couple of people we know can't handle losing an argument and I know you're a smart guy. See you later.

    Zyphon posted: »

    It's pretty funny, him now asking for a debate when it started by him dismissing the actual debate.

  • I'd save Luke, provided the choice came up in Episode 4 or 5. Kenny, if it came up in Episode 3.

    My reasoning isn't that I like Luke more. The opposite, in fact, as if it were a competition between which character I like/trust more, I would easily pick Kenny every time. The thing is, though, that we've already seen quite a bit of Kenny. He was in every Episode of Season 1, had a cameo in 400 Days, and it looks as if he'll be with us for most of Season 2 as well. I like that, I really do, but that is, in my opinion, enough time in the spotlight for any character. We've only just met Luke (from a story standpoint) and I'd really like to get to know more about him. He hasn't had nearly as much focus series wide as Kenny has.

    The addendum, that the choice must be in Episode 4 or 5 is because I feel Episode 3 is too early for Kenny to be killed off. We've only just reconnected with him, and having him die almost immediately after reintroducing him would be something I couldn't stand. There's a lot of things going on with him which I'm as interested in as I am learning more about Luke. I want more time to spend with Kenny before they kill him again, this time for real.

  • People automatically hate you now when you tell the truth to their faces

    Also lol as if those 10 people would even know what ad populum is without googling it.

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    At least Ten other people didn't come in here and tell me that unlike.... You ? Everyone knows it Lemon, You're a Troll incapable of having a real argument.

  • Everyone on one side of an argument is wrong.

    That's why we have arguments.

    What planet are you from?

    Zyphon posted: »

    What? You can't seriously think that you were contributing when you said that everyone on one side of the argument was wrong, can you?

  • edited March 2014

    Not even in real life, just other places on the forum. He may do things I don't like here, but he's a good poster anywhere else I've seen him. You've gotten a lot of people quite worked up about this whole thing, I'm not blaming him too much. A similar situation happened elsewhere where I was bordering on insulting this guy and Saltlick told me what I was doing, so I went back and apologized, agreeing to disagree with the other person. Yeah, I think he's a good poster, and you're judging his posting "skills" just by here.

    I fact, let's try to move away from saying good poster or bad poster. What are the rules or logic that you're going by to determine this? I'm just going to say that Saltlick is a good guy. Let's leave it at that, I'd rather not argue about Saltlick anymore because now you know my stance, and I know yours. I don't think either of our opinions can be swayed.

    As for you looking at the other side of an argument. you did not prove it wrong. What you brought up are either predictions, or your opinion of the character. You can't distinguish your own opinion from a fact, and you've got zero respect for anyone's opinion that you don't agree with, as you've shown repeatedly. Please, learn to accept that people have different opinions. You can't prove them wrong, they are just as valid as yours. They think Luke is a nice guy. You don't. you say that you've proved them wrong with the shed thing. Guess what, that's your opinion still. Luke clearly didn't want to go along with it, but yeah, he did. you can view that two ways, at heart, he's a good guy, or he'll go along with what his group says and he isn't a good guy. Either way, you can't prove one opinion is false and the other is true.

    Lemoncakes posted: »

    Oh he may be a good person in real life, I don't feign to know him just as you shouldn't feign to know me. Doing so would be incredibly judg

  • Ok was fun bye have a good one dude.

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    Well buddy I have to leave, My phone has no battery. I wouldn't stay here If I was you a couple of people we know can't handle losing an argument and I know you're a smart guy. See you later.

  • I'll only stay until I actually get frustrated, then I'll leave. See ya.

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    Well buddy I have to leave, My phone has no battery. I wouldn't stay here If I was you a couple of people we know can't handle losing an argument and I know you're a smart guy. See you later.

  • edited March 2014

    I'm from planet Earth, where most people can respect another's opinion. Not everyone in one side of an argument or debate is wrong, in fact, that is rarely the case. Usually, both sides can make good points and support their opinions so that they can become credible opinions. But still, unless we're talking about science, neither side is right most of the time. It just depends on which side garners more support, or even just having a good, healthy back and forth so that they can learn from each other.

    A debate about which character in a story is better is an opinion based on, facts are not involved. Please, please, just learn this, because it is what is at the heart of this new argument, you're inability to accept or even consider the opinion of other people when it contradicts your own.

    Lemoncakes posted: »

    Everyone on one side of an argument is wrong. That's why we have arguments. What planet are you from?

  • This was definitely fun. None of your posts made a bit of sense but we still wasted the whole day on this.

    9% Battery thanks to your brilliant points LemonCakes...

    Heated arguments are the best.

    Lemoncakes posted: »

    Ok was fun bye have a good one dude.

  • ~I'm the best poster everrrrrrrr~

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    This was definitely fun. None of your posts made a bit of sense but we still wasted the whole day on this. 9% Battery thanks to your brilliant points LemonCakes... Heated arguments are the best.

  • You're up there... Right behind Me, Zyphon, and just about everyone else but Yeah you're definitely on the list I'll give you that.

    Look, I've got about 5 minutes till my phone turns off use that time to redeem yourself and tell me how superior Iam. I take it this was the best day ever for you just getting to talk to me for so long.

    Lemoncakes posted: »

    ~I'm the best poster everrrrrrrr~

  • Saying "sorry" or being sorry doesn't really clean the slate for me when it comes to imprisonment and attempted manslaughter, as it shouldn't.

    Additionally you literally quoted me saying that I called someone a retard when in the very quote you quoted saying I did...I didn't.

    I asked if he was retarded, because he took exception to the use of the word in regards to Luke, who's a bit mentally slow, let's be honest.

    Zyphon posted: »

    No, if I disagree with you, which I do, then that means I have a different opinion, not that I'm wrong. Luke has been nice to Clem, and he s

  • i would save luke.

  • edited March 2014

    No you're a terrible poster SaltLick305 (but maybe not the worst[but still really bad so maybe])

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    You're up there... Right behind Me, Zyphon, and just about everyone else but Yeah you're definitely on the list I'll give you that. Look,

  • Are you implying the worst poster ever is LemonCakes ? If so... YAY he finally said something that that didn't instantaneously make me shake my head in disbelief.

    Lemoncakes posted: »

    No you're a terrible poster SaltLick305 (but maybe not the worst[but still really bad so maybe])

  • edited March 2014

    Kenny. I don't need him to take care of Clementine, she can take care of herself.

    He needs her. And she'll be there for him.

    "We don't leave friends behind!"- Clementine

  • No offense but i dont feel like replying to your every damn comment on explaining the scenes from the game, if you're that much curious about it you could always go back and play it. But since you insist on it: "I could give two shits about what Lilly wants" and "You like to think you're the leader of this group, but we can make our own goddamn decisions" are just some examples that shows that he isnt afraid to go against the group.

    Swindler posted: »

    What were some of the things that Kenny went against the group and did in season 1?

  • edited March 2014

    Really? That sounds like a poor excuse of "I couldn't find any solid evidence so I'm going to pretend not to care." Actually, you just proved my point. Kenny hated Lilly for trying to be the leader of the group. He believed in a democracy. Carlos wanted to put Clementine in the shed. Nick and Rebecca wanted to kill her, but settled for the shed idea. Alvin and Pete were okay with it to an extent. Luke was the only one to constantly oppose this idea. Kenny would actually let them put Clem in the shed if he didn't know her since he hates for one person to dictate a course of action. If Kenny was in Luke's shoes, as long as the group settled on that idea, he would probably be in the "okay with it to an extent" column and since the group didn't really have a problem with it (except for Luke, but this is a scenario where Kenny replaces Luke so that means no one opposes the shed idea) then Kenny would comply.

    Kartal5 posted: »

    No offense but i dont feel like replying to your every damn comment on explaining the scenes from the game, if you're that much curious abou

  • Now that the argument is over admit you lost it at the beginning @LemonCakes After that it just became a joke. (Saltlick 1-0 Lemoncakes)

    Lemoncakes posted: »

    No you're a terrible poster SaltLick305 (but maybe not the worst[but still really bad so maybe])

  • edited March 2014

    Still rude, still insulting. I'm not going to push the point, we all know you're an asshole.

    We clearly have a difference of opinion, honestly, I'm done with this. I'd do my whole, "let's just respect each others opinions", but I fear that you'd try to find some way to "prove me wrong". So let's part ways hating each other, it seems that people do that a lot with you.

    Lemoncakes posted: »

    Saying "sorry" or being sorry doesn't really clean the slate for me when it comes to imprisonment and attempted manslaughter, as it shouldn'

  • You two are still arguing with each other? I thought it was over already.

    Zyphon posted: »

    Still rude, still insulting. I'm not going to push the point, we all know you're an asshole. We clearly have a difference of opinion, hon

  • Losing to one person wasn't enough for him

    Rafoli posted: »

    You two are still arguing with each other? I thought it was over already.

  • In my opinion Lemon won the arguement against Saltlick.

    ImSnowWhite posted: »

    Losing to one person wasn't enough for him

  • It is, did you not read my comment? I'm done with him.

    Rafoli posted: »

    You two are still arguing with each other? I thought it was over already.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.