When Did You Realize Who Matthew Was?
What was the exact moment you realized Matthew was the man who Nick shot off the bridge?
I figured it out about the time Walter said he was outside doing something.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
What was the exact moment you realized Matthew was the man who Nick shot off the bridge?
I figured it out about the time Walter said he was outside doing something.
Comments
Yep about the same time he mentioned that he was walking around.
I didn't realize it till Luke showed the picture.
Yep very quickly
I was pretty sure the ski lodge had a group there.
The moment Nick shot Matthew, I knew it would come back to bite us in the ass somehow.... I was 100% sure about the same time as you did.
when they first said his name, because everyone here always gave away his name cause he was in the files before episode 2 came out >:(
I'm not even lying now:
Immediatly after I saw Walter.
In the preview for Episode 2 (the 'I thought you were dead' one), you can see him with Walter.
And I knew Matthew was part of his group, so the more shocked I was when Nick shot him.
Same
When Walter showed the can of peaches it clicked for me. I went from being happy Kenny returned to "Fuck we killed Matthew! BOLLOCKS!" very quickly :P
The moment Walter says: "Don't worry, Matthew will be back soon", shortly after entering the ski lodge.
fo shizzle I realised when Walt Disney said He will be back soon and I was like fo shiz nizzle
Th very first time they mentioned Matthew. I thought oh thats that guy
Same here.I was OH SHIT FUCKING NICK
I was too caught up in the return of Kenny to notice until Sarita brought him up again.. Once I saw the option to ask "What does Matthew look like?" it all fell into place.
Because we saw Matthew with Walter in the preview at the end of Episode 1, as soon as he went over the side of the bridge I knew we'd done goofed, and done goofed bad. As soon as they mentioned Matthew at the lodge, I was completely sure.
NNNIIIIIICCCCCKKKKKKKK
The first time that I thought about Matthew might be connected with the Ski Lodge group, was when there was an option to ask Sarita how Matthew looks.
Dat can of Clementines look-alike!
When Clementine got locked in the shed
When I saw the cans of peaches, since the cabin by the bridge had them as well.
When Walter said how he wouldn't know what to do without Matthew, i imagined that scenario aaaand then i realized what did Nick do.
When Luke told me... not very proud of that.
When Alvin showed the peaches, I thought nothing of it, minus my distaste for the bad joke. Then Walter made a similar joke with the same type of peaches... Oh crud.
I knew who Matthew was thanks to TheWalkingDeadWikia way before S2E2 was released. Plus I recognised him from the teaser as he is with Walter at the Ski resort.
The only thing I was spoiled about regarding episode 2 was Kenny's return (still so pissed, I saw a gif set with Kenny and screamed) so I didn't know Matthew was Walter's significant other until Walter showed me the can of peaches. Cue the "oh crap" moment.
For me it was after Walter showed Clem the can of peaches. Then if you click the peaches when you're exploring the lodge, Clem looks at them again with an "OH SHIT" look on her face. It clicked for me and I was "WHELP, NICK IS GONNA DIE." (He didn't in my play through but I was bummed to find out later that he was determinant.)
I figured out the first time someone mentioned Matthew.
As soon as I got to the rest of the people and (even before Clem saw Kenny) I was like,"They're gonna be pissed because I'm pretty sure we killed that guy and he was probably a part of this place"
I figured it the second time someone said Matthew's name. The first time they just say that Matthew isnt back, but at that point I had no idea how many people were in the group, so he could have been 1 of 10 people that werent there for all I knew. I kept note of it though, because I try to keep track of these things.
But when Walter mentioned him again within like a minute, I figured that was the guy and it really cemented that idea when Walter kept mentioning him when he was cooking beans and finally the can of peaches made it obvious.
same
Walter: "Striking resemblance."
Around when Sarita began talking about him. I was like "Wait, Telltale wouldn't hint at him THREE times unless he was a really significant... Shit."
It was when I was walking outside with Walter is when I had a hunch, but I still wasn't 100% sure.
The moment i saw Walter.
Me too
that when I realized also.
When I heard Sarita describing him
Iirc I realized who he was around when I got to the cabin. I was like "Wtf? He lied about having food? No....something's not right. I bet he lives in the ski lodge up there."
It's sad but I didn't realize it until Luke showed me the picture of them together.
When they mentioned Matthew for the second time, I thought of the knife which had a "WM" on it, so I kinda guessed that him and Matthew were a couple.
When Walter kept going on about him.