When Lee recommends a person to look after Clem...
Does it make any difference in season 2's dialogue?
I am mainly talking about episode 2's dialogue, but still, it was a pretty big decision (it at least felt that way) in season one, so does anyone know?
I picked Omid and Christa at the time, but I am tempted to go back and pick Kenny to see if it changes the dialogue (and I should have known that it would be Kenny to take care of her in the end).
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
If you pick Kenny, he still gets lost to the herd, but Christa says, "Look, I know Kenny was your guy, but we've all she's got now. We need to stay safe for her," or something similar to that.
I picked Omid and Christa as well on account of them both being bloody legends. I doubt it will make much of a difference though, it's a little too subtle of a dialogue choice to make a change in season 2 imho.
I know I'll get a lot of downvotes for this and not answering your question but, I told them to find a good family for her. I mean in the opening sequence in Season 2, I get it Clem can take care of herself and all but I mean she's just a KID! (And no, I'm not trying to be like Carlos. This is the truth!) What if there's a bandit inside that bathroom? That person could kidnapp Clem easily and quietly, then he can take her in to the woods and... god!!! From what I can see, Clem is a victim of irresponsibility. I don't know you guys but I was like;''What? Are you guys seriously let her alone in there while two of you gonna have sex in the other room?'' So, yeah. Christa has no rights to blame Clem for Omid's death. It's THEIR own fault.
I certainly wont downvote you, you actually make a good point, on my first playthrough i was also think wtf are you doing letting a 9 year old girl go into room by herself filled with who knows what!
It's BOTH of their faults them for leaving her and Clem for leaving a LOADED gun on the counter
It's like two sides of a coin
I doubt it would make a difference.
It would be cool though if what Lee said is where Clementine goes. So lets say you have reunited with Christa and have escapes Carver's compound. Christa tells you who Lee said to take care of her and starts heading off in one direction because she doesn't believe in strength in numbers. Kenny, and Sarita are going another direction because Kenny doesn't like the cabin group. Cabin group is going in another direction as well. If Lee said "Find her a family" then Clementine goes with cabin group. If he said "You guys take care of her"(meaning Omid and Christa) then Clem goes with Christa. If he said "Kenny should take care of her" then she would go with Kenny. Clem will go with whoever Christa told her Lee wanted to be with her. The funny part is that you don't make the decision because Lee did already in E5.
Clem's fault? Clem was carrying a gun to protect herself. Omid and Christa just doesn't give a saltlick about that and they left her alone in there. If they all just stayed in one room together, none of this would've happened. Don't get me wrong I love Omid and Christa but what they did just... unforgivable.
What happens if you picked "..."
Maybe she goes her own way?
Well I can't let her choose since it's a three-way choice.... But why would you be silent anyway? I guess she would probably just go off on her own. Obviously cabin group, Christa, and Kenny wouldn't leave her alone so maybe Carver or some zombies separate them and... she runs away. Since she shouldn't be by herself it would be cool if she ran into and stayed with the 400 day's group that stayed behind.
Carrying a gun yes but did you not see that she left the gun on the counter to get the Water when she could've brought the gun with her
No matter how you put it they shouldn't have left her but you can't give Clem a pass
She left the gun that michelle used to kill omid
I still stand it's BOTH o their faults
I said omid and christa because my kenny didnt even come with me to find her until i found him locked up.
Yeah, knowing thats shes a kid, they forget stuff, there're irresponsible at times besides she was their responsibility. So blaming her would still be blaming them. Its like if a child broke something at a store the parents would still be held accountable.
She was so little i cant imagine her being alone.
Yeah and that's what I'm saying they left her she left the gun it's both oftheirfaults
I agree, but, between the sink and grabbing a water bottle that rolled over into a stall two yards away? It's pretty reasonable to think you'd be good for the 30 seconds it would have taken; which begs the question, how did a bandit walk inside, grab the gun, and start rooting through her bag in such a short time without Clementine noticing or hearing anything?
And how did Christa and Omid finish up that quickly?
Like I had my lee tell her the gun always the gun first
I Agree that Clem isn't 100% blameless but everyone is guilty of letting their guard down now and then, and that wouldn't change in a zombie apocalypse.
sad nizzle fo real I ashamed of bromid and crispa espically crispy christa she yella at Mr Lee for how he dealt with clem in EP 3 yet she lets our lil boo boo go alone in a one way exit room fo real dawg that aint right
Who said it would lol
I agree Christa is awful.
I'll bet you she spent the next year and a half emotionally abusing Clem and treating her like shit about Omid. That shit was Christa and Omid's fault to begin with. They wanted some dirty restroom preggosex and paid the price.
It's an interesting idea, but I honestly don't like it. Players shouldn't be punished for something they said two years ago, because things change. You might say something in a moment that you regret later - and besides, what would happen with people who are using randomized saves? Or people who chose to remain silent in that moment (as was mentioned)? What if the game didn't import correctly or recognized your choice incorrectly?
It removes the player agency from the game in a very important moment. Generally, most people wouldn't like something like that.
For randomized saves it would just randomly choose an option ex: If you play episode 2 before episode 1 then the game makes random decisions for you in episode 1. And I'm not sure why it would import incorrectly and if it did that's Telltale's fault. For silence I said Clem would find 400 day's group but anyway I guess it would be better if it was a choice but what Lee said would make you want to follow his advice but you don't have to.
But honestly your right. It probably isn't the best idea. It was just a random idea I generated. But thanks to you and the others for your input.
Yeah, but that's just it: players would be punished for the game glitching out, or for whatever randomized save they got. A choice that big shouldn't be decided by the game for you.
(Gosh, I feel like I'm being rude right now - I hope none of that came off sounding rude. Just checking.)
fo real nizzle