it seems like nobody could. i was so pissed at the dog for chomping on me and making me drop my food i gladly left his ass to squirm... probably because im a cat person
You can blackmail him, then apologize and back out of the blackmail attempt ("I wouldn't really do that...but I don't have a lot of options"). It's rather cute, you still get the supplies and the juice box because he realizes how desperate Clem is, and for once it's the only going-halfway course of action ever to work in TWD.
the only things I could not bring myself to do are siding with larry, not taking the food from the station wagon and trying to sneak away without distracting the bandits to save christa
I hid the bite and let Kenny shoot Duck. Wasn't being bad for the sake of it and don't regret the choices one bit.
I'm never really rude to Larry, though. Wouldn't leave the supplies in the woods in episode 2, either
Yeah, I usually try to convince Kenny to kill him for closure. Appealing to Nick is hilarious if you choose to glare at him. She gives him this look that practically screams "If the tables are turned, I won't miss!"
The two major ones that come to mind are leaving the kid in the attic and telling Clementine not to trust anyone. I also haven't tried appealing to Nick or Rebecca at the cabin, though I can imagine it doesn't go well.
I'm the exact opposite, I practically make my mission to antagonize Larry. Which, come to think of it, is pretty dumb, considering his ice nd temper. Still can't beat lines like this...
I hid the bite and let Kenny shoot Duck. Wasn't being bad for the sake of it and don't regret the choices one bit.
I'm never really rude to Larry, though. Wouldn't leave the supplies in the woods in episode 2, either
Every time the game tells me that Clementine feels hurt/scared/scorned I get this feeling like "Wow, I'd be a terrible parent..." The only time I purposely yelled at her was the doggie door incident.
I couldn't be rude to Luke even though I did enjoy a bit of undetermined sassiness.
I couldn't pass up being a bitch to Rebecca in episode one season two.
I couldn't possibly make Clementine blame herself for Lee's death.
That's about it but I am still waiting for an option in the future to prove Carlos wrong on something medical related... I have a feeling he's either a piss doctor or he's not a real doctor :P
Good observations! I really struggled with the 'parents' issue. I tried to GENTLY convince her that they wouldn't be coming back, but she couldn't be swayed.
The apocalypse is probably the best thing that ever happened to Carlos. All those malpractice lawsuits would have ruined his career!
I couldn't side with Larry.
I couldn't lie to Walter.
I couldn't tell Clementine her parents were dead.
I couldn't be rude to Cleme… morentine.
I couldn't be rude to Luke even though I did enjoy a bit of undetermined sassiness.
I couldn't pass up being a bitch to Rebecca in episode one season two.
I couldn't possibly make Clementine blame herself for Lee's death.
That's about it but I am still waiting for an option in the future to prove Carlos wrong on something medical related... I have a feeling he's either a piss doctor or he's not a real doctor :P
I knew that they were dead the entire time, it was just too obvious. Although I did want to look for them with her because she would have never let it go if she didn't know what happened to them, then I was forced by telltale to not let her look for her parents, which caused Lee's death and the only way I could tell her that we could look for her parents was a lie which she ends up calling Lee out on. Dammit telltale, why do you do this to me...
Good observations! I really struggled with the 'parents' issue. I tried to GENTLY convince her that they wouldn't be coming back, but she … morecouldn't be swayed.
The apocalypse is probably the best thing that ever happened to Carlos. All those malpractice lawsuits would have ruined his career!
I chose "..." I was at a complete loss for words. I somewhat disagree though. Closure is important, but I couldn't risk everyone's lives in order to look for them.
I knew that they were dead the entire time, it was just too obvious. Although I did want to look for them with her because she would have ne… morever let it go if she didn't know what happened to them, then I was forced by telltale to not let her look for her parents, which caused Lee's death and the only way I could tell her that we could look for her parents was a lie which she ends up calling Lee out on. Dammit telltale, why do you do this to me...
I chose "..." I was at a complete loss for words. I somewhat disagree though. Closure is important, but I couldn't risk everyone's lives in order to look for them.
I won't side with Larry, under any circumstances. He was a typical lowbrow idiot. That thinks with his fists, not his brain. If he had one that is.
Where Clementine is concerned, I wouldn't take any option that said her parents were dead. At that time, hope is all she had and I wouldn't be the one to crush it.
Vernon. I never trusted him. So when he gave me the lecture about Clementine etc, I threatened him without hesitation. None of the other options were fitting. As it turns out, I was correct in not trusting him.
Kenny. I tried not to take the option to fight him as I thought he was going through enough. At first I didn't think I could avoid it, until I found the correct responses. As for Duck, I chose to end it as being a Father myself I know I wouldn't be able to shoot my children either.
Ben. I have played both options, but I have to say dropping him is horrific to me. Despite what he did or didn't do. I in no way think he deserves that ending. I only dropped out of curiosity once, but haven't since in replays.
Finally, shooting or leaving Lee. This caused a dilemma. On the one hand I didn't want Clementine to shoot him/me because of the lasting impression it would make. On the other, I didn't want Clementine to suffer the 'what if' syndrome. She would always be wondering where he was, knowing he was a Walker now. Plus I think she would regret not putting him/me out of his misery now she is older.
Therefore, I chose to have Clementine end it.
Season Two - So Far :-
I know I will get downvotes for this and quite frankly I don't care. This is just my opinion. Firstly, I chose to give the black girl my hat. It's only a thing and not worth risking your life over. Plus I knew that sooner or later Christa and Omid would come in and chances are I would get it back.
Obviously things didn't work out like that, but I didn't know it on the first play through.
Next, the dog situation. Yes I left him. I didn't think much to the whole scenario, so thought it best just to get through as quick as possible.
Then there was Rebecca. In my judgement, no other choice was suitable except trying blackmail. She was giving Clementine a hard time, so in retaliation there was no other option worth exploring.
Lastly in episode one was the Pete or Nick choice. I went with Pete. Yes I know he was bitten, but that actually made it easier to go with him. No one should die alone.
Episode two had only a couple of difficult choices. Firstly which table to sit at. Having thought about it for a few minutes, really there was only once choice. Kennys. Clementine hadn't seen him for god knows how long. So it seems reasonable to think that she would want to know everything that had happened to him in Savannah. Even if that information wasn't forthcoming.
Finally, whether or not to try and find Kenny when the Carver fiasco was happening. Again, after thinking a few minutes I decided to try and find Kenny. Yes things went tits up in my play through considering two people were killed. However, it may have been the correct decision in the long run. After all Kenny didn't kill those people, Carver did. No amount of tit for tat argument can justify cold blooded murder.
Anyway, I look forward to seeing how my decisions affect the outcome of my game.
Well thought out, good justification for everything, especially having Clementine put Lee down. It would be traumatizing, but would provide closure. I figured that if he left Lee to turn into a walker, she may never forgive herself for it. The only time I had her leave is when I chose neither option and let her decide.
Season One :-
I won't side with Larry, under any circumstances. He was a typical lowbrow idiot. That thinks with his fists, not his brain… more. If he had one that is.
Where Clementine is concerned, I wouldn't take any option that said her parents were dead. At that time, hope is all she had and I wouldn't be the one to crush it.
Vernon. I never trusted him. So when he gave me the lecture about Clementine etc, I threatened him without hesitation. None of the other options were fitting. As it turns out, I was correct in not trusting him.
Kenny. I tried not to take the option to fight him as I thought he was going through enough. At first I didn't think I could avoid it, until I found the correct responses. As for Duck, I chose to end it as being a Father myself I know I wouldn't be able to shoot my children either.
Ben. I have played both options, but I have to say dropping him is horrific to me. Despite what he did or didn't do. I in no way … [view original content]
Season One :-
I won't side with Larry, under any circumstances. He was a typical lowbrow idiot. That thinks with his fists, not his brain… more. If he had one that is.
Where Clementine is concerned, I wouldn't take any option that said her parents were dead. At that time, hope is all she had and I wouldn't be the one to crush it.
Vernon. I never trusted him. So when he gave me the lecture about Clementine etc, I threatened him without hesitation. None of the other options were fitting. As it turns out, I was correct in not trusting him.
Kenny. I tried not to take the option to fight him as I thought he was going through enough. At first I didn't think I could avoid it, until I found the correct responses. As for Duck, I chose to end it as being a Father myself I know I wouldn't be able to shoot my children either.
Ben. I have played both options, but I have to say dropping him is horrific to me. Despite what he did or didn't do. I in no way … [view original content]
Ive never done this because I think its a bit cruel, but Ive always wondered what the dialogue is like in Ep.4 if you say "We want an answer Clementine!" when asking her about Campman
I just think interrogating a 9 year old girl like that would be hilarious though
Ive never done this because I think its a bit cruel, but Ive always wondered what the dialogue is like in Ep.4 if you say "We want an answer… more Clementine!" when asking her about Campman
I just think interrogating a 9 year old girl like that would be hilarious though
With Lee, I could never bring myself to be anything else but a big good, honest, well meaning father figure to Clementine. I never killed the living unless in self defence or (in Duck's case) mercy kill him to end his pain and misery. I refused to abandon or kill off others as best I could, wanting as many to survive as long as possible. And in the end, I can't leave Lee to die, feeling that he has earned his rest after going to such extreme lengths to keep his little "sweet pea" safe. It just feels too cruel to leave him to reanimate as a Walker.
As Clementine, I try to follow my Lee's example as much as I can, relying on honesty and trust while at the same time still being "tough as nails" as Pete put it. Much like Lee, I just can't choose "jerk" choices, as Clem is a ray of light in an otherwise dark situation, helping those who need it and always trying to persuade others to do the right thing. Nick and Alvin are both still alive thanks to these type of decisions.
I couldnt bring myself to kill Ben, eventhough I play through the game a few times to get different outcomes, I just couldnt do it. I think it was friggen Kenny nodding at me to do it that burned me up.
The only ways I'm horrible to Clem is in her grooming to be a steel-hearted murderer.
I killed both St. John's, helped Saltlick Larry in front of her, did the you're strong/hair short/don't be afraid bullet-to-head ubermensch combo closer, etc.
That might be bad for a child's development in civil society but out here in the wild it's Murder-Death-Kill time 24/7 homeboyyyyyyyy.
One dialogue choice that I haven't tried because I would feel like a capital B is when Rebecca asks Clem if she wants to feel the baby move in her tummy. I think one of the options is "Eww, gross" or something like that. I just couldn't do it even though I disliked her in the last episode. Plus bonus points for female bonding moment!
I can' choose it either, even though I really want to! Clem probably had a traumatic experience with Christa's baby, so it kind of stands to reason that she might find the whole thing rather disgusting/frightening.
But the "Sure, can I?" option is just too damn adorable, proving that the little kid within Clementine isn't completely dead. It also feels like a way to formally make peace with Rebecca after she extends an olive branch during the walk to the mountains.
One dialogue choice that I haven't tried because I would feel like a capital B is when Rebecca asks Clem if she wants to feel the baby move … morein her tummy. I think one of the options is "Eww, gross" or something like that. I just couldn't do it even though I disliked her in the last episode. Plus bonus points for female bonding moment!
Comments
-Hard not to say "fuck you" to the cop in s1 ep1
-Hard not to get Hershel pissed at you, no matter what he gets pissed at you
-Hard to side with Larry in the drug store
-Hard to save doug, Gun>AV guy
-Hard not to feed Clem, Duck
-One of the hardest choices In my opinion is what to say when the St.Johns ask you whos in charge... I said Kenny though
-Hard not to insult the shit out of Brenda, "Put the gun down, bitch!"
-Hard to quick think when Omid was being a stubborn cunt when you had to jump on the Train
-Save the girl? or save the guy whos hobbling like an idiot when Christa and Omid were running after the train
-Cut my arm off or what?
it seems like nobody could. i was so pissed at the dog for chomping on me and making me drop my food i gladly left his ass to squirm... probably because im a cat person
You can blackmail him, then apologize and back out of the blackmail attempt ("I wouldn't really do that...but I don't have a lot of options"). It's rather cute, you still get the supplies and the juice box because he realizes how desperate Clem is, and for once it's the only going-halfway course of action ever to work in TWD.
Giving up the hat in All That Remains.
I feel you
I always was about to make a scummy playthrough, but I never could bring myself to be mean to Clem, until recently I finally did it
But no matter how I play, I always leave Lilly (so far) and I always help kill Larry (so far)
Well i sometimes accidentally pick a dialogue option in season 1 and then find out it hurt Clem's feelings so i have to replay the scene.
What can i say, i'm a big softie XD.
My mum didn't feed Clementine... should I be worried?
the only things I could not bring myself to do are siding with larry, not taking the food from the station wagon and trying to sneak away without distracting the bandits to save christa
I hid the bite and let Kenny shoot Duck. Wasn't being bad for the sake of it and don't regret the choices one bit.
I'm never really rude to Larry, though. Wouldn't leave the supplies in the woods in episode 2, either
I accidentally pick this one:
Me thinking:''Okay honey. No problem. Let's see where the bathroom is okay?
Me:''LEE WTF?!''
Yeah, I usually try to convince Kenny to kill him for closure. Appealing to Nick is hilarious if you choose to glare at him. She gives him this look that practically screams "If the tables are turned, I won't miss!"
I'm the exact opposite, I practically make my mission to antagonize Larry. Which, come to think of it, is pretty dumb, considering his ice nd temper. Still can't beat lines like this...
At the St. Johns' dinner table.
I can never feel good about siding with Larry. Its also nearly impossible to not threaten that chickenshit Vernon now. I also won't make Clem cry.
Every time the game tells me that Clementine feels hurt/scared/scorned I get this feeling like "Wow, I'd be a terrible parent..." The only time I purposely yelled at her was the doggie door incident.
You should be worried about yourself, yes.
I couldn't side with Larry.
I couldn't lie to Walter.
I couldn't tell Clementine her parents were dead.
I couldn't be rude to Clementine.
I couldn't be rude to Luke even though I did enjoy a bit of undetermined sassiness.
I couldn't pass up being a bitch to Rebecca in episode one season two.
I couldn't possibly make Clementine blame herself for Lee's death.
That's about it but I am still waiting for an option in the future to prove Carlos wrong on something medical related... I have a feeling he's either a piss doctor or he's not a real doctor :P
Good observations! I really struggled with the 'parents' issue. I tried to GENTLY convince her that they wouldn't be coming back, but she couldn't be swayed.
The apocalypse is probably the best thing that ever happened to Carlos. All those malpractice lawsuits would have ruined his career!
I knew that they were dead the entire time, it was just too obvious. Although I did want to look for them with her because she would have never let it go if she didn't know what happened to them, then I was forced by telltale to not let her look for her parents, which caused Lee's death and the only way I could tell her that we could look for her parents was a lie which she ends up calling Lee out on. Dammit telltale, why do you do this to me...
I chose "..." I was at a complete loss for words. I somewhat disagree though. Closure is important, but I couldn't risk everyone's lives in order to look for them.
I always, always, ALWAYS give Clem food in episode 2. I know it's a little thing, but not giving her food is something I'll never be able to do.
I wouldn't either but if only they had tried to look for them when the streets weren't flooded with walkers.
Yep, me too, every time. I always feed Duck too.
Season One :-
I won't side with Larry, under any circumstances. He was a typical lowbrow idiot. That thinks with his fists, not his brain. If he had one that is.
Where Clementine is concerned, I wouldn't take any option that said her parents were dead. At that time, hope is all she had and I wouldn't be the one to crush it.
Vernon. I never trusted him. So when he gave me the lecture about Clementine etc, I threatened him without hesitation. None of the other options were fitting. As it turns out, I was correct in not trusting him.
Kenny. I tried not to take the option to fight him as I thought he was going through enough. At first I didn't think I could avoid it, until I found the correct responses. As for Duck, I chose to end it as being a Father myself I know I wouldn't be able to shoot my children either.
Ben. I have played both options, but I have to say dropping him is horrific to me. Despite what he did or didn't do. I in no way think he deserves that ending. I only dropped out of curiosity once, but haven't since in replays.
Finally, shooting or leaving Lee. This caused a dilemma. On the one hand I didn't want Clementine to shoot him/me because of the lasting impression it would make. On the other, I didn't want Clementine to suffer the 'what if' syndrome. She would always be wondering where he was, knowing he was a Walker now. Plus I think she would regret not putting him/me out of his misery now she is older.
Therefore, I chose to have Clementine end it.
Season Two - So Far :-
I know I will get downvotes for this and quite frankly I don't care. This is just my opinion. Firstly, I chose to give the black girl my hat. It's only a thing and not worth risking your life over. Plus I knew that sooner or later Christa and Omid would come in and chances are I would get it back.
Obviously things didn't work out like that, but I didn't know it on the first play through.
Next, the dog situation. Yes I left him. I didn't think much to the whole scenario, so thought it best just to get through as quick as possible.
Then there was Rebecca. In my judgement, no other choice was suitable except trying blackmail. She was giving Clementine a hard time, so in retaliation there was no other option worth exploring.
Lastly in episode one was the Pete or Nick choice. I went with Pete. Yes I know he was bitten, but that actually made it easier to go with him. No one should die alone.
Episode two had only a couple of difficult choices. Firstly which table to sit at. Having thought about it for a few minutes, really there was only once choice. Kennys. Clementine hadn't seen him for god knows how long. So it seems reasonable to think that she would want to know everything that had happened to him in Savannah. Even if that information wasn't forthcoming.
Finally, whether or not to try and find Kenny when the Carver fiasco was happening. Again, after thinking a few minutes I decided to try and find Kenny. Yes things went tits up in my play through considering two people were killed. However, it may have been the correct decision in the long run. After all Kenny didn't kill those people, Carver did. No amount of tit for tat argument can justify cold blooded murder.
Anyway, I look forward to seeing how my decisions affect the outcome of my game.
Well thought out, good justification for everything, especially having Clementine put Lee down. It would be traumatizing, but would provide closure. I figured that if he left Lee to turn into a walker, she may never forgive herself for it. The only time I had her leave is when I chose neither option and let her decide.
Grammar? What is this madness. Seriously dude, you are one of the few people who actually use grammar on this site.
Ive never done this because I think its a bit cruel, but Ive always wondered what the dialogue is like in Ep.4 if you say "We want an answer Clementine!" when asking her about Campman
I just think interrogating a 9 year old girl like that would be hilarious though
It's actually not that bad. I forget the exact wording, but It's similar to the way he says it in the preview.
With Lee, I could never bring myself to be anything else but a big good, honest, well meaning father figure to Clementine. I never killed the living unless in self defence or (in Duck's case) mercy kill him to end his pain and misery. I refused to abandon or kill off others as best I could, wanting as many to survive as long as possible. And in the end, I can't leave Lee to die, feeling that he has earned his rest after going to such extreme lengths to keep his little "sweet pea" safe. It just feels too cruel to leave him to reanimate as a Walker.
As Clementine, I try to follow my Lee's example as much as I can, relying on honesty and trust while at the same time still being "tough as nails" as Pete put it. Much like Lee, I just can't choose "jerk" choices, as Clem is a ray of light in an otherwise dark situation, helping those who need it and always trying to persuade others to do the right thing. Nick and Alvin are both still alive thanks to these type of decisions.
[Thanks, pete] is definitely not an option i can bring my self to click, he's coming with me everywhere i go
Did almost everything above. That's what i like about this game, there isn't a wrong answers.
NO! NO NO NO NO NO!! Clementine always eats FIRST and she gets the FUCKIN' APPLE!!
Sorry for yelling but no matter how many times I replay this chapter, Clementine eats first, dammit!
Ditto. I ask him to come with me every time, because after he stood up for Clem when no one else would, leaving him just seems selfish to me.
If the zombie apocalypse happens she's going to use you as a meat shield, sorry.
I couldnt bring myself to kill Ben, eventhough I play through the game a few times to get different outcomes, I just couldnt do it. I think it was friggen Kenny nodding at me to do it that burned me up.
Ive seen playthroughs where people refused to feed Clementine and I was like "What the heck is wrong with you???"
The only ways I'm horrible to Clem is in her grooming to be a steel-hearted murderer.
I killed both St. John's, helped Saltlick Larry in front of her, did the you're strong/hair short/don't be afraid bullet-to-head ubermensch combo closer, etc.
That might be bad for a child's development in civil society but out here in the wild it's Murder-Death-Kill time 24/7 homeboyyyyyyyy.
True but there is still guilt for certain actions, which I do like.
One dialogue choice that I haven't tried because I would feel like a capital B is when Rebecca asks Clem if she wants to feel the baby move in her tummy. I think one of the options is "Eww, gross" or something like that. I just couldn't do it even though I disliked her in the last episode. Plus bonus points for female bonding moment!
I can' choose it either, even though I really want to! Clem probably had a traumatic experience with Christa's baby, so it kind of stands to reason that she might find the whole thing rather disgusting/frightening.
But the "Sure, can I?" option is just too damn adorable, proving that the little kid within Clementine isn't completely dead. It also feels like a way to formally make peace with Rebecca after she extends an olive branch during the walk to the mountains.