Would Lily still have shot Carley/Doug if......

edited April 2014 in The Walking Dead

Would Lily still have made the shot that killed Carley/Doug if her dad was still alive?
I think that she was under a lot of stress and depression from her dad dying in such a horrible way, that maybe she wasn't thinking as clearly. I think her dad's death has some affect on her shooting the gun.

Comments

  • Yeah, but Kenny....Alt text

  • Yeah she probably wouldnt but how would Carley or Doug help out in Season 2? they were side characters we didnt really need them

  • Noooooo carley was amazing!

    bobjoeshmoe posted: »

    Yeah she probably wouldnt but how would Carley or Doug help out in Season 2? they were side characters we didnt really need them

  • Fuck Doug.

    JPAssini posted: »

    Fuck Carley.

  • Fuck Carley.

    Rylee posted: »

    Noooooo carley was amazing!

  • You wish,

    JPAssini posted: »

    Fuck Carley.

  • [removed]

    You wish,

  • Your probably right. If her dad was there she would have probably been more controlled, and less stressed, and depressed. So she probably wouldn't go as far as killing someone, but maybe kicking someone out. But hey. It was a good twist, and made the game more interesting so its fine with me. Still. I wish the romance of Carley and Lee could have went on a little bit longer.

  • Fuck Wall street

    JPAssini posted: »

    Fuck Carley.

  • Lee deserved better

    Your probably right. If her dad was there she would have probably been more controlled, and less stressed, and depressed. So she probably wo

  • Yeah, I wish there actually was an outcome where Larry lived. I was hoping I could do something in the story to convince that Lee wasn't a bad guy.

  • What about if lee and lilly found out that Larry and carley were........ yeah that EXPLAINS EVERYTHING

  • Your saying he deserved better then Carley? I think she was good enough.

    Saltlick123 posted: »

    Lee deserved better

  • No carley was fine, but lee deserved better treatment from Larry and he deserved a better fate...

    Your saying he deserved better then Carley? I think she was good enough.

  • vinceforprez2016

    Saltlick123 posted: »

    Fuck Wall street

  • Larry would have just punched Ben.

  • Nah, nobody would've been shot. She might have kicked Ben to the curb, but that's about it.

  • What's going on anymore?

    vinceforprez2016

  • Hmm, yeah. I wonder how the situation might have gone if Larry was still alive to see it. Lilly probably would have still shot Carley/Doug and Larry would be shocked as well but maybe still defend her, also we probably would have had a choice to kick them both out or just Lilly.

  • Its the power of carley, thats what.

    HarjKS posted: »

    What's going on anymore?

Sign in to comment in this discussion.