What did you guys choose [Obvious Spoilers ahead]

So, the Episode is FINALLY out on Steam, and it KICKED ASS!

Seriously, I think this was the best Episode EVER!

It all was so unexpected, and with that I mean ALL of it.

Reggie's death was a shock, just..wtf?!

That was the moment I wanted Carver to die. Like, really die. No fucking around, just killing him.

Alvin's death...so sad... :'(

And Troy's death felt SO justified...what a (dickless) dick...he deserved every second of his suffering.

#fucktroy

But anyway, now..what did you choose in the Episode?

Here's what I did:

1. Helped Sarah with her chores? - Helped Sarah, it was the right thing to do imo...poor girl

2. Told Bonnie about Luke? - I actually didn't think about it and just told her. She seemed to be alright after all, and I was right.

3. Admitted to have stolen the walkie talkies? - I did, and instantly regretted it. It was what I would have done if I had been Lee...(feels). Luckily, Kenny stepped in. I guess Carver actually would have killed Clem, he was seriously fucked up. SICK IN THE HEAD!

4. Watched Kenny kill Carver? - That was the toughest decision of all, for me. I SO wanted to see him die, but on the other hand didn't want CLEM to see it. In the end, my 'egoism' won. Wish I hadn't stayed. Clem AND me are going to have fucking nightmares about Carver's eye flipping out his skull...(actually, maybe only I will have nightmares)

5. Chopped of Sarita's arm? - I sure did. I saw her get bit, then Clem standing there looking at the walker taking a chomp in horror, and was like:
'Do it, Clem!!!'
And luckily, I got the choice to do so. I didn't hesitate.

So, what did YOU guys do? Did you also stay with Kenny and watched Carver get some of the crowbar?
Did you chop of Sarita's arm?
Also, how did you treat the people? I was an absolutey dick to Carver and Troy as much as possible. I told Troy to not kick me, and told Carver he was a murderer and wished Kenny had killed him.
And I also told Luke to fucking shoot him.
And I actually grinned when Troy lost his manhood...he couldn't even pee himself...poor guy (jk, what a dick)
I also shed a tear at Carlos' death. Poor Sarah, just so fucked up...actually, half of the Episode was fucked up.

And I loved it!
«1

Comments

  • Agree with everything and made the same choices :D
  • I made the same choices except I didn't tell Bonnie about Luke...not sure why I guess I was just trying to be secretive.
  • I have almost the same choices as you. Almost because I walk away from Carver when Kenny was going to kill him.
  • In the end, I wished I had done that too. Clem (and me) didn't have to see THAT shit
    Tewudin posted: »

    I have almost the same choices as you. Almost because I walk away from Carver when Kenny was going to kill him.

  • 1. I helped Sarah with her chores, too. I was afraid she was going to try to hurt herself with those shears.
    2. I kept it from Bonnie. I didn't want Clem to play her hand too soon. Who knows what Bonnie would say if Carver threatened her?
    3. I tried to deceive Carver by saying that I found it, but then Kenny stepped up and said that he took it. I felt terrible about it. I didn't expect him to take the blame like that, and he paid heavily for it.
    4. I watched, but I don't regret it. I think that if you're willing to support the decision to execute someone, you should be willing to not turn away when it happens.
    5. Heck, yeah. Let's just hope it works. I was afraid of the fresh blood being bait for the walkers though. It seems like they all jumped on Carlos after he was shot. I'm not sure if it was the noise or the smell of fresh blood that drew them in to attack Carlos. I hope Sarita ends up okay.
  • Yeah. I didn't even consider Clementine to stay there. I was like "No Carver! Sometimes she has to do what needs to be done but she doesn't need to watch it if it isn't necessary."

    In the end, I wished I had done that too. Clem (and me) didn't have to see THAT shit

  • MusicBoxMusicBox Banned
    edited May 2014
    1. Helped Sarah with her chores? - Helped her, didn't care about what Carver might think at all, the poor girl was in need of help.

    2. Told Bonnie about Luke? - I wanted to trust her but at that moment didn't trust her enough to tell her.

    3. Admitted to have stolen the walkie talkies? - Nope, was about to tell Carver he must've lost them when Kenny cut me off.

    4. Watched Kenny kill Carver? - I did. My Clem is nothing like Carver but she knows what kind of a person he was and that he needed to be stopped, running away from it just to shield herself from that was unnecessary in a world like that.

    5. Chopped of Sarita's arm? - First I panicked and didn't really know what to do but then I decided to cut it off before it spread, if she doesn't bleed out she'll be alive then.
  • edited May 2014
    Almost the same, just used a lot of silence options when talking to Carver for example, playing a badass with him or Troy seemed like a dumb idea after seeing what they can do. I also didn't chopped Saritas arm off, that was the hardest decision for me but I just didn't saw it as a good idea, there was already too much fresh blood and noise around already, I had a feeling she is done for anyways and trying to save her might get someone else killed too. After the Lee's arm fiasko Im not doing that again.
  • edited May 2014
    1. I helped Sarah with her chores. She was a wreck and I didn't want to leave her alone like that. Plus, it's not like all the plants were getting done anyway. Either I did all of mine and she did none of hers, or I did all of hers and got none of mine done. Sarah needed support, that seemed more important.

    2. I didn't tell Bonnie. It was mostly on impulse; the plan seemed to be looking shaky after I got pulled away from the others and I wanted to get back on track as fast as possible. In hindsight, I would have probably told her if I had paused and thought about it more carefully. I trusted her, I just didn't feel it was necessary at the time.

    3. I didn't tell Carver about the Walkie-Talkie. I figured if I said 'maybe you lost it' it would work better, as it's not technically a lie... he DID lose it, because I stole it. I wanted to keep the situation calm, and I felt that was the right way to do it at the time. Might have told the truth if I was given the choice again, but what's done is done.

    4. I watched. It wasn't any desire to see violence or anything... I just didn't want to let Kenny out of my sight again. Wouldn't have minded an option to stay and just not look while Kenny kills him. That said, I didn't believe seeing violence like that was going to affect Clementine anymore. She's already seen some bad stuff, I think the damage is already done.

    5. I chopped off Sarita's arm. It's possible she will bleed to death, but it's also possible she would have just turned anyway. I figured getting the arm off as soon as possible would give her a better chance.
  • edited May 2014
    Here are my choices:

    1. I helped Sarah. She was pretty badly shaken up and I wanted to help her, and I knew that leaving her alone would mean that she would get into more trouble because or her inability to relax and work.

    2. I told Bonnie. I figured I could trust her, since she expressed doubts about Carver and did nothing but treat Clementine with kindness.

    3. I admitted to the theft. This seemed like an easy choice to me since I figured that Carver wouldn't have gotten brutally violent towards a child if it mean that Telltale would be taking a big risk showing a fully grown man nearly beating a 11-year-old girl to death. Didn't matter either way, Kenny takes the blame no matter what.

    4. I did not watch Kenny kill Carver. I did at first until Sarita pushed me into leaving, and I realised just in time that it would mean that a child is watching a man being beaten to death. I didn't want that for Clementine, so I left.

    5. I chopped off Sarita's arm. My hardest choice yet. She was bitten by the hand and I didn't want to leave her, so I made the choice to chop off her arm. Her reaction felt traumatising, most shocking scene in Telltale's Walking Dead so far.
  • 1. Helped Sarah with her chores? - No, I didn't help her. If she couldn't manage on her own without her father then she was more useless than she was initially, plus I wasn't going to take the blame when Carver shows up and checks on the plants. I didn't expect him to murder Reggie, he should have pushed Sarah off instead.

    2. Told Bonnie about Luke? - Yes, I told her about Luke, but I was hoping she would force Clementine to stay instead of escape.

    3. Admitted to have stolen the walkie-talkies? - I tried, but Kenny stopped Clementine anyway. I wanted to keep everyone in that place.

    4. Watched Kenny kill Carver? - As soon as Carver's structured community fell to the walkers he was no longer of use to me. I didn't mind seeing him die, it was actually quite enjoying to see his eyeball pop out and his brains get mashed in.

    5. Chopped of Sarita's arm? - I chopped it off, like duh. Who would want to bring along a bitten survivor? That would have just caused more chaos later on. I honestly thought at first I was going to have the choice of either killing the walker and leaving her behind, and if I had to leave her behind then I would.
  • You would have liked to see Sarah die? Wow. But alright, your choice to hate her of course
    The_MCB posted: »

    1. Helped Sarah with her chores? - No, I didn't help her. If she couldn't manage on her own without her father then she was more useless tha

  • Yes, she was too much trouble honestly. Would you honestly keep a person like that around? Sheltered and unable to remain calm in tense situations? Having a person like that around is a death sentence in an apocalypse like this.

    You would have liked to see Sarah die? Wow. But alright, your choice to hate her of course

  • edited May 2014
    Not necessarily. I see your point, and I might think different if Sarah was an adult.

    But not like this, with Sarah only being 15, and having no idea how the world is now
    The_MCB posted: »

    Yes, she was too much trouble honestly. Would you honestly keep a person like that around? Sheltered and unable to remain calm in tense situations? Having a person like that around is a death sentence in an apocalypse like this.

  • Alvin went out like a fucking bad ass rest in peace my man :(
  • edited May 2014
    essentially the same choices. I thought that by staying behind I could prevent Kenny from doing it, so I ended up frantically trying to find a way to back out. Just had to cut off Sarita's arm to at least give her a chance, but that appears to have gone judging by the preview. Alvin died in my Episode 2 so I didn't see what happened to him. Was his death sad?
  • edited May 2014
    Yes, his death is VERY sad

    He sacrifices himself for Clem, because he realizes he can't come with them (Carver beat him up so hard he could barely walk)

    He sat down in Carver's chair, then a guard comes in and shoots him in the chest, and (I think) sees Clementine fleeing.

    Before the guard can do anything, Alvin shoots him in the chest.

    EDIT: And he also gives a really sad speech before being shot.

    'Look out for my girls. I'm sure it will be a girl...' and another line I don't remember

    Then he dies, and Clem leaves him, grieving.
    Someguy12 posted: »

    essentially the same choices. I thought that by staying behind I could prevent Kenny from doing it, so I ended up frantically trying to find

  • Made all the same choices as you, OP, except I stayed quiet about the theft. I figured I'd fess up if Carver started threatening somebody too bad but then the beatdown commenced and I was like....dayum.
  • 1. Helped Sarah with her chores? - Yes, Sarah needed help and I honestly thought I'd have enough time to help her and then do my part of the "chores" too, screw Carver

    2. Told Bonnie about Luke? - I told her, she admitted to knowing Luke and basically regretting not going with him so I thought it was safe to to tell her

    3. Admitted to have stolen the walkie talkies? - Yes, I was about to admit it when Kenny covered for me and said he did it.

    4. Watched Kenny kill Carver? - No, Clementine (and myself) didn't need to see it. The guy was a bag of dicks, but I didn't want to prove Carver right that I was *anything* like him by sticking around

    5. Chopped of Sarita's arm? - Yes, because in blind panic I thought it might save her life, but the way she looked at me like I was a monster...IDK if I made the right choice
  • 1. Yes. She needed it.

    2. **NEVER** TRUST A JUNKIE

    3. "I found it" apparently didn't count as admitting to the theft. Kenny stopped it anyway.

    4. Yes, and why was there no "Give me the crowbar, Kenny, I want a turn" option? Then again, I opened with shooting Carver and told Luke to just shoot him. Evil Overlord's List Rule 4! Common sense! Every media ever! JUST. SHOOT. HIM!

    5. Yes. Had to be done.
  • 1. I did not help Sarah, I was hoping for her to be the one to get in trouble.

    2. I went out to talk to Kenny

    3. I admitted to stealing the Walkies because I was afraid Luke might have died at that point.

    4. Of course I watched it, even though I really liked Carver.

    5. I feel like I made a mistake, I really hope Sarita dies next episode. I chopped her arm off, but thinking back on it, I should have just killed the walker.
  • 1. Helped Sarah- she was a total wreck
    2. Told Bonnie about Luke- I figured she could be trusted because she had planned on leaving before
    3. Tried to admit to stealing the walkie talkies- didn't want anyone to be killed
    4. Watched Kenny kill Carver- great villain but a piece of shit, besides Clem has probably seen all kinds of things like that by now
    5. Chopped off Sarita's arm- I panicked and figured it was the only way to save her
  • 1, I helped Sarah with her chores, I felt sorry for her.
    2. Didn't tell Bonny about Luke. I the player truster her, but I figured Clem wouldn't entirely dare to do so yet.
    3. Didn't admit it. I tried the lie about Carver maybe losing them himself. My Clem felt pretty horrible about what happened.
    4. Watched Kenny kill Carver. Ooh yesss, and enjoyed every gory second of it.
    5. Chopped off Sarita's arm. I'd accidentally spoilered myself, otherwise I probably wouldn't have understood it was an option, but as it was it's the best shot at possibly saving her.
  • We made the same chooses! :)
  • edited May 2014
    1. Helped Sarah with her chores? - Helped Sarah. Why wouldn't I? Clem's a great friend.

    2. Told Bonnie about Luke? - Told her about him. I know she's a good person and it's always good to be honest.

    3. Admitted to have stolen the walkie talkies? - Yea.... I triple dotted that....I wish I said "Must've lost them..."

    4. Watched Kenny kill Carver? - This wasn't in my Clem's character so I didn't watch

    5. Chopped of Sarita's arm? - Of course. If you do it fast enough, you can save her. If I just killed the walker, she'd be dead for sure. I just didn't think about how she would react afterward :s She reacted the same way I would have. (I was honestly hoping she wouldn't faint with all those other walkers surrounding her.)
  • edited May 2014
    Guys, could you help? I chose to give up the walkie talkie , but at the end the choice said that I didn't! I know that this will be major in the next episode. Is there another way to change it, instead of playing it over?
  • edited May 2014
    Wasn't there Walker blood on the hatchet? Wouldn't that have got into Sarita's arm if you cut it off? I spared it hoping we could cut that thing off with something cleaner.
  • Those were my choices:

    1. Helped Sarah with her chores? - Of course I helped her, she is my friend and she was a wreck and needed the help! The slap was enough, I didn't want her to get into more trouble for not doing her chores.

    2. Told Bonnie about Luke? - I did, she seemed trustworthy and nice and she was about to leave the camp before, so I dunno, I wanted to give her another chance to really leave this time.

    3. Admitted to have stolen the walkie talkies? - Yes, I did. I mean, it was I who stole them and didn't want anyone else to get in trouble for my theft... Hah, didn't get as planned tho :|

    4. Watched Kenny kill Carver? - That was a really hard decision. I didn't really want Clem to see that, but on the other hand I was feeling really sadistic and after what he did to Alvin and Reggie... Carver deserved it and I watched.

    5. Chopped of Sarita's arm? - Didn't even had to think about this, I dit it. As soon as I saw the walker biting her (that scene really freaked me out tbh) I knew that I was going to chop her arm of. But now? I'm not really sure if that was the right decision... What if she dies because the fresh blood attracts the walkers and they all attack her? Maybe it would have been better to get away from the zombies and THEN chop her arm of... But maybe that would've been too late, hm :/
  • Blood and a zombie's bite are different my friend.
    Twistee posted: »

    Wasn't there Walker blood on the hatchet? Wouldn't that have got into Sarita's arm if you cut it off? I spared it hoping we could cut that thing off with something cleaner.

  • Helped with chores.

    Told Bonnie about Luke. I trust her.

    I was going to admit but then Kenny stepped in... Shortly after I restrained Sarita, because helping Kenny would only make matters worse.

    Didn't watch him kill Carver. I tried to let him live but NOPE. I watched the Carver death if you watch and I'm glad I left.

    Chopped the arm!
  • 1. I shot Sarah.

    2. Told Bonnie about Luke, then shot her.

    3. Shot the walkie-talkies.

    4. Watch Kenny kill Carver, then shot Kenny.

    5. I shot Sarita.

    Lee taught me well.
  • Infected blood is infected blood, I'm pretty sure if Walker blood gets in your system you're pretty much screwed.

    She'll probably die from the blood loss anyway, or the herd will smell her fresh blood - Which could lead to her possible death.
    xeliosx posted: »

    Blood and a zombie's bite are different my friend.

  • heh yeah, much better than the episode 2 way lol :P

    Alvin went out like a fucking bad ass rest in peace my man :(

  • You're right. Sadly it looks like she won't make it.
    Twistee posted: »

    Infected blood is infected blood, I'm pretty sure if Walker blood gets in your system you're pretty much screwed. She'll probably die from the blood loss anyway, or the herd will smell her fresh blood - Which could lead to her possible death.

  • edited May 2014
    1. I helped Sarah. She already received punishment that day, so I tried to avoid it this time.

    2. Told Bonnie. It seemed a whole lot easier to take a chance with her than to try to lie my way out that door.

    3. I tried to cover up the theft. Carver was going to hurt someone regardless, so I was hoping to at least keep the radio.

    4. I stayed to watch. At this point, I'm a bit tired of people jumping between putting Clem in harm's way when it suits them, and shielding her when they get a pang of conscience.

    5. I killed the zombie. I know time is important when it comes to these things, but chopping off her arm in the middle of a herd seemed like the wrong time to do it. She would either draw more walkers with all that fresh blood or bleed to death before anything could be done.
  • 1. Helped Sarah with her chores.
    2. Told Bonnie about Luke.
    3. Didn't admit to stealing the walkies.
    4. Yes, I watched Kenny kill Carver, and I loved every part of it.
    5. Of course I chopped off Sarita's arm. After the like five minute slow motion thing of her hand getting bit I'm like "yeah, there's pretty much no other choice".
  • i cut saritas arm off and i was laughing.
  • 1. Helped Sarah with her chores? - I don't know why, but I didn't. I was like "better do my work, he's gonna be pissed if he sees I didn't do it" and right after I clicked it I paused and... "WHY THE FUCK DID I DO THAT."

    And then the whole Reggie thing happened and I was yelling at my screen "REGGIE NO IT WAS MY FAULT. Not his. My fault. My fault. My fault. Don't do anything to him don't do anything to him don't FUCKING- NOOOOO"

    2. Told Bonnie about Luke? - Yeah. I didn't see why not. Bonnie didn't seem like she was going to reveal the plan, and she seems like a good person.

    3. Admitted to have stolen the walkie talkies? - This episode was basically me yelling at the screen "IT WAS MY FAULT IT WAS MY FAULT IT WAS MY FAULT" so. Yeah. But Kenny just had to interrupt and... uugh.

    4. Watched Kenny kill Carver? - HELL NO. I didn't want to see it, I didn't want Clem to see it. I figured that neither Kenny nor Rebecca would hold any grudges so I just went with the rest of the group. And I'm glad I did that because, according to some people it was BRUTAL.

    5. Chopped of Sarita's arm? - I saw her getting bitten (fun fact: I thought it was Sarah at first) and immediately thought "We have to cut it off." I did it as soon as the option appeared.

    I treated them not being very aggressive. Every time Troy appeared I was afraid that he'd hit me so I went along (I stared back at him). And Carver... he just scares me.

    I also told Luke to shoot Carver. We were just wasting time at that point, and I just wanted to get the hell out of there.
  • yeah I read it up on the wikia, he was one of the best in the cabin group

    Yes, his death is VERY sad He sacrifices himself for Clem, because he realizes he can't come with them (Carver beat him up so hard he c

  • edited May 2014
    I feel like I'm the only one who didn't chop Saritas arm. I thought if I cut it she'd probably die right there, and it was on her wrist so that bite probably gives her an hour before it's too late to amputate. The rest of mine are the same as yours.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.