Yeah, now that I look back that makes more sense than what I previously thought..his heart seemed to be in the right place, but I still think staying even one more day would've been a much bigger risk than leaving immediately. Who knows who would've been offed next for acting "out of line"?
About luke suggesting leaving people behind he was more saying if it came down to that as everyone was insisting they leave then and there heck luke even stated that maybe they should wait and rest up
How do you figure? Kenny wasn't the one who fired the shot that winged Carlos and Sarita is responsible for her own carelessness amidst the … morechaos.
Luke isn't responsible for Kenny losing an eye, either (Kenny chose to protect Clementine and took the beating that resulted in that).
"luke may turn his back on us"
Just like how he didn't go through hell and back to get to Carver's camp and rescue us when he could have just walked away?
- Kenny is trying to protect Clementine at all costs
- Kenny tried to rescue the group in Episode 2
- Kenny took a life-threatening so Clementine wouldn't get in trouble
- Kenny trusts Clementine (in my play-through)
- Kenny risked his life for Clementine in Season 1
- Kenny cares for family more than anything, and I feel like he considers Clementine family after the events of Season 1
- Kenny offered to take care of Clementine in Season 1: Episode 1
- Kenny's temper can be a detrimental factor to the overall group
- Luke gave clementine something to eat in Episode 1
- Luke traveled from the lodge, to Carver's camp, on foot, to save the group
- Luke didn't fully trust Clementine in Episode 1
- Luke caused Kenny to take a life-threatening beating because of food (it should have been a heroic capture)
- Luke disappeared at the end of Episode 2 (maybe if he didn't run, the events at the Lodge wouldn't have led to the group arriving at Carver's camp)
- Luke was going to leave some people behind
- Luke disappears again (trailer)
Kenny's pros outweigh Luke's cons, so I'd have to side with Kenny.
If that were the case, Kenny would have had no reason to stop Clementine from exposing her guilt. The fact that he intervened and took the blame showed he had a good idea that Carver would not let such a thing slide without severe repercussions - so Kenny took the blame to protect Clementine in the off chance that Carver didn't keep his word (which he didn't - and I doubt he'd have gone any lighter on Clementine if she was the one who came forth).
Kenny is a very reckless man. Kenny can be selfish at times. Kenny fights horribly.
But Kenny is a family man. Now that he sees Clem as his family, he is willing to protect her at all costs-including taking a beating that fucked his eye up without bitching about it. I can kind of see him reversing the past, die for his family instead of watching them die in future episodes.
Couple of things...
1) Who's to say he never tried to track them down? The last time Kenny saw Omid and Christa was either on the rooft… moreops (if Ben was traveling with them) or from within a building (after rescuing Christa). Outside of the Marsh House, Crawford and the house they had been holed up in, (all of which were swarming with walkers) he'd have no idea where to start looking for them after that; and Georgia is a big state.
Given his personality, Kenny probably searched high and low for them; and eventually came to the conclusion that they had perished.
2) While freeing himself of his binds, Kenny mentioned being a prisoner. So, at some point, he had been captured and escaped.
So,he didn't just hole himself up in a store and gave up until Sarita arrived.
Kenny lost an eye for Clem. As long as Sarita's still around, I'm saving him. (If she's not, and he's really and truly broken because of it - maybe I'd choose Luke instead just because I don't want Kenny to have to live with that all over again. Lord knows he's suffered enough already.)
Who knows - a lot could happen before that kind of decision comes up, but at least at this point, I'd pick Kenny. I love Luke, I really do, but Kenny lost a damn eye to protect Clem. He's proven himself trustworthy enough to be her caretaker in my book.
Despite Kenny being my bro from the first game, I'd been on the fence about this until this episode. Not anymore though.
Kenny, he was defending Clem all the way.
Luke, however did a huge mistake on his part of the episode, which costs Kenny's eye. I'm still giving him a chance till the end of the season.
"luke may turn his back on us"
Just like how he didn't go through hell and back to get to Carver's camp and rescue us when he could have just walked away?
Kenny, without a doubt.
I have nothing against Sarah - but the girl is more of a liability and is absolutely incapable of taking care o… moref herself. I'd rather have someone who's got my back in a battle; not someone who increases my chances of getting killed in said battle.
Couple of things...
1) Who's to say he never tried to track them down? The last time Kenny saw Omid and Christa was either on the rooft… moreops (if Ben was traveling with them) or from within a building (after rescuing Christa). Outside of the Marsh House, Crawford and the house they had been holed up in, (all of which were swarming with walkers) he'd have no idea where to start looking for them after that; and Georgia is a big state.
Given his personality, Kenny probably searched high and low for them; and eventually came to the conclusion that they had perished.
2) While freeing himself of his binds, Kenny mentioned being a prisoner. So, at some point, he had been captured and escaped.
So,he didn't just hole himself up in a store and gave up until Sarita arrived.
Actually Luke was suggesting that they have a chance to recover while everyone disagreed and wanted to go tonight. When Luke explained that … moreif we go tonight then we'll have to leave folks, everyone got pissed at him. To be fair, if it wasn't for Luke's plan failing the way it did and Kenny getting beat up, Bonnie wouldn't have helped them escape. Kenny's plan was to draw the herd to the camp and... that's it. "We improvise". Without Bonnie they wouldn't have anyone to spring them out and a lot more people would've died.
if u r kept in this situation in next episode ... whom will you save ?? this is not test for whose love is great or something ... this is the question for survival
Why should we choose something like this? Seriously, ive noticed since episode 2 that there has been a "war" over wich one Clem will show more preference.
Every character has their qualities and flaws and both care for Clem. Just deal with it.
Definitely Luke. I know iIl get tons of down votes especially after Kenny's heroics in Epi 3 but lets be rational: Kenny is way too emotiona… morel and head strong. He would have easily died in the beginning if the truck didn't knock him out. He is very bold and although that has helped him so far, it honestly can not work eveytime. Luke is younger, level headed, and cares for Clementine. Ill agree that Kenny loves Clem and they have a great connection but Luke is a much safer bet.
Luke trust Clem.
He didn't wanna Clem do always the work.
"Wait a second! She is the plan?"
Luke didn't underestimated Clem. I think Luke's big role come out in episode 4.
"Where the fuck is Luke?" Episode 4 trailer
About luke suggesting leaving people behind he was more saying if it came down to that as everyone was insisting they leave then and there heck luke even stated that maybe they should wait and rest up
Maybe it's the dialogue trees I've chosen but that's not even a second thought, Kenny of course. These people kidnapped Clementine and locke… mored her in a shed to let her die of impending fever or infection then when she cleaned everything up in time they forced her to run away from Carver with them, when it would have probably just been better had she went off on her own. In my cut scenes and dialogue with Luke she never warmed up to him, he was the root of all her problems.
These people have been holding her back from day 1. Kenny is the only person she is remotely loyal to and that dates back to Season 1. When he dies, and he probably will, she should go off on her own and be a hermit until these bag of bones start rotting and thinning out in the July heat every year.
Really?
Not again..
How much this "Kenny vs Luke", "Kenny or Luke" threads? We need all of this? It's gonna make fights on the for… moreum. I don't like it. Almost all people can accept the other people option, so we're so fucked up in every time.
Kenny. I genuinely like Luke, he's a good guy, but I don't necessarily agree with him on everything. He also seems shifty regrading his deci… moresions like trying to back out of escaping from Carver at the last minute. Yes, members were weak, but Carver was going to increase guards and security after finding Luke, they got lucky that carver was sidetracked.And,although, I trust Luke, I don't trust him to make the hard decisions.For example, when he had Carver at gun point he wouldn't shoot. Kenny had to do it. Maybe some one would have rather tied him up,but it seemed pretty obvious to me that Carver was crazy, and didn't feel much regret for his actions. Once he was freed he would have just gone back after the group. Shooting was the only way to ensure the safety of the group indefinitely. Luke couldn't make that decision, Kenny could. Lastly, he's not very dependable. He managed to get caught nearly destroying the whole plan. Also, it seems as d… [view original content]
I wasn't a big fan of Kenny in S1 or S2E2 (though I was happy he was alive), but I've definitely come around with him a lot since this episo… morede, and my Clem agrees with him a lot more than my Lee did. But, I still really like Luke and feel he hasn't yet been given the fleshing out and time in the spotlight to make this a fair fight (in terms of who to pick). I'm holding out hope that they do more with Luke in E4 especially, so it's more of a contest.
At this moment, I still don't know who I'd go with, it was Luke before this episode, now I'm a little more indecisive (but still leaning toward Luke I suppose), but we'll see what the rest of the season holds.
Kenny, without a doubt in my mind. You know a man who is willing to make the hard decisions no one else wants to make (i.e. - killing Larry … moreinstead of risking his coming back as a walker) and puts his own life at risk on numerous occasions to save someone else (helping Ben/Christa, taking a severe beating for Clementine) you know that's a man you can count on.
Kenny is a very reckless man. Kenny can be selfish at times. Kenny fights horribly.
But Kenny is a family man. Now that he sees Clem as hi… mores family, he is willing to protect her at all costs-including taking a beating that fucked his eye up without bitching about it. I can kind of see him reversing the past, die for his family instead of watching them die in future episodes.
Not sure. I think I will wait for Luke's moment to shine and give him a chance. For now I would say Kenny though, hard decision. I honestly hope that both will live (I know it is Telltales, but I can't help it) I like them both.
Comments
Luke isn't responsible for Kenny losing an eye, either (Kenny chose to protect Clementine and took the beating that resulted in that).
- Kenny tried to rescue the group in Episode 2
- Kenny took a life-threatening so Clementine wouldn't get in trouble
- Kenny trusts Clementine (in my play-through)
- Kenny risked his life for Clementine in Season 1
- Kenny cares for family more than anything, and I feel like he considers Clementine family after the events of Season 1
- Kenny offered to take care of Clementine in Season 1: Episode 1
- Kenny's temper can be a detrimental factor to the overall group
- Luke gave clementine something to eat in Episode 1
- Luke traveled from the lodge, to Carver's camp, on foot, to save the group
- Luke didn't fully trust Clementine in Episode 1
- Luke caused Kenny to take a life-threatening beating because of food (it should have been a heroic capture)
- Luke disappeared at the end of Episode 2 (maybe if he didn't run, the events at the Lodge wouldn't have led to the group arriving at Carver's camp)
- Luke was going to leave some people behind
- Luke disappears again (trailer)
Kenny's pros outweigh Luke's cons, so I'd have to side with Kenny.
But Kenny is a family man. Now that he sees Clem as his family, he is willing to protect her at all costs-including taking a beating that fucked his eye up without bitching about it. I can kind of see him reversing the past, die for his family instead of watching them die in future episodes.
Who knows - a lot could happen before that kind of decision comes up, but at least at this point, I'd pick Kenny. I love Luke, I really do, but Kenny lost a damn eye to protect Clem. He's proven himself trustworthy enough to be her caretaker in my book.
Despite Kenny being my bro from the first game, I'd been on the fence about this until this episode. Not anymore though.
Because of this, I would let Kenny die regardless who it stood between (except Rebecka).
If you 'neg' this because YOU happen to love Kenny, I take that as an acknowledgement that he is, indeed, a bitch.