Good Storyline(s) for Luke?

Hey Guys, I just think that his storyline was done rather badly this episode. I still think about what exactly I would love to see from him. You can write your ideas and storylines here, of course.

Not sure, maybe he could find and protect Christa (without knowing who she is) and then bring her to the group. Reuniting Clem and Christa. Hmm.

Anyone any ideas? I am rather idealess right now.
«1

Comments

  • I've been thinking about this a LOT because I love Luke, and I feel he was underused in Episode three. They were building him up rival Kenny in being with Clem, and they didn't make that connection a lot. Like when she wad talking about Lee with the walker guts, I wanted SOMETHING from Luke because we told him about Lee.

    Now, going forward, I want more Luke backstory. As much as I love him, his death (lets face it, it's the walking dead) won't shock me unless we know more about him.
  • I agree 100 percent.

    I've been thinking about this a LOT because I love Luke, and I feel he was underused in Episode three. They were building him up rival Kenny

  • To simplify my main complaint with this episode, Kenny got more character development than he needed to in the most vital scenes in the ep. I dont just care about Kenny, I'm interested in other characters like Luke or Nick. Not saying that I hate Kenny, I am saying that they are wasting the potential of some very interesting characters that barely got any screentime.*cough* NICK *cough*

    I agree 100 percent.

  • But Nick was already one of the most important characters of episode 2. He's my favorite character of this season but I think it's ok for the spotlight to focus on others a bit more...

    To simplify my main complaint with this episode, Kenny got more character development than he needed to in the most vital scenes in the ep.

  • Good point! This season is already not so great with character development! I do think it would have been better (not just for Luke, but other folks as well) to not use 'almost all the screentime' and 'almost all the good scenes' on Kenny, since he is the only one which was having enough development already. It would have made season 2 richer on sympathising with others. I love Kenny though.

    To simplify my main complaint with this episode, Kenny got more character development than he needed to in the most vital scenes in the ep.

  • This. As much as I would love to see him have some badass time in the spotlight, I think first things first, we need to learn more about where the dude has been and where he's going and what he thinks about all of it. And maybe hear him talk about why he clicked with Clementine so fast and find out it's connected to his past or something.

    I just really hope he's not sidelined again in episode four.

    I've been thinking about this a LOT because I love Luke, and I feel he was underused in Episode three. They were building him up rival Kenny

  • Amen.
    lotrabc posted: »

    This. As much as I would love to see him have some badass time in the spotlight, I think first things first, we need to learn more about whe

  • Make him not disappear every second and give him a personality. That's my two cents.
  • Luke was being built up good, and then the idiot writer behind Episode 3 destroyed him.

    I've been thinking about this a LOT because I love Luke, and I feel he was underused in Episode three. They were building him up rival Kenny

  • edited May 2014
    I dont agree sorry. People say he didn't have a good storyline because he almost didn't appear, so what? He came back for the group, managed to hide for quite a bit, you think that's not enough?

    I already know i'm getting a lot of thumbsdown for writing this but one thing is storyline, another thing is wishing for your favorite character to appear all the time.
  • edited May 2014
    I like Luke. I feel his story should last until at least Episode 5. If he has to die, let it be a hero death saving Clem, Sarah, Rebecca, Etc.
    Honestly though, if Nick survives Episode 2, perhaps Luke in Episode 5 will get bit trying to save his friend Nick, but, Nick dies anyways. Now, the "Hero in vain" Luke is bit and will die.
  • Let him get bitten , and then just move on .Give Jane, Bonnie, and Mike and any of the 400 days characters a chance step up and become leaders of the group.
  • edited May 2014
    Give Luke a fight scene, I can only remember luke killing 2 walker's
    (1st time )Luke kills walker and saving Clem in the wood's in episode 1
    (2nd time) luke Kill walker before going on the bridge in episode 2
    Luke killed no living person or undead in episode 3

    Luke need's more fight scenes
  • edited May 2014
    I disagree. I would not like to see Luke all the time. I am 'rather' pleased about the last episodes, one thing I did not like was that Luke got no good storyline. No, I do not mean him getting no screentime - I mean him getting no STORYLINE! Being away for a few days and then come back is not really a storyline, is it? Or at least a rather boring one. I would have actually liked it better, if Luke came only in the last minutes back, but then at least did something important (like protecting Clem, killing Carver, ect...)

    So no, I would not like for him to appear all the time. I would like for him to have scenes that are important! That is the small, but fine difference.
    Kladeos posted: »

    I dont agree sorry. People say he didn't have a good storyline because he almost didn't appear, so what? He came back for the group, managed

  • edited May 2014
    I would not approve of that ;)
    Cowpie posted: »

    Let him get bitten , and then just move on .Give Jane, Bonnie, and Mike and any of the 400 days characters a chance step up and become leaders of the group.

  • edited May 2014
    Luke has killed a couple walkers, but never a person.
    He doesn't need fight scenes. This is part of his "Soft" personality they had going for him. This is also shown when Clementine tells him he killed that dog and Luke scolds her for it.

    Luke is simply a soft, passive, farmboy who is trying to keep his friends alive. This is like how Nick is a friendly, but cocky, with a temper, farmboy who also wants to keep his friends alive.
    Order 66 posted: »

    Give Luke a fight scene, I can only remember luke killing 2 walker's (1st time )Luke kills walker and saving Clem in the wood's in episo

  • edited May 2014
    That's a valid point. But i dunno, in my opinion, i enjoyed the way he appeared in this episode.

    I actually have those feelings towards Nick, how he almost never participated in the group's conversations and when he did was just to say he agreed with Luke.

    I disagree. I would not like to see Luke all the time. I am 'rather' pleased about the last episodes, one thing I did not like was that Luke

  • edited May 2014
    There is nothing wrong with you enjoying his appearance in this episode. We all have different opinions. :)

    I agree with you that Nick got sooo much wasted potential as well. (Maybe even more than Luke) The problem with him is that he is dead in some games, which is why they can't give him important storylines anymore. That is probably why Luke is 'overshadowing' him.
    Kladeos posted: »

    That's a valid point. But i dunno, in my opinion, i enjoyed the way he appeared in this episode. I actually have those feelings toward

  • That's true. Let's hope in the next episode he participates more.
  • I actually didn't see him after things went wrong when Sarah screamed or in the preview. Hope he's okay.
  • I do hope to see more of Nick myself. Still doubt that they give him much screentime though :(

    I do not think that he would get such a stupid 'off-screen' dead, that would really show me just how bad the writing got. I think he is ok and that his death is going to be heroic. I hope.
    Kladeos posted: »

    I actually didn't see him after things went wrong when Sarah screamed or in the preview. Hope he's okay.

  • edited May 2014
    Yeah.

    With Ben i actually think they made a good job, he had some nice interactions after that option of letting him die, he didn't seem like an "outside" character. Maybe they can do the same with Nick.

    I do hope to see more of Nick myself. Still doubt that they give him much screentime though :( I do not think that he would get such a

  • I agree. It worked very well for Ben, why not for Nick?
    Kladeos posted: »

    Yeah. With Ben i actually think they made a good job, he had some nice interactions after that option of letting him die, he didn't seem like an "outside" character. Maybe they can do the same with Nick.

  • Luke needs a scene like Clem had at the end of "All That Remains." We should be able to ask him all the questions and hear what his backstory his. A scene where Luke is probably badly injured, and in order to distract him from pain, Clem encourages him to describe his history before and during the start of the zombie apocalypse.

    I always resort to bringing up how Nick is the only S2 person who had been explored this way, and that's why his character is the most developed, yet he's the first determinant character among the whole Cabin Crew? Was his character developed just so that he could die early on? If so, then where's Alvin's backstory? We heard Pete before he got bitten. Where's Sarita's backstory other than "she found Kenny?" We know more about Jane from her subtle behaviors alone, and she's only present in the last half of Ep. 3!
  • I think this would be cool. Maybe Luke is dying from internal bleeding and Clementine is trying her best to keep him comfortable and distracted.
  • I don't think they overdid Kenny; the problem was that they underrepresented everyone else. Gotta remember that there were no passive hub scenes, and Kenny was the most active person in attempting escape, making it the most narratively sensible that he would do the most talking. Remember the state of the other potential main actors to drive the plot along (Alvin: KOd, Luke: fatigued to the point of collapse, Nick, Chronically depressed, Carlos, busy most of the episode tending Carver's (strangely) unseen wounded.

    They really need to add more Nick though, you are right. It's like he is dead no matter what you do at this rate of communication. They really need to add a great quiet talking scene for those of us who enjoy his character before he bites the dust.

    I really hope if he dies, he ends up in the same situation as Pete. Clem would be all like: "I promised Pete I'd take care of you." Hopefully by this point Nick comes to terms with his depression and can die with some sense of satisfaction. But this is the walking dead, so he'll probably die like most people: alone, weak, cold, and scared, Or suddenly, and without warning.

    I think for Nick to go full arc though he has to go out like 'uncle' Pete does if you save him in episode 1.

    To simplify my main complaint with this episode, Kenny got more character development than he needed to in the most vital scenes in the ep.

  • Luke may be unwilling to kill the living, but he is far from soft or passive. He's pretty damn active and takes leadership of the group when Pete kicks the bucket, and also tries to save the group in episode 3. That is to say, he is nowhere near as active or dominant as Kenny, but Luke's no pushover.
    cameroncr95 posted: »

    Luke has killed a couple walkers, but never a person. He doesn't need fight scenes. This is part of his "Soft" personality they had going

  • Good points.
    Qipoi posted: »

    I don't think they overdid Kenny; the problem was that they underrepresented everyone else. Gotta remember that there were no passive hub sc

  • I would like something like that.
  • edited May 2014
    I'd just like to know Luke's back story. I was hoping Episode 3 might give some of that out but it didn't. If they ever bring it up [which I really hope they do] that's something I'd like them to dive into. Besides, I wanna know if my hunch is right if he had any younger siblings before.

    But for plot points on what I'd want to see with him, hm...where he doesn't die? An anti death shield maybe? XD

    Being serious, Luke's in a bad condition right now because he hasn't eaten or slept in days, so I'd dare Telltale to take that a step further, like maybe Luke gets shot or wounded somehow and they gotta help him, and without Carlos around that would be a serious problem. But it would mean for the most part, Luke would be restricted in what he can do, at least in a 'fight off walkers' sense, time that with Rebecca on the verge of having a baby and walkers showing up, and that would be really, really bad news.

    But yeah back story, pretty please? It doesn't have to be deep, just a widdle something.
  • YESSSSSS! We know Kenny, we know what path he's headed on, we KNOW he misses Duck, I mean, he talked about him last episode!

    Why can't we spend that time hearing Nick tell some dumb story about Luke when they were kids?

    To simplify my main complaint with this episode, Kenny got more character development than he needed to in the most vital scenes in the ep.

  • Tbh, I want Luke to say, 'I had a little sister like you, once', yes, it'd be super cliche, but it would flesh him out a bit!
    lotrabc posted: »

    This. As much as I would love to see him have some badass time in the spotlight, I think first things first, we need to learn more about whe

  • I've said this somewhere else, bringing along an acclaimed TWAU writer wasn't a good idea. The guy who wrote the new season should have stuck around to OK everything!
    cameroncr95 posted: »

    Luke was being built up good, and then the idiot writer behind Episode 3 destroyed him.

  • That's it, we're getting him a goddam leash.
    Baldex posted: »

    Make him not disappear every second and give him a personality. That's my two cents.

  • This new guy is just going to kill the series. He needs to go away.

    I've said this somewhere else, bringing along an acclaimed TWAU writer wasn't a good idea. The guy who wrote the new season should have stuck around to OK everything!

  • I would like that, but I want him to LIVE at the end of it.. Hmm, maybe Clem and him are keeping watch together or something? idk, but I want backstory!
  • OH, I just had a thought!

    Maybe Luke could get badly injured and needs stitches so he chickens out and gets Clem to do it, and while she's doing it, as someone said above, she asks him about his past to distract him from the pain!
  • Can I write to Telltale and attach this post and ask them if I could write Luke's parts in Amid The Ruins? :P

    I've been thinking about this a LOT because I love Luke, and I feel he was underused in Episode three. They were building him up rival Kenny

  • He is a softie at heart. This episode was good for one thing, it was showing us a sleep deprived, hungry and tattered Luke almost giving up. We don't see him get fired up until he points that gun at Carver. He was prepared to take more crap from Carver because he felt so defeated. But that WASN'T explored further, like I wanted to talk to him one on one about it like we did with Nick!

    If this underdevelopment means he lives longer, then I'm cool with it.
  • He didn't want to be like Carver. Carver kills people who get in the way of his community. Luke doesn't want to ever be like that. If Carver is in the way of his and his groups survival, he doesn't want to kill to survive.
    cameroncr95 posted: »

    Luke has killed a couple walkers, but never a person. He doesn't need fight scenes. This is part of his "Soft" personality they had going

Sign in to comment in this discussion.