Nor did I, but was a rash action taken because we were surrounded. I figured that dispatching the walker was quicker and easier than trying to hack through her arm. Although I regretted my choice, time will tell - it might turn our better after all.
yeah, I didn't cut her arm either, it's pointless..the hatchet had walker blood and if we cut the arm or just the walker, Sarita'll die in the next episode I'm sure...and I don't want to make her last moments painful and armless
I don't know if this is still so one-sided, but back when I played S1 it was really one sided to save Shawn over Duck. I'm not going to lie,… more I also went for Shawn first, but I thought it was unusual to have saving a kid be the unpopular choice.
The huge one-sidedness of Carley over Doug was also odd, but she got waaay more screen time, was on the mission with you, reeked of love interest AND seemed more useful (marksmanship over... mechanical ability? I'm not sure what exactly they were trying to sell Doug as). I expected the choice to be more 50/50 when I first played through though...
I was surprised that it was split with killing the St. John brothers... popular to kill Danny but unpopular to kill Andy? I killed neither but it was strange to me that people were generally willing to kill one but not the other.
I also talked down Kenny on the train, don't know why that was unpopular...
Surprising to me that most players … [view original content]
Yeah I didn't get that either. To me, staying was only proving that Carver was right. I sure as hell wasn't going to give him that satisfact… moreion. My Clem will kill if necessary but I'm not going to turn her bloodthirsty and vindictive and revenge-obsessed. She didn't want nor need to see such an excessive death.
I killed BOTH of St.John brothers. I was surprised when I discovered that 75% of players spared Andy. I mean, really? The brothers killed Mark and served him to the group, "killed" Larry (while they didn't kill him directly the St.Johns are one of the reasons he died (Not counting Kenny)), most probably ate their staff, nearly killed Kenny, held Duck at a gunpoint, nearly killed Katjaa, hurt Clementine, and etc... Call me cruel, but those FUCKERS just had it coming.
Well to be fair, when you say the "I found it" option it counts as covering it up, which makes sense, but that was the first choice I saw and I chose it. It seemed like it wouldn't have been covering up the theft.
I was suprised that like 70% of people weren't going to come clean and show the walkie talkie to Carver when he was counting down.
I ch… moreose the "I got it" option without second thoughts.
Having him find it by himself would have been way worse than being truthful.
To me that was an easy choice because it's not like we have to worry about Clem dying right then and there. That's the reason I take the blame for everything. Clem's our player character so we know she'll come out alright in the end. We can't say the same for the other characters.
I was suprised that like 70% of people weren't going to come clean and show the walkie talkie to Carver when he was counting down.
I ch… moreose the "I got it" option without second thoughts.
Having him find it by himself would have been way worse than being truthful.
I think it was about doing it in front of Clementine. I killed one of them the first time around and the look on Clem's face, I had to go reload. I didn't want to harden her that much at that point.
I killed BOTH of St.John brothers. I was surprised when I discovered that 75% of players spared Andy. I mean, really? The brothers killed Ma… morerk and served him to the group, "killed" Larry (while they didn't kill him directly the St.Johns are one of the reasons he died (Not counting Kenny)), most probably ate their staff, nearly killed Kenny, held Duck at a gunpoint, nearly killed Katjaa, hurt Clementine, and etc... Call me cruel, but those FUCKERS just had it coming.
Im suprised people are so kind to some characters, like im surprised that not 100% of people watched Carver died, when i watched it i clapped, muahahahha and i didnt even realise how butt hurt Luke, Sarita and the rest of the group got when i said i was going to stay, i just wanted some fucking gore
The reason talking down Kenny was unpopular is because you have to choose pretty specific things to say to get him to stop the train, otherwise he'll just start fighting you.
I don't know if this is still so one-sided, but back when I played S1 it was really one sided to save Shawn over Duck. I'm not going to lie,… more I also went for Shawn first, but I thought it was unusual to have saving a kid be the unpopular choice.
The huge one-sidedness of Carley over Doug was also odd, but she got waaay more screen time, was on the mission with you, reeked of love interest AND seemed more useful (marksmanship over... mechanical ability? I'm not sure what exactly they were trying to sell Doug as). I expected the choice to be more 50/50 when I first played through though...
I was surprised that it was split with killing the St. John brothers... popular to kill Danny but unpopular to kill Andy? I killed neither but it was strange to me that people were generally willing to kill one but not the other.
I also talked down Kenny on the train, don't know why that was unpopular...
Surprising to me that most players … [view original content]
Yeah she will make it to the end but in what shape she will be in depends on our choices. I thought Carver would have beat the shit out of Clementine if she had come clean and that's why I tried to cover it up
To me that was an easy choice because it's not like we have to worry about Clem dying right then and there. That's the reason I take the bla… moreme for everything. Clem's our player character so we know she'll come out alright in the end. We can't say the same for the other characters.
I mean,Ben was kind of a "douche" and he let Clementine alone when they were surrounded by zombies.He did a lot of bad stuff but come on...Let him fall?I think that this is kind of inhumane...
Becca wasn't on her way to becoming a ruthless killer, she refuses if you ask her to kill Stephanie.
She was just a scared teenager trying to be tough in front of the adults.
80% people let go of Ben.
I mean,Ben was kind of a "douche" and he let Clementine alone when they were surrounded by zombies.He did a lot of bad stuff but come on...Let him fall?I think that this is kind of inhumane...
I don't know if this is still so one-sided, but back when I played S1 it was really one sided to save Shawn over Duck. I'm not going to lie,… more I also went for Shawn first, but I thought it was unusual to have saving a kid be the unpopular choice.
The huge one-sidedness of Carley over Doug was also odd, but she got waaay more screen time, was on the mission with you, reeked of love interest AND seemed more useful (marksmanship over... mechanical ability? I'm not sure what exactly they were trying to sell Doug as). I expected the choice to be more 50/50 when I first played through though...
I was surprised that it was split with killing the St. John brothers... popular to kill Danny but unpopular to kill Andy? I killed neither but it was strange to me that people were generally willing to kill one but not the other.
I also talked down Kenny on the train, don't know why that was unpopular...
Surprising to me that most players … [view original content]
To be honest, I don't see S2 Clem as someone else I'm trying to protect. That was S1. Now, like I did with Lee, I'm taking the choices I would personally take. This means, "What would I do in this situation?", not "What would innocent little Clem do in this situation?".
Well in ep 3 season 2 I thought that the majority of people would choose to walk away with Sarita, not to watch Kenny brutaly kill Carver, i… moret's crazy and I didn't want Clem to see this s**t, it's pointless...if Kenny wants me to leave - then I'll leave. I certanly didn't want to watch this murder...(well I replayed the episode later and watched it and it was kinda cool cuz a little, tiny piece of my soul wanted a revenge, but that don't make it right)
I know Carver was a bad man, really bad, but I don't see any reason for Clem to watch this "big show". Carver wanted that, to make her emotionless badass killer and I don't intend to make his last moments a little bit happier...so think whatever you want, I know that for me leaving with Sarita was the right thing.
idk, i was bro-team-kenny, and for me to have fought him i would have had to have lee say one of the options to basically initiate the fight. but like i said, i usually did what kenny wanted to do anyways because he thinks like me, kind of.
The reason talking down Kenny was unpopular is because you have to choose pretty specific things to say to get him to stop the train, otherwise he'll just start fighting you.
Telling Bonnie about Luke..
I was amazed to see I was in the major minority for not telling Bonnie about Luke. was like 29%..
I think… more most of us know from 400Days that Bonnie isnt exactly a bad-person, but the only thing Clem know's is Bonnie was a scout, got some food, then returned with Carver and the others with weapons and kidnapped the entire group.
Why would Clem give her information?? Sure Bonnie is acting nice, but what's to say she wouldnt run off and tell Carver??
By the end of the episode, I do trust Bonnie a little more, but at that time I didnt trust her at all..
If you help Sarah or not in harms way. I thought people would think like me and do my own work but they helped her instead. I thought it was time for her to man up
I made Clementine leave Lee behind instead of shoot him. Obviously it wouldn't really be Lee if he reanimated. The walkers technically are just dead bodies that are moving around. They can't think for themselves or have an kind of conscious or intelligent. Either way, Lee really would be dead. Plus, I still think that if you do make her shoot Lee, then she won't be able to do it (since the gun jerks to the left before the screen goes black). I'm surprised that so many people made her do that. She just saw her parents as walkers, then found out Lee was bitten, and then she has to go out and find Omid and Christa alone.
There was no way I was going to let that Season 1 bitten woman shoot herself....first off, because that's my gun and my bullet that I might need later, second because gunshots are crazy loud!
I saved Shawn over Duck because they made Duck so damned annoying! I think more people would have saved Duck if he'd been less of a weirdo. I was pretty glad when he went away and volunteered to do it myself.
I saved Carley over Doug and think most folks did because it did reek of love interest and that wouldn't have been a bad way to go. Plus she was just waaaayyyy cooler than Doug and seemed more useful to the group.
Not killing the cannibal brothers I don't get at all. THEY. WERE. TRYING. TO. EAT. YOU.
I cut Lee's arm off because I wanted to see how they'd handle doing that in terms of gameplay....I went back and reloaded the save both ways but used one-arm Lee as my final.
Oh..Well I think I remember correctly because I replayed Season 1 yesterday because I was bored (didn't finish the whole game) but I got to the one with Crawford and in the statistics it showed me that 80 percentage. =D
I agreed with Kenny on of all the big choices that have major impacts on your relationship with him, but I was constantly having petty arguments with him on almost everything else. When I went to talk to him on the train I was thinking about the situation and planned on being calm, but I lost my temper and impulsively chose to say something to him that I didn't even believe myself that initiated the fight. I felt like shit for making that decision and beating him up since his son was dying, and his behavior was understandable under such a horrible situation; it was especially regrettable considering I went into the situation with that in mind. In the end it really helped develop the relationship between Lee and Kenny in my game though. When Kenny told Lee he was there for him, and that he considered him and Clementine family it was one of the most memorable moments in the game for me. I didn't see that coming for whatever reason, and it came at a time when I felt the most hopeless and desperate that I had ever felt in the game up until that point. It made all the arguing and fighting between Lee and Kenny seem small and petty. In episode five I chose to tell Kenny I was sorry for any pain I had caused him based on what I had said to him back in episode three that had initiated the fight on the train. In the end I think all of that stuff really enhanced my entire experience and created a very strong and realistic feeling bond between Lee and Kenny.
idk, i was bro-team-kenny, and for me to have fought him i would have had to have lee say one of the options to basically initiate the fight. but like i said, i usually did what kenny wanted to do anyways because he thinks like me, kind of.
at first I didn't take cuz I saw the gameplay earlier and though that somehow I would more time with her when I came back from Crawford and that she got taken right after coming from there. I got confused
I don't have the statistics handy, so I don't know if it was a popular choice or not, but I can't imagine there are people that didn't take … moreClem with them into Crawford.
Should have been a 100% take Clem with you statistic.
-Omid might turn
-There's a stalker after her that knows the location of the house
-She's already escaped the house and followed Lee before
-If the group gets captured or killed she's screwed anyway.
Now if the other option was to leave her in the care of the other cancer survivors, then I might have considered it.
I don't know if this is still so one-sided, but back when I played S1 it was really one sided to save Shawn over Duck. I'm not going to lie,… more I also went for Shawn first, but I thought it was unusual to have saving a kid be the unpopular choice.
The huge one-sidedness of Carley over Doug was also odd, but she got waaay more screen time, was on the mission with you, reeked of love interest AND seemed more useful (marksmanship over... mechanical ability? I'm not sure what exactly they were trying to sell Doug as). I expected the choice to be more 50/50 when I first played through though...
I was surprised that it was split with killing the St. John brothers... popular to kill Danny but unpopular to kill Andy? I killed neither but it was strange to me that people were generally willing to kill one but not the other.
I also talked down Kenny on the train, don't know why that was unpopular...
Surprising to me that most players … [view original content]
season 1 yeah let that bitch off herself she was going to die anyways. I killed almost anyone that could've been killed. and I enjoyed it.i didn't kill cray cray woman cuz she was about to spill shit. I wanted to fight Kenny but somehow I calmed him. again killed everone that could be killed.
season two. yea fuck that fucker hope he fucking died of thirst. saved pete liked him. accepted apology. blame myself cuz I wanted to be a lil nice. stayed was scared carver might behead him or something, at the time I was like fuck sarah shes 15, I found out how old she was via wiki. didn't tell bonnie
Oh, I have a lot, I made so many unpopular choices in my playthrough. haha.
season 1:
1.Giving the bitten girl the gun: to take a line … morefrom the game, I was showing mercy.
2.Killing both st john brothers: they were cannibals, I repeat fucking CANNIBALS.
3.Killed Jolene instead of Danny killing her: she was threatening to shoot Lee's balls(lol), and I thought she planned to kidnap Clem.
4.Talked Kenny down on train: I didn't think getting in a fight with him would help at all.
5.Killed the stranger: He kidnapped Clem, and he was crazy. Didn't want to let him kidnap some other innocent girl to "complete" his family.
400 Days:
1.Shot Justin's foot off instead of Danny's: Justin seemed like the kind of guy that would stab you in the back.
2.Killed Stephanie, instead of leaving: Roman's camp had safety, shelter, meds, food, weapons etc. I wasn't about to let that go, and Becca was on her way to being a ruthless killer anyway.
… [view original content]
I killed the stranger and shot him in the head as well, but it's a very hard QTE in comparison to all the others in the game so I don't think most players chose whether or not to choke him to death or let Clementine shoot him on their original play thru. You don't even know the alternative to not choking him to death and it could have easily just lead to the player getting killed. I think it had a lot to do with chance. I would have liked to have seen the stats on how many players chose to shoot him in the head after they choked him though. I had a habit of over doing the button mashing on the QTE so I had no problem choking him in my first game, but after replaying the game later on and realizing that pressing the buttons as rapidly as I did the first time around was completely unnecessary for every QTE in the game up until that moment lead to me seeing Clem shoot him. I was still trying to kill him on that play thru, but I was treating it the same as previous QTE and it didn't work that time around.
Lee killing the Stranger - though I guess I was so drowned in blood lust at that point that I didn't even think that people missed the option because of the disappearing prompt. Guess it wasn't much of a choice.
I killed both of those fuckers and told Clem some people have to die because they are bad. That's how I handled mine too. I did save Duck though. I have a soft spot for kids.
There was no way I was going to let that Season 1 bitten woman shoot herself....first off, because that's my gun and my bullet that I might … moreneed later, second because gunshots are crazy loud!
I saved Shawn over Duck because they made Duck so damned annoying! I think more people would have saved Duck if he'd been less of a weirdo. I was pretty glad when he went away and volunteered to do it myself.
I saved Carley over Doug and think most folks did because it did reek of love interest and that wouldn't have been a bad way to go. Plus she was just waaaayyyy cooler than Doug and seemed more useful to the group.
Not killing the cannibal brothers I don't get at all. THEY. WERE. TRYING. TO. EAT. YOU.
I cut Lee's arm off because I wanted to see how they'd handle doing that in terms of gameplay....I went back and reloaded the save both ways but used one-arm Lee as my final.
Comments
I chose the "I got it" option without second thoughts.
Having him find it by himself would have been way worse than being truthful.
I mean,Ben was kind of a "douche" and he let Clementine alone when they were surrounded by zombies.He did a lot of bad stuff but come on...Let him fall?I think that this is kind of inhumane...
I'm pretty sure more people saved him instead of dropped him 66% actually pulled him up.
I think that's just me though...
I saved Shawn over Duck because they made Duck so damned annoying! I think more people would have saved Duck if he'd been less of a weirdo. I was pretty glad when he went away and volunteered to do it myself.
I saved Carley over Doug and think most folks did because it did reek of love interest and that wouldn't have been a bad way to go. Plus she was just waaaayyyy cooler than Doug and seemed more useful to the group.
Not killing the cannibal brothers I don't get at all. THEY. WERE. TRYING. TO. EAT. YOU.
I cut Lee's arm off because I wanted to see how they'd handle doing that in terms of gameplay....I went back and reloaded the save both ways but used one-arm Lee as my final.
season two. yea fuck that fucker hope he fucking died of thirst. saved pete liked him. accepted apology. blame myself cuz I wanted to be a lil nice. stayed was scared carver might behead him or something, at the time I was like fuck sarah shes 15, I found out how old she was via wiki. didn't tell bonnie