Most difficult decision
What's the most difficult decision you ever had to make in the TWDG?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
What's the most difficult decision you ever had to make in the TWDG?
Comments
what table to sit at.
which side of the face to punch more, the right or the left. (andy)
That was a hard one to me as well.
Save Ben
There was conflict in my head from cold perceptive this guy ruined everything and is ticking time bomb to finish off the rest of the group with his stupidity . After he left Clem to die with the Walkers and didn't look after her my decision was made to kill him at next opportunity he went over the line.
But then morals in my head came into play Ben could die worthless not contributing anything positive to the group he will die a failure everyone deserves a second chance. Then of course he wasn't conscious of the evil he did and was a good kid with bad luck. I also remembered Clem and at this point I already told her never to kill humans just walkers and ben was her friend and needed to set a good example. I had faith in Ben to redeem himself
So I saved him and never taught I ever would when came down to it I can't let a good person die I even try to save Larry despite their mistakes
Monkey wrench, spike remover or spanner.
Why can't I hold all these tools?
Good one. I saved him, But not because of that. I wanted to split his head into two after he left Clementine and after he got Carley killed. But what have always redeemed him to me is that he always tried to help, He's not useless. He jut could use more training of how to handle himself and frankly, The dev team wanted him to look like a shitbird.
when you punch Andy?
yup
I know how you feel, Bro. xD
i was like i'll take the wrench , no the spike remover , no the spanner XD
To me it was Carley Vs Doug. I liked them both. Carley is badass and independent and Doug is a tech geek. Both are Skylar approved.
Do I give everyone a Kenny stache or not?
That's not a choice.
That's an obligation.
Answering if Nick was a good guy or not.
Now to most of you, the answer was probably easy. He's a good guy. But I was so caught up in the moment, only thinking about the bad things that he'd done, that I answered differently.
Yes. I am the 16%.
Actually, I got a better choice.
Who do I give the Kenny stache first?
Obviously I chose Ganon because Waluigi already has a respectable stache.
Damn right
Save or Kill Larry.
This is actually the toughest decision for me. Even though I choose the same choice, it's really complicated. You have Larry this guy who has hated you're guts and could have got you killed. He's been out to make you're life miserable, and now he is having a heart attack. But the thing is you're locked in a room, and if he dies then he turns. If he turns then everyone dies. I always chose to save him because I think it's the more moral choice. My choices have always been based on morality, and sometimes I can be taken aback by emotions.
But this guy was hopeless. Clementine was in the room. I have been thinking about this situation over and over. If Larry died then Clementine could have died, and that wouldn't be good! Protecting Clementine has been my #1 priority. But when it came to this decision, I'm not really sure. Morality or survival? Will you give a part of yourself to survive? That is the question. It's different for most. I believe the statistics was around 60% of players who tried to save Larry. And I'm quite glad this is the case.
I didn't want Clementine to see that, but she did anyway. Like Lee said "God, what does that do to a kid?" It's a really traumatizing event and I doubt she will ever forget it. Not many would forget that terrible situation, and when she remembers it she will remember Lee(Or my Lee) trying to save him. I now feel like morality is my #1 now. Sure I can make some terrible mistakes when I'm angry, but when it comes to saving people, I will always try to save them.
"And I may not have what it takes to last for long, but that's okay. 'Cause at least I can say when the world goes to shit, I didn't let it take me down with it"
I thought about it as i hate the whole S2 group but then decided to let him live. He could be an asset later.
Well, I could say that I 90% disagree with you, But it's just an opinion. I chose to do nothing on that situation. He had to die but i didn't want to lose Lilly's support. But i have my own long reasons and philosophies.
Choosing to go find Kenny or Luke, or to surrender during the A House Divided Finale.
I understand. It is on opinion.
Wait you did nothing? Wouldn't that make them both hate you?
Kenny told me that i was a piece of shit xD but then Lilly told me that we're cool. I actually liked Lilly a bit but after she killed Carley i was like, DIE BITCH!
I chose to surrender because i knew you'll end up in the carver camp anyway, And i was right. But if it really mattered, I'd have gone with Kenny.
Exactly this ^ after Larry tried to kill me with that punch then left me to die also him being an ass*** all the time I couldn't wait to kill him. But what I saw dying was somebody's father the only thing Lily had left also felt guilty because we hated each other. My morals teaching Clem made decisions for me like deciding not to steal and killing Stjohns etc without Clem I would steal all day and kill but she didn't want to and was right plus never wanted to become the killer the group expected of me wanted to kill walkers to show Clem can keep your morals and survive
I'm moist
I actually had a different view, I wanted Clem to be S2's Clem as she is right now. I killed The St. johns in order not to let them kill or torture anyone else, Clementine has to understand that very well in order to survive. That's sometimes, You just have to ignore morality. Which i don't really believe in.
I'm all up for rambo Clem to but it's easy to lose yourself if you throw morals out the window and not treasure what separates you from the walkers. She will make the hard decisions but most not lose herself to the evil of ZA
To me It's not throwing yourself away, I'm personally a self-proclaimed Chaotic-neutral. Which means i don't have regard to morality. My regard is to the people i deem worthy. Clementine has earned a high priority in my S1's walkthrough because she can stand for herself. Every situation that happens to every character is considered throw their actions and the circumstances before taking action. Not throw morality to me.
Verdict: I create my own morality. That's what i wanted to teach Clem.
In s2 I agree just S1 as Lee I will throw morality out the window to protect Clem but when I feel circumstance is unnecessary violence and a opportunity to teach Clem lessons she needs to learn I will if I make Clem heartless what a life that would be consumed by evil and hate without morals.
TLOU SPOILER
I'm the same Like when I agreed with Joel with Ellie in TLOU he murdered whole hospital of innocent people just to save her and damned the human race if I deem someone worthy I will sacrifice all morals to save and protect them to every time no matter the sacrifice required If was a choice I would of done same thing
Not exactly my point. My point is that I'm not supposed to be everyone's guardian angel. People have to take care of themselves. But if i ran into a situation where i can help a character that earned my admiration, I'd surely do it. This is not heartlessness. And the word "Protect" isn't really my type. That's why i like Carley/Molly/Jane/Clem. I admire people who are resourceful even in a young age, I treated Clementine very well and never spoke to her aggressively.
Am I wrong to think that Larry did not have to be killed as fast as Kenny did? Granted if he turned it would be problematic but 1. He was already on the floor and as big as he is it would take longer for him to move around 2. There was enough saltlick to pin him down, if he turned then drop one on his head. 3. It is not really your decision to kill him before he turns since Lily was there.
Only thing I'll say is Kat and Duck were held in a separate place so Kenny had selfish reasons to get out of there quickly.
Choosing to bring Clem to Crawford or not. I ended up choosing to bring her and I'm glad I did.
Took the spanner bro.
That's actually what I was going to say. :P Season 2 at least, it might have been the most difficult so far.
Well, Kenny's selfishness has always bugged me ever since Episode 2 of Season 1. But Larry had to die.
And it proved one thing, Clem is better shooter than i am. I stood there carefully trying not to misshot Molly, While she took him down with one shot.
Believe it or not, for me the Most difficult decision of the game was choosing who should be the one to shot the boy in the attic.
I did already make Kenny shot his own son, because in my opinion it was the right thing to do. Kenny needs to be strong and be able to leave his past behind. But then, only 1episode later,Telltale brings this heart breaking scene. I decided that Kenny should also be the one that shots the boy in the attic. But please believe me, it wasn't an easy decision for me.
Whether to let the girl shoot herself, because in a way your offering someone the chance to commit suicide. It's such a dark choice to make.
How about giving Chet dat Kenny Stache.
Kenny's selfishness bugged me until Episode 3 of Season 2, after which he became one of my favourite characters again. Fuckin' radio beater.