i think the OP meant realism as in with human characters and not the walkers,i can nitpick and say it's been moved along a faster pace than … morei would of liked,and the characters have not been fully fleshed out,but the actual episodes have been great. I really hope Amid the Ruins doesn't dissapoint,as it's had the mystery around from the get go.
i think the OP meant realism as in with human characters and not the walkers,i can nitpick and say it's been moved along a faster pace than i would of liked,and the characters have not been fully fleshed out,but the actual episodes have been great. I really hope Amid the Ruins doesn't dissapoint,as it's had the mystery around from the get go.
Not really strict realism. It is just the word many of us associate with character consistency and logic, which is what the OP is talking about. Sorry for the condescending response.
There were just as many in season 1, All fictions especially zombie ones have things that dont make complete sense but there you go. They never really bother me
@Clemmy1 wrote:
i think the OP meant realism as in with human characters and not the walkers,i can nitpick and say it's been moved al… moreong a faster pace than i would of liked,and the characters have not been fully fleshed out,but the actual episodes have been great. I really hope Amid the Ruins doesn't dissapoint,as it's had the mystery around from the get go.
Not really strict realism. It is just the word many of us associate with character consistency and logic, which is what the OP is talking about. Sorry for the condescending response.
*
**Omid and Christa leaving Clementine alone***- Not unrealistic, Christa needed room for herself since she was pregnant and all. And don't forget Omid did come in to check on Clem.
Clementine not being smart enough to take the gun with her- Really ? For the long three steps she was taking it seemed fair enough to leave the gun.
Here now I know the world in this universe is fucked up but i don't think in reality Michelle would be as rough to Clementine as she did with her only being nine years old- She was an asshole, she just wanted stuff and she did feel bad when she shot Omid so she wasn't going to actually shoot Clem.
Clementine not drowning or getting hypothermia or at least commenting on the coldNot unrealistic either, she does fold her arms so she shows she is cold. The unrealistic thing is that her hat never comes off.
**A doctor not knowing the difference between a dog bite and walker bite **Yeah that was stupid.
Instead of washing the bloody walker knife she rubs it against her pants then uses it to open food and then continues to eat the food- She was hungry and she got all the blood off, don't know what more you want
Luke and the rest of the group doesn't know how a dog bite looks Again yeah this is stupid.
Sarah being....Sarah ( No she's not autistic, she's highly sheltered, but still..) I have no idea how this is unrealistic...
How the hell did an eleven year old girl withstand the pain of horribly stitching herself She was in a lot of pain doing it so again I disagree with this.
**The sudden personality change with Carlos and Rebecca **Carlos? I don't think he changed that much, Rebecca was weird but I assume it is due to some story changes between episodes.
**The odds of finding Kenny ( I love Kenny, he's my favorite character, but I doubt in real life Clem and Kenny would of ever found eachother ) **They were both heading North like a lot of people according to Matthew so I don't think this is unrealistic either.
Carlos not knowing how to grab a Key and twist it to stop the wind turbine. **Yeah that was dumb as well ha
** Carlos letting Clementine turn off the wind turbine. Well Clem did say she would do it so...
Carlos telling Clementine the adults are talking after everything she's done for the group.- I must have missed this, when does it happen?
A day or two after saying that to her Carlos doesn't mind letting her go fucking mission impossible style sneaking on the roof and getting the radio and somehow Tavia did not notice this happening in front of her. No-one else was light enough Clem had to do it and Tavia just missing it isn't unrealistic either.
**I understand she just lost her father, screaming once would of been acceptable in my book, but then she screams again, and again, in a horde of walkers... **Sarah has been sheltered through the entire thing and the one person she really cared about just died. So no
If Sarita survives the amputation that's breaking Kirkman's rules, that hatchet had walker blood on it. Except we don't know what will happen so this is a bit of a stupid point. I mean if Lee lived without cutting his arm off that would be against the rules.
So overall I think you are just being really picky, I would agree that Season 1 was better written but I disagree with most of this.
@Clemmy1 wrote:
i think the OP meant realism as in with human characters and not the walkers,i can nitpick and say it's been moved al… moreong a faster pace than i would of liked,and the characters have not been fully fleshed out,but the actual episodes have been great. I really hope Amid the Ruins doesn't dissapoint,as it's had the mystery around from the get go.
Not really strict realism. It is just the word many of us associate with character consistency and logic, which is what the OP is talking about. Sorry for the condescending response.
You're only criticising and quite a few are valid points. Yes this is a game and no you can't expect a game like this to be totally realistic, but I understand where you're coming from.
My biggest bugbear for example was the dog incident. To me that was crossing the line and just violent for the sake of it. Same goes for Carver in some respects. I do understand that the game writers want to make this game popular and entertaining, but they shouldn't have to cross the line or be violent for the sake of it to achieve that. I believe the writers are better than that. So personally i'm glad that Carver was killed off. Perhaps now in future we will have a good story concentrating on Clementines survival, not her or her friends trying beat the living sh*t out of people.
Thing is, if you dare to criticise the game. Even with valid points, you are going to get some that will defend it to the hilt. Even though they know you are correct. As I said before, if you dare to think differently you are punished.
Depends on the agent causing the infection. In some fictional zombie worlds, the virus (or other agent) that causes people to become zombies also causes their flesh to become toxic to bacteria, insects, carrion birds, and other things which would otherwise break down the body.
Its a zombie game. How realistic do you want it? If you wanted it 100% realistic we should remove the zombies.
Another unrealistic thing, … moreif a zombie apocalypse was to happen, it wouldn't last three years.
Rotting corpses walking around for three years? How long does meat in your fridge last?
And that's in your fridge, not exposed to changing temperatures and conditions. Now imagine that happening to a human. Yep. Wont last long.
The game is completely unrealistic. Everything about the game is unrealistic.
But that doesn't you all from playing it. Stop picking faults, relax and enjoy the game.
That's what its there for, enjoyment.
You're only criticising and quite a few are valid points. Yes this is a game and no you can't expect a game like this to be totally realist… moreic, but I understand where you're coming from.
My biggest bugbear for example was the dog incident. To me that was crossing the line and just violent for the sake of it. Same goes for Carver in some respects. I do understand that the game writers want to make this game popular and entertaining, but they shouldn't have to cross the line or be violent for the sake of it to achieve that. I believe the writers are better than that. So personally i'm glad that Carver was killed off. Perhaps now in future we will have a good story concentrating on Clementines survival, not her or her friends trying beat the living sh*t out of people.
Thing is, if you dare to criticise the game. Even with valid points, you are going to get some that will defend it to the hilt. Even though they know you are correct. As I said before, if you dare to think differently you are punished.
HAHAHAH the whole zombie apocalypse thing itself is unrealistic but that's another topic..Haha..you wanna get realistic with me son? Also the only annoying thing I agreed with you on was "A doctor not knowing the difference between a dog bite and walker bite" like really..the jaw line...where did Carlos get his doc degree from again? Stitching doll arms?
Comments
Yeah, that's what i meant.
Heavy Sigh
She knows what she's doing.
....Are you SURE you mean battery?
What?
I assume he's referring to the cutter thingy.
EDIT: Blowtorch.
Not really strict realism. It is just the word many of us associate with character consistency and logic, which is what the OP is talking about. Sorry for the condescending response.
Season 1 was SUPER unrealistic. You could shove a plank and a blowtorch up your pants.
Oh, wish he was more specific...thanks for clearing that up
Lee did carry a car battery in his pocket in Ep4 of TWD.
And some at his parents' drugstore...
What? Molly's battery and yeah the blowtorch too.
Huh? Didn't he put it in Molly's backpack?
wat
She gave it back to him and he put it in his pocket.
Batteries for a portable radio are a lot different than batteries for a car lol
*
**Omid and Christa leaving Clementine alone***- Not unrealistic, Christa needed room for herself since she was pregnant and all. And don't forget Omid did come in to check on Clem.
Clementine not being smart enough to take the gun with her- Really ? For the long three steps she was taking it seemed fair enough to leave the gun.
Here now I know the world in this universe is fucked up but i don't think in reality Michelle would be as rough to Clementine as she did with her only being nine years old- She was an asshole, she just wanted stuff and she did feel bad when she shot Omid so she wasn't going to actually shoot Clem.
Clementine not drowning or getting hypothermia or at least commenting on the coldNot unrealistic either, she does fold her arms so she shows she is cold. The unrealistic thing is that her hat never comes off.
**A doctor not knowing the difference between a dog bite and walker bite **Yeah that was stupid.
Instead of washing the bloody walker knife she rubs it against her pants then uses it to open food and then continues to eat the food- She was hungry and she got all the blood off, don't know what more you want
Luke and the rest of the group doesn't know how a dog bite looks Again yeah this is stupid.
Sarah being....Sarah ( No she's not autistic, she's highly sheltered, but still..) I have no idea how this is unrealistic...
How the hell did an eleven year old girl withstand the pain of horribly stitching herself She was in a lot of pain doing it so again I disagree with this.
**The sudden personality change with Carlos and Rebecca **Carlos? I don't think he changed that much, Rebecca was weird but I assume it is due to some story changes between episodes.
**The odds of finding Kenny ( I love Kenny, he's my favorite character, but I doubt in real life Clem and Kenny would of ever found eachother ) **They were both heading North like a lot of people according to Matthew so I don't think this is unrealistic either.
Carlos not knowing how to grab a Key and twist it to stop the wind turbine. **Yeah that was dumb as well ha
**
Carlos letting Clementine turn off the wind turbine. Well Clem did say she would do it so...
Carlos telling Clementine the adults are talking after everything she's done for the group.- I must have missed this, when does it happen?
A day or two after saying that to her Carlos doesn't mind letting her go fucking mission impossible style sneaking on the roof and getting the radio and somehow Tavia did not notice this happening in front of her. No-one else was light enough Clem had to do it and Tavia just missing it isn't unrealistic either.
**I understand she just lost her father, screaming once would of been acceptable in my book, but then she screams again, and again, in a horde of walkers... **Sarah has been sheltered through the entire thing and the one person she really cared about just died. So no
If Sarita survives the amputation that's breaking Kirkman's rules, that hatchet had walker blood on it. Except we don't know what will happen so this is a bit of a stupid point. I mean if Lee lived without cutting his arm off that would be against the rules.
So overall I think you are just being really picky, I would agree that Season 1 was better written but I disagree with most of this.
yeah cause we all know the definitions of strict realism and just plain old realism xDDDD
You're only criticising and quite a few are valid points. Yes this is a game and no you can't expect a game like this to be totally realistic, but I understand where you're coming from.
My biggest bugbear for example was the dog incident. To me that was crossing the line and just violent for the sake of it. Same goes for Carver in some respects. I do understand that the game writers want to make this game popular and entertaining, but they shouldn't have to cross the line or be violent for the sake of it to achieve that. I believe the writers are better than that. So personally i'm glad that Carver was killed off. Perhaps now in future we will have a good story concentrating on Clementines survival, not her or her friends trying beat the living sh*t out of people.
Thing is, if you dare to criticise the game. Even with valid points, you are going to get some that will defend it to the hilt. Even though they know you are correct. As I said before, if you dare to think differently you are punished.
Depends on the agent causing the infection. In some fictional zombie worlds, the virus (or other agent) that causes people to become zombies also causes their flesh to become toxic to bacteria, insects, carrion birds, and other things which would otherwise break down the body.
End result -- zombies can persist for years.
Thinking differently does not automatically make him immune to any sort of criticism, either.
What's with the double stardard?
HAHAHAH the whole zombie apocalypse thing itself is unrealistic but that's another topic..Haha..you wanna get realistic with me son? Also the only annoying thing I agreed with you on was "A doctor not knowing the difference between a dog bite and walker bite" like really..the jaw line...where did Carlos get his doc degree from again? Stitching doll arms?
Clem and the wind turbine was unrealistic, apart from that it's ok.
Alvin getting shot in the heart, comes back and shoots the guy and dies again.
Funny how she managed to jump to another building with a car battery in her backpack.