The Telltale forums are now read only. Past posts will stay available to browse, but new posts and replies have moved to our official Discord.

Join the conversation on Discord

Clementine's Fate

edited November 2012 in The Walking Dead
Now, before people go nuts: I LOVE CLEMENTINE. Remember that before going to town on me.

Does anyone else think killing off Clementine and Lee would've been a better ending? Or more emotional and memorable rather?



HEAR ME OUT!


I mean, now we have this cliffhanger ending and I don't know where the series is gonna go or how it will incorporate past characters. I figure, if they were going to kill one of the two stars, they might as well had killed both and started from scratch.

I mean, how would they even go about bringing up what Lee did around Clem to new characters without painstakingly trying to write it in. Either they do a writer's copout and have Clem vaguely mention Lee and never become specific on his actions around her or they'll try to incorporate your decisions only to write themselves in to a corner like they did in Episodes 4 and 5. And that leads to plotholes. And I hate plotholes.

New cast. New location. New scenarios.

Comments

  • edited November 2012
    That would have been too sad. Maybe only acceptable if they had no plans for Clem in season 2. It kind of looks like they do.
  • edited November 2012
    Dildor wrote: »
    That would have been too sad. Maybe only acceptable if they had no plans for Clem in season 2. It kind of looks like they do.

    I wish they didn't have plans for Clem. I like her as a character, but let's move on.
  • edited November 2012
    No, we want more Clem. This hasnt been enough. Wait a while. The last game they do should have her death.
  • edited November 2012
    Of course there's a third scenario - new group... that meets clem/omid/christa and then after an episode or two they part ways.....

    That gives people some closure, while allowing for a new storyline.
  • edited November 2012
    Clem was okay for the first season, but they should try harder to pull my strings. A cute little girl who screems for protection is a little too cheap in the long run.
  • edited November 2012
    But this is a rare experience and to try again would be just "Oh boring Telltale doing ot again'
    They have an opertunity and they can build more love for clem and I hope the TV show adapts her. Shes that great and could be a charecter to befriend Carl and his new born sister.
    Imagine the emotion finding Clem if that is continued in TWD S4 of finding a scared Clem whos lost so much. The right actress and this would really take a great TV moment
  • edited November 2012
    I hope the TV show adapts her.

    problem being that the voice actress is a white lady in her late 30s...

    If they were going to kill both of them, i'd much rather they just kept both alive instead.

    i'd have been happy with a happy lee/clem ending and a new bunch in S2.
  • edited November 2012
    Thats what I mean... IF tv did it they would need a kid with a simlar voice and atleast a bit look like Clem.
This discussion has been closed.